Abstract:Motivated by the magnitude of discrepancies that are typically encountered in blind analysis contests between numerical model predictions and test data, a methodology is presented to incorporate modeling uncertainties in the assessment of capacity-designed steel moment-resisting frames (MRFs) under earthquake loading. Sources of modeling uncertainties are identified in order to define a set of variables that control the seismic response of steel MRFs. For each variable, statistical distributions that rely on experimental databases are deduced. Special attention is paid to the truncation limits to enable the generation of individual parameter samples that have an actual physical meaning. Besides strength modification factors for various steel grades, distributions are offered for the parameters that are used to model wide-flange (composite) beams, steel hollow structural section columns and damping. Both intracomponent and intercomponent interdependencies are explicitly discussed in an attempt to propose correlation coefficients that comply with the current design philosophy and construction sequence. Although the focus is strictly on collapse of capacity-designed steel MRFs, the proposed methodology can be utilized to examine less severe limit states and/or existing structures where capacity-design principles do not necessarily apply. A 4-story steel MRF, tested full-scale at the E-Defense facility to collapse, is employed as a case study to demonstrate the applicability of the proposed methodology. It is shown that although the steel MRF examined is insensitive to modeling uncertainties regarding both collapse and story mechanism prediction, local response parameters can vary considerably versus the ones observed during the test. Through a parametric investigation on the strong-column-weak-beam (SCWB) ratio, the parameters that have an impact on the associated predictions are identified. Implications for capacity design, collapse capacity and residual drift are also discussed, highlighting the benefits that higher SCWB ratios can have on seismic response.

Modeling and Response Prediction in Performance-Based Seismic Evaluation: Case Studies of Instrumented Steel Moment-Frame Buildings

Effect of nonlinear modeling approaches used for composite elements on seismic behavior of composite framed buildings

Instrumental Assessment of the Predictive Capability of Nonlinear Static Analysis Procedures for Seismic Evaluation of Buildings

A Critical Evaluation of the Coefficient Method, Capacity Spectrum Method and Modal Pushover Analysis for Irregular Steel Buildings in Seismic Zones

Performance Comparisons of Seismic Assessment Methods with PSD Test Results of a Deficient RC Frame

Impact of Probabilistic Modeling Alternatives on the Seismic Fragility Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Dual Wall–Frame Buildings towards Resilient Designs

A hybrid model-data method for seismic response reconstruction of instrumented buildings

Using image-based inspection data to improve response predictions of earthquake-damaged unreinforced masonry buildings

Incremental dynamic analysis and FEMA P695 seismic performance evaluation of a cold‐formed steel–framed building with gravity framing and architectural sheathing

Performance-based post-earthquake decision making for instrumented buildings

Influence of the modelling approach on the seismic assessment of RC structures by nonlinear static analyses

Incorporating Modeling Uncertainties in the Collapse Assessment of Capacity-Designed Steel Moment Frames under Seismic Loading

Assessment of the Impact on Steel Walls and Bracing Systems in the Analysis of Seismic Waves during a Building Moment Resistance Frame

A comparative study of concentrated plasticity models in dynamic analysis of building structures

Seismic response of non-structural components in multi-storey steel frames

Fragility-Based Performance Evaluation of Asymmetric Single-Story Buildings in Near Field and Far Field Earthquakes

An efficient method based on shear models for structural seismic response prediction considering hysteretic characteristics

Comparative Assessment of Performance-Based Design Methodologies Applied to a R.C. Shear-Wall Building

Seismic Damage Assessment of Instrumented Wood-frame Buildings: A Case-study of NEESWood Full-scale Shake Table Tests

Seismic Performance Evaluation Using Nonlinear Time History Analysis with Three-Dimensional Structural Model for a Hybrid Frame-Core Tube Structure

A Performance-Based Design Approach for Rectangular Concrete-Filled Steel Tube (RCFT) Frames under Seismic Loading