Towards what end? Collective bargaining and the making and unmaking of the working class

Zaad Mahmood,Supurna Banerjee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0143831X221096863
2022-06-02
Economic and Industrial Democracy
Abstract:Economic and Industrial Democracy, Ahead of Print. In contemporary literature, bargaining is often construed as an instrument in the hands of the employer, a practice that is sustained by undermining worker solidarity and promoting interests of privileged unionized workers at the expense of other workers. This article challenges such narratives by foregrounding the idea of solidarity and highlighting the complex interplay of solidarity emanating from the multiple ways consciousness about worker identity plays out. Drawing on the literature on new social movements (NSM) and industrial relations (IR), the article shows that the relevance of bargaining is not merely confined to instrumental economic goals but extends to politically constitutive action. In the process of bargaining the political agency of workers and distinctive articulations of solidarity are identified. This article presents and classifies three kinds of solidarity that correspond to the three dimensions of political consciousness, namely critical solidarity, limited solidarity and absent solidarity across cases that are shaped by contextual realities of labour politics.
industrial relations & labor
What problem does this paper attempt to address?