"Bringing Workers Back In: Native-Place Networks, Solidarity, and Labor Standards in China"

Enying Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5465/ambpp.2013.136

2013-01-01

Academy of Management Proceedings

Abstract:Drawing on prior literature on labor standards, social networks, and industrial relations in China, I argue that given the weak union tradition there, alternative organizational bases for workers’ mobilization and solidarity in local contexts have become an important factor for improving labor standards. Using a mixed method, including 54 in-depth interviews and a unique survey of 105 firms and 1,270 workers in these firms, this article specifies two findings: 1) despite the ever-increasing top-down regulatory efforts by the state and multinational corporations (MNCs), exploitative labor relations still exist as approximately ten percent of surveyed workers reported the experiences of labor abuses; only 53 percent of surveyed firms paid above minimum wages; and 2) the unique native-place networks among rural-to-urban migrant workers are a primary source of solidarity and have been crucial to preventing labor abuses; however, similar to immigrants’ ethnic enclaves in the U.S. and European contexts or the general paradox of embeddedness (Uzzi 1997), an overreliance on native-place networks reduces their salaries, suggesting an inverted U-shaped relationship between workers’ solidarity and their economic opportunities. This article contributes to a new perspective of labor standards by shifting analytic lens onto informal social organization of workers and their solidarity.