Abstract:As the diversity of people in higher education grows, Universities are struggling to provide inclusive environments that nurture the spirit of free inquiry in the presence of these differences. At the extreme, the value of diversity is under attack as a few, vocal academics use public forums to question the innate intellectual abilities of certain demographic groups. Throughout my career as an astronomer, from graduate student, through professor to department chair, I have witnessed these struggles firsthand. Exclusive cultures result in lost opportunities in the form of unfulfilled potential of all members of the institution - students, administrators and faculty alike. How to move steadily towards inclusion is an unsolved problem that hampers the advancement of knowledge itself. As every scientist knows, problem definition is an essential feature of problem solution. This article draws on insights from dynamical systems descriptions of conflict developed in the social and behavioral sciences to present a model that captures the convoluted, interacting challenges that stifle progress on this problem. This description of complexity explains the persistence of exclusive cultures and the inadequacy of quick or simple fixes. It also motivates the necessity of prolonged and multifaceted approaches to solutions. It is incumbent on our faculties to recognize the complexities in both problem and solutions, and persevere in responding to these intractable dynamics. It is incumbent on our administrations to provide the consistent structure that supports these tasks. It incumbent on all of our constituents - students, administration and faculty - to be cognizant of and responsive to these efforts.

The dark side of moral outrage: Understanding the risks to long-term, meaningful community development work in higher learning

Good students & bad activists: The moral economy of campus unrest

Critical Practice for Challenging Times: Social Workers' Engagement with Community Work

‘Moral distress’ and the beginning practitioner: preparing social work students for ethical and moral challenges in contemporary contexts

Ethical and Transformative Scholarly Public Engagement: Pitfalls, Possibilities and Promises

Pushing against a future dark side for community development: An editorial call to action

Dialogic Problematization of Academic Integrity Education

Moral outrage: social workers in the Third Space

Complicating Narratives: Defining and Deconstructing Ethical Challenges in Community Psychology

Community Building in Social Justice Work: A Critical Approach

Addressing the Dark Side of Leadership in the University System Using Community of Practice (CoP) Approach

Empowering students to confront environmental injustice: Dialogue, theory, empathy, and partnership

Finding ways (and words) to move: Mad student politics and practices of loneliness

Creating a sustainable action-oriented engagement infrastructure-a UMN-MIDB perspective

Caring, Courage and Curiosity: Reflections on our roles as scholars in organizing for a sustainable future

Epistemic Justice as a "New Normal?" Interrogating the Contributions of Communities of Practice to Decolonization of Knowledge

Problematize, Theorize, Politicize, and Contextualize: A Social Justice Framework for Postsecondary Integrated Reading and Writing Instruction

Engaging Impasse: Nurturing a Culture of Dialogic Engagement on a University Campus

“Reclaiming My Time” Amid Organizational Change: A Dialectical Approach to Support the Thriving and Career Development for Faculty at the Margins

Campus Culture Wars and the Sociology of Morality

A Dynamical Systems Description of Privilege, Power and Leadership in Academia: identifying barriers and paths to inclusive communities of excellent scholarship