Corporate cultures. Turning "us versus them" into "we"

J L Sherer

1994-05-05

Abstract:Health care executives are coming around to the philosophy that shared values--and shared corporate culture--represent the number one success factor in any merger. In fact, studies have documented merger failures in cases in which corporate culture issues have been ignored. The question is: How can executives--and organizations--overcome the cultural obstacles?

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Mergers and acquisitions process: the use of corporate culture analysis

Yaakov Weber,Shlomo Yedidia Tarba

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/13527601211247053

2012-07-27

Cross Cultural Management: An International Journal

Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this paper is to advance cross‐cultural management during mergers and acquisitions (M&A), an issue that remains poorly understood despite a large body of literature accumulated over many years of study and experience. Design/methodology/approach Based on literature review and case studies of both successful and unsuccessful companies, this paper clarifies the concept, the assessment and the use of corporate culture and its dimensions during all mergers and acquisitions stages, and as such shows its role as an important and influential milestone in the international business environment exploration. Findings The paper arrives at the conclusion that the enduring paradox of the high rate of M&A failure vs the growing activity of M&A may be due to lack of synchronized activities of all merger stages. Practical implications The paper presents frameworks and managerial tools that can help researchers and practitioners conduct better corporate culture assessment during all stages of the M&A, including screening, planning, and negotiation, and enhance the effectiveness of interventions carried out during post‐merger integration process. Originality/value The paper offers insights into corporate culture and its impact during pre‐merger stage, negotiation, and the post‐merger integration process.
The Impact of Leadership and Change Management Strategy on Organizational Culture and Individual Acceptance of Change during a Merger

Marie H. Kavanagh,Neal M. Ashkanasy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8551.2006.00480.x

IF: 5.6

2006-03-01

British Journal of Management

Abstract:This article reports a longitudinal study that examined mergers between three large multi‐site public‐sector organizations. Both qualitative and quantitative methods of analysis are used to examine the effect of leadership and change management strategies on acceptance of cultural change by individuals. Findings indicate that in many cases the change that occurs as a result of a merger is imposed on the leaders themselves, and it is often the pace of change that inhibits the successful re‐engineering of the culture. In this respect, the success or otherwise of any merger hinges on individual perceptions about the manner in which the process is handled and the direction in which the culture is moved. Communication and a transparent change process are important, as this will often determine not only how a leader will be regarded, but who will be regarded as a leader. Leaders need to be competent and trained in the process of transforming organizations to ensure that individuals within the organization accept the changes prompted by a merger.

management,business
When cultures collide: the challenge of global integration

Charlotte D. Shelton,Richard F. Hall,John R. Darling

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/09555340310493036

2003-10-01

European Business Review

Abstract:The past two decades have been characterized as a time of merger mania. Unprecedented numbers of consolidations have occurred. Paradoxically these mergers have typically failed to achieve the targeted results. From a general point of view, the financial track record of recent mergers is, in fact, abysmal. It appears that the proposed efficiencies of scale often do not materialize. Yet, the merger frenzy continues. Globalization is a contributing factor. However, the cultural, political, psychological and geographical hurdles of cross‐cultural integration are enormous. This article explores the challenge of global integration by examining the much‐publicized DaimlerChrysler merger. The authors discuss innovative integration strategies and present a set of quantum skills that can be used to neutralize cross‐cultural barriers, thus enabling global leaders to create high performance organizations.

English Else
Corporate Culture

Gary B. Gorton,Jillian Grennan,Alexander Zentefis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3928972

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Corporate culture is an omnibus term that includes many elements like norms, values, knowledge, and customs that are relevant to a firm. Economists have made great progress recentlyin devising methods of measuring different aspects of corporate culture. These empirical measures of culture have explained mergers and acquisitions, corporate risk-taking, and unethicalbehaviors observed in corporations, among other topics. We argue that unpacking corporateculture into its components is the right way to research it empirically. Theories of corporateculture are still in development, and we discuss the major contributions thus far. We argue that atheory of the firm and of corporate decision-making that is based on corporate culture is moregermane to the practical realities of firms’ inner workings than prevailing theories based onagency costs. Corporate culture has the potential to set the theoretical paradigm for all corporatefinance research.
Culture Change Requires Personal and Organizational Changes: Lessons from the Shared Equity Leadership Model

Adrianna Kezar,Elizabeth Holcombe,Jordan Harper,Natsumi Ueda

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00091383.2023.2151806

2023-02-03

Change: The Magazine of Higher Learning

Abstract:In Short This article presents a model of shared equity leadership that helps transform campus cultures so that students, faculty, staff, and administrators from all backgrounds experience greater inclusion and ameliorates equity gaps. The key to success is the combination of personal- and organizational-level changes that create a critical mass of employees dedicated to the work of diversity, equity, and inclusion. The findings also showed that each faculty, staff and administrator must first turn inwards and do their own personal work in order to then turn outwards to transform their institutions. Organizational-level changes (such as hiring diverse leaders, revising reward and incentive structures, and expanding accountability systems to include a focus on DEI) were simultaneously enacted as campus change agents worked on their personal journeys.
Cultural change that sticks

Jon R Katzenbach,Ilona Steffen,Caroline Kronley

Abstract:When a major change initiative runs aground, leaders often blame their company's culture for pushing it off course. They try to forge ahead by overhauling the culture--a tactic that tends to fizzle, fail, or backfire. Most cultures are too well entrenched to be jettisoned. The secret is to stop fighting your culture--and to work with and within it, until it evolves in the right direction. Today's best-performing companies, such as Southwest Airlines, Apple, and the Four Seasons, understand this, say the authors, three consultants from Booz & Company. These organizations follow five principles for making the most of their cultures: 1. Match strategy to culture. Culture trumps strategy every time, no matter how brilliant the plan, so the two need to be in alignment. 2. Focus on a few critical shifts in behavior. Wholesale change is hard; choose your battles wisely. 3. Honor the strengths of the existing culture. Every culture is the product of good intentions and has strengths; put them to use. 4. Integrate formal and informal interventions. Don't just implement new rules and processes; identify "influencers" who can bring other employees along. 5. Measure and monitor cultural evolution. Otherwise you can't identify backsliding or correct course. When the leaders of Aetna applied these rules while implementing a new strategy in the early 2000s, they reinvigorated the company's ailing culture and restored employee pride. That shift was reflected in the business results, as Aetna went from a $300 million loss to a $1.7 billion gain.
Corporate identity and corporate communications: the antidote to merger madness

John M.T. Balmer,Keith Dinnie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/13563289910299300

1999-12-01

Corporate Communications: An International Journal

Abstract:This article examines the potential relevance of corporate identity and corporate communication to the merger and acquisition process. Recent studies indicate that around 50 per cent of all mergers failed to produce the synergistic benefits that were expected of them. The authors argue that this failure rate may be attributable to the neglect of corporate identity and corporate communication issues and have identified nine reasons why mergers fail, chief among which are: the undue attention that is given to short‐term financial and legal issues to the detriment of long‐term identity and communication issues; inadequate recognition of the impact of leadership issues on identity and communication; and failure to secure the goodwill of a wide range of stakeholder groups common to both companies. The authors offer a template pertaining to corporate identity and corporate communication issues in the merger and acquisition process which they call the merger mix.
Using the framework of corporate culture in "mergers" to support the development of a cultural basis for integrative medicine - guidance for building an integrative medicine department or service

Claudia M Witt,Marion Pérard,Brian Berman,Susan Berman,Timothy C Birdsall,Horst Defren,Sherko Kümmel,Gary Deng,Gustav Dobos,Atje Drexler,Christine Holmberg,Markus Horneber,Robert Jütte,Lori Knutson,Christopher Kummer,Susanne Volpers,David Schweiger

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S66778

2015-01-19

Abstract:Background: An increasing number of clinics offer complementary or integrative medicine services; however, clear guidance about how complementary medicine could be successfully and efficiently integrated into conventional health care settings is still lacking. Combining conventional and complementary medicine into integrative medicine can be regarded as a kind of merger. In a merger, two or more organizations - usually companies - are combined into one in order to strengthen the companies financially and strategically. The corporate culture of both merger partners has an important influence on the integration. Purpose: The aim of this project was to transfer the concept of corporate culture in mergers to the merging of two medical systems. Methods: A two-step approach (literature analyses and expert consensus procedure) was used to develop practical guidance for the development of a cultural basis for integrative medicine, based on the framework of corporate culture in "mergers," which could be used to build an integrative medicine department or integrative medicine service. Results: Results include recommendations for general strategic dimensions (definition of the medical model, motivation for integration, clarification of the available resources, development of the integration team, and development of a communication strategy), and recommendations to overcome cultural differences (the clinic environment, the professional language, the professional image, and the implementation of evidence-based medicine). Conclusion: The framework of mergers in corporate culture provides an understanding of the difficulties involved in integrative medicine projects. The specific recommendations provide a good basis for more efficient implementation.
Creating Corporate Culture: a study of strategies employed to cultivate High Performance Mentality within Sony Ericsson

Frendberg Elin

Abstract:The current expansion of mergers and acquisitions forces new postmerged organizational cultures to take form, and requires solid strategies for handling that procedure. Research indicate that at least half of all mergers fail in creating expected synergies, and that the reason for failing is assumed integration issues such as culture clashes. Creating a strong organizational culture is often appointed a principal factor for managing a post-merged situation. This study focuses on analyzing the acculturation process of Sony Ericsson, challenged by fusing Japanese and Swedish companies into a joint venture. The purpose is defining which criteria govern the strategic process of creating corporate culture in order for this to illuminate possible future problems. By applying an interpretative approach, with certain descriptive elements, I propose to illustrate the concepts of organizations and cultures as being process-based rather than structured systems. On analyzing the case in light of theoretical discussions and earlier research, three statements connected to post-merger success emerged: 1)Organizational type marginally affects the ability of creating a strong corporate culture 2)Merger type affects the ability of creating a strong corporate culture to a certain extent 3)Integration process extensively affects the ability of creating a strong corporate culture Creating corporate values strongly connected to the employees? private norms was also found essential to succeeding in creating a strong culture. This further involves the need for providing a combination of top-down and bottom-up strategies on creating a long-term corporate culture.

Business
The Importance of Culture: Why Leadership, Diversity, and Safety Matter

Julie E Adams,Erica Taylor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hcl.2024.05.007

Abstract:Organization culture and ethical behavior are clearly important in creating an environment conducive to high-quality care for patients. As surgeons, we have a duty to our patients, colleagues and profession, as well as society at large, to uphold values that promote a safe, just and equitable workplace. This article explores concepts associated with leadership, diversity, and patient care.
Tips From the Iceberg: Effecting Culture Change in Health Care Teams

D. Matthew Sherrer,Brooke R. Vining,Martha Anne Rich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/jmq.0000000000000198

2024-08-29

American Journal of Medical Quality

Abstract:For centuries, fables have been used as teaching aids that bring simple lessons to life through storytelling. The extensive research of John Kotter has been distilled into fable form in the book "Our Iceberg is Melting." Here, we will describe an instance of applying Kotter's eight-step model to overcome relational tension between anesthesiologists and nurse anesthetists and a resultant culture of collaboration at 2 of the authors' academic medical centers.

health care sciences & services
Corporate culture as a theory of the firm

Gary B. Gorton,Alexander K. Zentefis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ecca.12537

2024-06-09

Economica

Abstract:Markets and firms offer contrasting methods to arrange production. In markets, contracts govern the purchase of parts and services. In firms, the shared values, customs and norms coming from a corporate culture govern employees' joint development of parts and services. We argue for this distinction as a theory of the firm. Firms exist because corporate culture at times is more efficient to carry out production than are detailed contracts. The firm's boundary encircles the areas of production for which a manager optimally chooses corporate culture as the organizing device. Consistent with empirical evidence, the model explains why some mergers and acquisitions fail, and why corporate cultures are hard to change.

economics
Examining Public Relations’ Role in Shaping Organizational Culture, with Implications for PR, HR, and CSR/Sustainability

Pamela G. Bourland-Davis,Beverly L. Graham

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/978-1-78714-585-620181008

2017-11-07

Abstract:Tapping into an organization’s stories provides an opportunity to examine the organization’s culture and promotes understanding of ways an organization represents itself. Using a communication audit research method to examine organizational culture at a healthcare facility in the southeastern United States during a major change, the study reported in this chapter examines interplay among public relations (PR), human resources (HR) management, and corporate social responsibility or sustainability programs. Use of this research method enabled identification of consistently recurring cultural themes. The results provide support for PR and HR playing an integral role in advocating for and supporting the culture of organizations, although that role may be more implicit than explicit. Findings suggest that corporate social responsibility can be an integral part of organizational culture, and may work best – serving as a source of employee pride – if efforts develop organically from within the organization with employee support.
Culture and workplace: Joining the dots

Lori Tierney

DOI: https://doi.org/10.69554/fpjs5060

2015-08-01

Abstract:What is culture? Every organisation has a culture. Whether it originates from the top, the middle or the bottom, it is there. Ordinarily, corporate culture begins with a founder. They bring a philosophy, an attitude and a way of thinking to start a business. Those hired tend to agree with their boss, otherwise they would not be hired. Henry Ford is one example, Steve Jobs is another. Corporate culture is rapidly and radically changing as technology impacts the workplace. This paper examines the differences in corporate culture, ranging from Google to Apple, from the General Services Administration to the feelings of an employee of an advertising agency who disagrees with the rush to open office. The reader can make up their own mind depending on the information presented, their own personal experiences and, perhaps, prejudices.
What's needed next: a culture of candor

James O'Toole,Warren Bennis

Abstract:If there's one thing that the past decade's business disasters should teach us, it's that we need to stop evaluating corporate leaders simply on the basis of how much wealth they create for investors. A healthier yardstick would be this: the extent to which leaders create firms that are economically, ethically, and socially sustainable. The first step toward accomplishing that task is to create a culture of candor. Companies can't innovate, respond to stakeholder needs, or run efficiently unless the people inside them have access to timely, relevant information, point out professors O'Toole, of the University of Denver's Daniels College of Business, and Bennis, of the University of Southern California. Increasing transparency can be an uphill battle against human nature, however. The obstacles are numerous: macho executives who don't listen to their subordinates or punish them for bringing bad news; leaders who believe that information is power and hoard it; groupthink among team members who don't know how to disagree; boards that fail to question charismatic CEOs. Nevertheless, leaders can take steps to nurture transparency. By being open and candid, admitting their errors, encouraging employees to speak truth to power, and rewarding contrarians, executives can model the kind of conduct they want to see. Training employees to handle unpleasant conversations with grace also will break down barriers to honest communication. To avoid being blinded by biases, leaders can diversify their sources of information--an obvious measure that's rarely taken. Perhaps the biggest lever for cultural change is the executive selection process--choosing leaders for their transparent behavior, not just their ability to compete. And a few companies have even gone so far as to share all relevant information with every employee.
Dual or dueling culture and commitment: The impact of a tri-hospital merger

Janice M Jones

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/00005110-200304000-00009

Abstract:Objectives: This article addresses differences in RNs' commitment to their employing hospital versus the umbrella corporate organization, and the role of organizational culture during a tri-hospital merger. This study is the first to investigate the construct of dual commitment in healthcare organizations. Background: Fiscal restraints, decreasing reimbursement, and increasing competition have made organizational mergers and acquisitions prevalent. As corporate culture changes, organizational variables previously related to organizational commitment may no longer apply. Methods: RNs employed on general nursing units at 3 hospitals involved in a merger process completed 2 versions of Mowday's Organizational Commitment Questionnaire. Commitment to hospital and corporate system were examined. Semi-structured interviews, participant observation, and analysis of company documents assessed the organizational culture changes that have occurred. Results: Thirty-one percent of the nurses returned completed questionnaires; 9 were interviewed. RNs from the acquiring hospital demonstrated a significantly stronger commitment to the corporate system than the nurses from the acquired hospitals. The RNs at all 3 hospitals showed significantly greater commitment to their own particular hospital than to the umbrella corporate system. Conclusions: Moderate level of commitment reflected uncertainty of job status, work overload, and feelings of unappreciation. These attitudes prevent nurses from exerting efforts on behalf of the organization.
The Evolution of American Companies' Mergers and Acquisitions: Characteristics, Causes and Enlightenment

朱琪,黄祖辉

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1672-0202.2003.01.009

2003-01-01

Abstract:Great changes about American corporate governance in the 1980s and 1990s have taken place. In the 1980s, large-scale mergers, takeovers and restructuring in the characteristic of leverage buyouts and hostile takeovers were shown. In the 1990s, leverage buyouts and hostile takeovers were reduced significantly. Meanwhile, other corporate governance mechanism such as manager stock options and corporate board has taken more uses. The characteristics, causes and enlightenment of trends as above are analysed in this paper.
The Cultural Risk and Cultural Integration in Corporate Mergers and Acquisitions

Huang Ting-ting

Abstract:There is a great cultural risk in corporate mergers and acquisitions. In order to ensure the success, the cultural integration of enterprises is an important link in the implement stage of corporation. The paper points out that the culture conflict results in the cultural risk in corporate mergers and acquisitions and puts forward the cultural integration principle and strategy.

Business
A successful and necessary evolution to shared leadership: a hospital's story

B J Merkens,J S Spencer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/13660759810202587

Abstract:The success and adaptability of healthcare organizations will depend more and more on their ability to draw on the capabilities of their people. Tillsonburg District Memorial Hospital, a rural Ontario hospital, has evolved an organization and culture based on shared leadership and decision-making responsibility. Today this extends to front-line teams. This did not come about, however, without continuous effort. Successful transition takes preparation, guidance, much thought, commitment and patience.
The three Cs for cultivating organizational culture in a hybrid world

Michael Arena,Scott Hines,John Golden

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.orgdyn.2023.100958

IF: 1.133

2023-01-25

Organizational Dynamics

Abstract:For years we have known that effective organizational culture is critical to ensuring revenue growth, employee retention, and even stock price acceleration. Yet, culture change is hard. Today, in the hybrid world, most employees still spend the majority of their time working within small work teams, but team members are often remote from one another. These employee interactions are essential to sharing and modeling the norms and behaviors necessary to cultivate the desired culture. Combining behavioral data with the use of organizational network analysis helps to overcome these limitations and provides a deeper understanding of the employee cultural experience—even in the hybrid context. In our research, we evaluated 10 attributes critical to an organization's culture from more than 50,000 employees across three years. Using passive data, we also re-constructed the employee network based on primary interactions. Our research highlighted three critical cultural patterns that will help to more deeply evaluate culture in a hybrid context, but even more importantly,help target local solutions that can be quickly implemented. We call these the three"C's" of cultivating culture. We show that organizational culture clusters in the employee network, is contagious among employees, and is contextually dependent.We discuss our key insights on the three C's, concluding with practical applications for leaders applying these insights in their organization.

management,business,psychology, applied

Corporate cultures. Turning "us versus them" into "we"

Mergers and acquisitions process: the use of corporate culture analysis

The Impact of Leadership and Change Management Strategy on Organizational Culture and Individual Acceptance of Change during a Merger

When cultures collide: the challenge of global integration

Corporate Culture

Culture Change Requires Personal and Organizational Changes: Lessons from the Shared Equity Leadership Model

Cultural change that sticks

Corporate identity and corporate communications: the antidote to merger madness

Using the framework of corporate culture in "mergers" to support the development of a cultural basis for integrative medicine - guidance for building an integrative medicine department or service

Creating Corporate Culture: a study of strategies employed to cultivate High Performance Mentality within Sony Ericsson

The Importance of Culture: Why Leadership, Diversity, and Safety Matter

Tips From the Iceberg: Effecting Culture Change in Health Care Teams

Corporate culture as a theory of the firm

Examining Public Relations’ Role in Shaping Organizational Culture, with Implications for PR, HR, and CSR/Sustainability

Culture and workplace: Joining the dots

What's needed next: a culture of candor

Dual or dueling culture and commitment: The impact of a tri-hospital merger

The Evolution of American Companies' Mergers and Acquisitions: Characteristics, Causes and Enlightenment

The Cultural Risk and Cultural Integration in Corporate Mergers and Acquisitions

A successful and necessary evolution to shared leadership: a hospital's story

The three Cs for cultivating organizational culture in a hybrid world