Debating Human Security in China: Towards Discursive Power?

Shaun Breslin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00472336.2014.907926

IF: 2.2

2014-05-20

Journal of Contemporary Asia

Abstract:While the concept of human security is sometimes dismissed in China as an irrelevant and alien “Western” concept, it has been the subject of serious academic debate – particularly in the mid-2000s, when a series of crises led to a rethinking of the nature of security in and for China. But like other theories and concepts which have been largely developed outside China, human security has been “Sinicised” to reflect Chinese contexts and preferences. In the process, the emphasis on the individual human being that is normally at the heart of human security discourses is typically replaced by a focus on the collective humankind, and Chinese analyses are often packaged together with broader understandings of non-traditional security. This results in a Chinese version of the concept where the state remains a key referent point and actor – indeed, the state is the key guarantor of human security, not a threat to it. And it is this Chinese definition, so the argument goes, that Chinese practices should be judged against, and not supposed universal definitions that in reality only reflect the history and values (and interests) of Western states.

area studies