Abstract:Since 1991, Measurement Science and Technology has awarded a Best Paper prize. The Editorial Board of this journal believe that such a prize is an opportunity to thank authors for submitting their work, and serves as an integral part of the on-going quality review of the journal. The current breadth of topical areas that are covered by MST has made it advisable to expand the recognition of excellent publications. Hence, since 2005 the Editorial Board have presented 'Outstanding Paper Awards'. This year awards were presented in the areas of Fluid Mechanics, Measurement Science, Precision Measurement, Sensors and Sensing Systems, and Optical and Laser-based Techniques. Although the categories mirror subject sections in the journal, the Editorial Board consider articles from all categories in the selection process. 2013 Award Winner—Fluid Mechanics Extraction of skin-friction fields from surface flow visualizations Tianshu Liu Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, MI 49008, USA The skin friction or wall shear stress, τ w, for a wall bounded turbulent flow is a quantity of fundamental importance. It is the basis for the wall unit, ν/u τ (kinematic viscosity/friction velocity: [τ w/ρ ]1/2), which establishes the intrinsic length scale in the flow. The selected paper [1] provides a comprehensive review of—and builds upon—prior techniques to obtain τ w values over an area of interest for flow past complex geometries. The quantities that can be measured by optical imaging are shown to be related to the skin friction by the optical flow equation, which in turn is solved numerically as an inverse problem via the variational approach. The paper provides a well defined set of guidelines for other investigators. Detailed examples of skin-friction measurements using luminescent oil films as well as temperature- and pressure-sensitive paints are presented. Quantitative uncertainty estimates are included in the paper. Given the importance of the wall shear stress (skin friction) in fluid mechanics and the notorious difficulty of measuring this quantity directly, this paper is expected to be a seminal contribution. The paper was one of four in the special feature on Wall Shear Stress organized by Professor A Naguib in the December 2013 issue. 2013 Award Winner—Measurement Science Analysis of calibration-free wavelength-scanned wavelength modulation spectroscopy for practical gas sensing using tunable diode lasers K Sun, X Chao, R Sur, C S Goldenstein, J B Jeffries and R K Hanson High Temperature Gasdynamics Laboratory, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, USA In the previous two years, the Measurement Science Award has gone to important papers in diagnostic fields, namely particle image velocimetry (PIV [2]) and x-ray micro-computed tomographic systems [3]. This year's award [4] goes to another diagnostic field, infrared spectroscopy for practical gas sensing. Infrared spectroscopy is a very important topic for measurement science, concerned with the monitoring of gases in our environment. Over two decades, this form of spectroscopy has been enabled with the development of tunable diode lasers (TDLs). Hence, tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy (TDLAS) is now an established method for in situ measurements of gas composition, temperature, pressure and velocity. Gases such as ammonia, methane, carbon dioxide and monoxide, hydrogen chloride, hydrogen fluoride and sulfur dioxide can all be monitored by commercially available systems. Some advances have been associated with improvements in infrared detectors or in the properties of some diode lasers. For homogeneous gases, the interpretation using the Beer–Lambert law and direct absorption (DA) is quite straightforward. DA is the preferred method when an absorption line can be found in the infrared region with an isolated transition of sufficient strength, and with a linewidth small enough to allow the laser to be wavelength-scanned on the absorption line, and just off it (as a reference baseline). Otherwise, wavelength modulation spectroscopy (WMS) is used for those cases where the gas offers small absorbance, or high pressure or for absorbers with closely spaced transitions, which are blended in the wings precluding measurement of a non-absorbing baseline. WMS is a powerful technique, but the interpretation is more complex, and the authors explain in their introduction the strategies that are normally adopted for data interpretation. In this new paper, the authors explain a new strategy for wavelength modulation spectroscopy. The strategy is different in two significant ways. Firstly, the measured laser intensity is used to simulate the transmitted laser intensity. Secondly, digital lock-in and low-pass filter software is used to expand both simulated and measured transmitted laser intensities into harmonics of the modulation frequency. In this way, the analysis scheme does not require an isolated transition; instead it recovers the lineshape for absorption from unresolved blended transitions. The paper goes on to describe an example using this novel method. It discusses the analysis of WMS absorption detection using water as an example. The advantages of the new method are explained, and a comparison is made with the more usual Fourier analysis approach. This paper is excellent in its clarity, presentation and scientific description. Issues have been clearly identified, and a new method of analysis has been presented with some evidence of validation. Its conclusions contain an in-depth summary, and the following 42 references are informative and representative of what is a very large field of study. It was voted as the best paper from a shortlist of 12 nominated papers. 2013 Award Winner—Precision Measurement Interferometric diameter determination of a silicon sphere using a traceable single laser frequency synthesizer Xuejian Wu, Yan Li, Haoyun Wei, Honglei Yang, Guoce Yang and Jitao Zhang State Key Lab of Precision Measurement Technology and Instruments, Department of Precision Instrument, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, People's Republic of China This paper [5] describes the determination of the absolute diameter of a silicon sphere for the Avogadro project using a phase shifting interferometer based on a flat etalon. The absolute diameter is attained by combining the fractional and integral measurement results, which are measured with phase shifting interferometry and frequency sweeping interferometry using laser frequency tuning, respectively. An optical frequency comb is used as the frequency ruler to measure and control the frequency of an external cavity diode laser in order to reduce the uncertainty contribution from the laser frequency on the phase steps to an insignificant level. The Carré algorithm with arbitrary but equal phase steps is used to calculate the fractional interference phases according to the characteristic of single laser frequency synthesiser. The paper provides a comprehensive description of the measurement techniques together with an uncertainty budget for the measurement of a silicon sphere. An overall measurement uncertainty of 5 nm is achieved. This paper has been downloaded more than 130 times since its publication. The selection committee members on the Precision Measurement Award, Dr A Yacoot, Dr P Williams, Dr H Bosse, Professor X Chen and Dr T Eom, selected this paper from a strongly competitive list of several candidates. Considering its impact on accurate evaluation of the measurement of silicon spheres, the paper was selected as the winner of the Precision Measurement Award for 2013. 2013 Award Winner—Sensors and Sensing Systems Enhancing the dynamic range of ultrasound imaging velocimetry using interleaved imaging C Poelma1 and K H Fraser 2 1Laboratory for Aero and Hydrodynamics (3ME-P&E), Delft University of Technology, Leeghwaterstraat 21, 2628 CA Delft, The Netherlands 2Department of Bioengineering, Imperial College London, South Kensington Campus, SW7 2AZ London, UK This paper [6] presents an innovative interleaved imaging technique to overcome the dynamic velocity range limitation of current ultrasound imaging velocimetry. Due to the nature of the recording of ultrasound images, the conversion from pixel displacement to velocities is less straightforward since the lines of an image are not recorded at the same time, so the inter-frame time needs to be corrected for any displacement. The upper limit of displacement velocities is widely reported in the literature as a major problem with the best measured in-vivo flow rates of ~ 70–80 cm s−1 or by restricting the field of view to as high as 140 cm s−1. In this study, the authors introduce a novel imaging method that enhances the dynamic range of ultrasound imaging velocimetry by an interleaved read-out approach. Using this technique, the inter-frame time is no longer fixed to the imaging rate and allows for the displacement of fast flows to be reduced by choosing an appropriate image offset parameter. The authors show that this technique allows for measurement of flows of up to 140 cm s−1 with the maximum lateral field of view and unrestricted depth. In their winning paper the authors have very clearly articulated the dynamic range limitations of the flow measurement using ultrasound imaging velocimetry and have very elegantly described the theory and experimental implementation of the interleaved imaging technique. The superior performance of the proposed method is clearly demonstrated through experimental results and images analyzed using the necessary mathematical transforms. The improved dynamic flow rate measurements using ultrasound imaging velocimetry made feasible using this technique are likely to have a significant impact on non-invasive blood flow monitoring for clinical screening and post-operative monitoring. 2013 Award Winner—Optical and Laser-based Techniques Detection of excited level population transfer in an MOT through the measurement of trapped atom number. L Moi1, G Batignani1, A Khanbekyan1, K Khanbekyan1, C Marinelli1, E Mariotti1, L Marmugi1, L Corradi2, A Dainelli2, R Calabrese3, G Mazzocca3, L Tomassetti3 and P Minguzzi4 1CNISM, Physics Department, University of Siena, via Roma 56, 53100 Siena, Italy 2INFN—Laboratori Nazionali di Legnaro, viale dell'Università 2, 35020 Legnaro (PD), Italy 3University of Ferrara and INFN, via Saragat 1, 44122 Ferrara, Italy 4CNISM, Physics Department, University of Pisa, largo Pontecorvo 3, 56127 Pisa, Italy The selected paper [7] applies a direct fluorescence detection scheme to monitor the very low number of trapped atoms, simulating the conditions in a francium magneto-optical trap (MOT). Precise atomic parity nonconservation measurements are inherently difficult due to the fact that extremely weak signals must be detected. By scanning a probe beam across a resonance condition and then detecting the MOT fluorescence, the authors were able to monitor the population transfer from the ground level and the first excited level in the MOT. The significance of this work is that it presents a rapid and flexible method to detect the number of trapped atoms in conditions where very low numbers of these atoms are present. Such high precision measurements are essential in nuclear physics and are fundamental to our understanding of nuclear decay processes. We have selected this article for the Best Paper Award because the measurement technique demonstrated is not only innovative, but also flexible to implement as it is wavelength independent and presents a high signal to noise ratio. The experimental configuration was also extremely well documented in the paper, including a detailed estimate of the detection limits. Data were presented for many different excitation mechanisms to show the wide applicability of the measurement technique. It is expected that this innovative measurement strategy will be seen in successful applications of the study of atomic parity nonconservation in different nuclear particles in the near future. The chairmen would like to thank the authors for choosing to publish their work in Measurement Science and Technology , and hope that other researchers enjoy reading these works and feel encouraged to submit their own best work to the journal. References [1] Liu T 2013 Extraction of skin-friction fields from surface flow visualizations as an inverse problem Meas. Sci. Technol 24 124004 [2] Oishi M, Kinoshita H, Fujii T and Oshima M 2011 Simultaneous measurement of internal and surrounding flows of a moving droplet using multicolour confocal micro-particle image velocimetry micro-PIV Meas. Sci. Technol. 22 105401 [3] Hiller J, Maisl M and Reindl L M 2012 Physical characterization and performance evaluation of an x-ray micro-computed tomography system for dimensional metrology applications Meas. Sci. Technol 23 085404 [4] Sun K, Chao X, Sur R, Goldenstein C S, Jeffries J B and Hanson R K 2013 Analysis of calibration-free wavelength-scanned wavelength modulation spectroscopy for practical gas sensing using tunable diode lasers Meas. Sci. Technol 24 125203 [5] Wu X et al 2013 Interferometric diameter determination of a silicon sphere using a traceable single laser frequency synthesizer Meas. Sci. Technol. 24 115202 [6] Poelma C and Fraser K H 2013 Enhancing the dynamic range of ultrasound imaging velocimetry using interleaved imaging Meas. Sci. Technol. 24 115701 [7] Moi L et al 2013 Detection of excited level population transfer in an MOT through the measurement of trapped atom number Meas. Sci. Technol. 24 015201

Abstract:Since 1991, Measurement Science and Technology has awarded a Best Paper prize. The Editorial Board of this journal believes that such a prize is an opportunity to thank authors for submitting their work, and serves as an integral part of the on-going quality review of the journal. The current breadth of topical areas that are covered by MST has made it advisable to expand the recognition of excellent publications. Hence, since 2005 the Editorial Board have presented 'Outstanding Paper Awards' in four subject categories: Fluid Mechanics; Measurement Science; Precision Measurements; and Sensors and Sensing Systems. This year also saw the introduction of a new category—Optical and Laser-based Techniques. 2009 Award Winners—Fluid Mechanics Digital particle image velocimetry (DPIV) robust phase correlation Adric Eckstein and Pavlos P Vlachos Department of Mechanical Engineering, Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA, USA This paper [1] represents a valuable improvement to the phase-only correlation technique (first proposed by Wernet in this journal in 2005 (Wernet M 2005 Symmetric phase-only filtering: a new paradigm for DPIV data processing Meas. Sci. Technol. 16 601–18) for particle-image-velocimetry (PIV) measurements of fluid flow. The authors establish a sound theoretical foundation and clearly describe the working principle of their robust phase correlation method. The methodology for assessing performance is excellent. Detailed results on several internationally recognized PIV test cases are presented. The robust phase correlation method is of general applicability and therefore can be expected to have substantial impact in this very active area of fluid-mechanics measurements. 2009 Award Winner—Precision Measurement A nanonewton force facility and a novel method for measurements of the air and vacuum permittivity at zero frequencies V Nesterov Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt (PTB), Bundesallee 100, D-38116 Braunschweig, Germany This paper [2] describes a new method for measuring the air and vacuum permittivity by observing a nanonewton force in a disk-pendulum. The frequency dependence of the vacuum permittivity, ε0, has been one of the fundamental questions in physics. Although it is confidently believed that there is no frequency dependence in ε0, very few experiments have been conducted to verify the properties of ε0. Especially in the region near zero frequencies, no experiment has been done in the vacuum. The precise measurement of the vacuum permittivity is therefore of fundamental interest to test the correctness of Maxwell's equations in an electrostatic field. In this paper, the author developed a new principle using a disk-pendulum, where the displacement of the disk-pendulum in the presence of an electrostatic field has been detected by optical interferometry. The nanonewton forces generated by the electrostatic field have been measured to evaluate the air and vacuum permittivity at zero frequencies, achieving a relative standard uncertainty of 10−5 in the measurement of ε0. The measurement system developed here also opened a new way for the force standard in the nanonewton region, investigation of the Casimir effect, direct measurement of laser power etc. This paper has been downloaded more than 200 times since its publication. The selection committee members on precision measurement selected this paper from a strongly competitive list of eleven candidates for its sophisticated idea, originality in apparatus, and excellent result with uncertainty evaluation. Considering its impact on fundamental physics and also on precision force measurement in the nanonewton region, the paper was nominated for the MST Precision Measurement Award from the papers published in 2009. 2009 Award Winners—Sensors and Sensing Systems High-resolution and compact refractometer for salinity measurements D Malardé, Z Y Wu, P Grosso, J-L de Bougrenet de la Tocnaye and M Le Menn Optics Department, UMR CNRS 6082 FOTON, TELECOM Bretagne, CS 83818, 29238 Brest Cédex 3, France Laboratoire de Métrologie et de Chimie Océanographique, SHOM 13 rue du Châtelier, BP 30316, 29603 Brest Cedex, France The absolute salinity of seawater is an important component in the determination of the ocean's thermodynamic properties. This paper [3] presents a measurement system for very accurate determination of the salinity. The method is based on measuring the refractive index of seawater, a parameter that is related to the salinity. Although the method is essentially simple: using a prism and a PSD for direct measurement of the angle of refraction, the refraction also depends on many more parameters (temperature, pressure, wavelength). Moreover, for obtaining accurate salinity values, a high resolution of the refractive index is required, of the order of 10−7, under all possible conditions. Starting with a list of notations and symbols, the paper follows with an overview of existing methods for salinity measurements and their performances. Next, the principle based on refractometry is introduced, and a theoretical model is presented, comprising a large number of parameters that influence the properties of the refractometer. From this analysis there follows an optimization of the geometry of the device. The sensitivity for salinity and other water parameters are estimated from theory, and verified experimentally. Salinity measurements are compared with those using standard salinometers, and show an uncertainty less than a few 10−3 psu (practical salinity units). The obtained resolution is about 4 × 10−7, which is limited by that of the readout electronics of the PSD. It is demonstrated that this can be further improved to achieve the required resolution lower than 10−7. The authors make clear that their prototype, the length of which is about 12 cm, is an important step to a fully in situ oceanographic salinometer, but further testing is required to confirm reliability. Indeed, the paper does not report on long term effects of, for instance, contamination of the optical parts. Hopefully this will be investigated and published in the next stage of the research. 2009 Award Winners—Measurement Science Analysis and mitigation of measurement uncertainties in the traceability chain for the calibration of photovoltaic devices Harald Mullejans, Willem Zaaiman and Roberto Galleano European Commission, Joint Research Centre, Institute for Energy, Renewable Energy Unit, European Solar Test Installation, Via E Fermi 2749, I-21027 Ispra (Va), Italy The energy output and efficiency from different types of photovoltaic (PV) devices is an essential characteristic of photovoltaics. They may only be assessed from cell performance under standard test conditions, with traceability back to international standards. As this paper [4] points out in its introduction, the reliability of the measurements and their uncertainty are of crucial importance to manufacturers, operators and investors. Several features in the format of the article help to make this an excellent paper. Following an informative abstract, the paper has a concise introduction followed by a detailed formulation of the problem to be addressed. After a discussion of present-day international codes related to the measurement and performance of PVs, the paper goes on to describe one of the most difficult issues in traceability, that of deriving an irradiance quantity which is normally measured by a reference PV device. This might appear straightforward, but the paper highlights the difficulties of measuring the irradiance of sunlight (either simulated or natural) during the evaluation of the electrical performance of PV devices. The calibration of any PV device essentially consists of the measurement of the IV characteristics, by sweeping the device from its short-circuit condition (SC) to its open-circuit condition (OC) when exposed to (pulsed or continuous) simulated or natural sunlight. In this paper, all measurements were carried out at the European Solar Test Installation at Ispra in Italy. After describing the measurement methods, the authors discuss at length the calculations of measurement uncertainty. This leads to a rigorous discussion of relative uncertainties from measurement parameters. Uncertainties arise from a range of parameters that include small contributions from electrical, temperature and fill factor parameters. But the greatest arises from uncertainties both in the optical source and in the reference cell. As a consequence, the authors make a convincing case both for identifying the sources of uncertainty and for reducing overall uncertainties from ±2.6% to below ±2%. The conclusions are concise, and the paper is rounded off with a list of 34 references with several papers cited from 2005 onwards. This paper was rated as excellent by external referees, and has been downloaded several hundred times since its publication. It is one of 30 papers nominated this year in the Measurement Science category, and gained most votes from those short-listed. The discussion on measurement uncertainty sets a fine example to all researchers involved in experimental measurement science. 2009 Award Winners—Optical and Laser-based Techniques Measurement of tiny droplets using a newly developed optical fibre probe micro-fabricated by a femtosecond pulse laser T Saito, K Matsuda, Y Ozawa, S Oishi and S Aoshima Shizuoka University, 3-5-1 Johoku, Naka-ku Hamamatsu, Shizuoka 432-8561, Japan CRL, Hamamatsu Photonics K.K., 5000 Hirakuchi, Hamakita-ku Hamamatsu, Shizuoka 434-8601, Japan This Award goes to a paper [5] describing a fascinating and novel optical fibre probe applied to measurements in gas–liquid two-phase flows. Optical probes have already been widely applied to two-phase flows. These include the use of four-tip optical probes (F-TOP) for millimetre-size bubbles/droplets, and a single-tip optical fibre probe (S-TOP) for sub-millimetre size bubbles/droplets. This new paper describes how micro-machining a groove into the side of the silica fibre using a femtosecond laser system leads to a new optical fibre probe (Fs-TOP). It is capable of measurements of velocity and size of droplets down to about 50 µm in diameter. A useful introduction describes the importance of characterization required in gas–liquid two-phase flows. Measurements are required in a variety of research fields, e.g. sprays, automotive engines, fine chemistry and atomic power plants. Characterization of bubbles/droplets at high density has been desired for both laboratory and industrial use. Addressed towards this goal, this paper describes the use of optical fibre probes that have been modified with a side-wall groove. The authors point out that whereas the S-TOP is made very easily, with the tip of the S-TOP only micro-ground into a wedge shape, the Fs-TOP is very difficult to fabricate. In addition to a wedge tip, fabrication involves a femtosecond laser system with nano-order six-axis automatic optical stages and confocal optics. Hence it is important to intelligently select between these two types of probe depending on the measurement objective. Moreover, like all types of new probe, it is first necessary to validate its performance against other probes with accepted performance characteristics. After describing the experimental arrangement, the authors discuss at length the performance of the new Fs-TOP and that of the S-TOP for comparison. Additionally, results from the Fs-TOP are compared with those from visualization of the droplets by a high-speed video camera. Results show satisfactory agreement. After a lengthy presentation of results and discussion, the authors produce a concise set of inclusions, including a summary of the small perturbation in droplet size arising from the presence of the probe. The paper was one of 22 papers nominated this year for the Best Paper Award in Optical and Laser-based Techniques. It crosses the disciplines of optical measurement science and measurements required for the characterization of two-phase fluid flow. Exploiting new technological facilities in micromachining, the paper is an excellent example of new opportunities that may arise in measurement. References [1] Eckstein A and Vlachos P P 2009 Digital particle image velocimetry (DPIV) robust phase correlation Meas. Sci. Technol. 20 055401 (14pp) [2] Nesterov V 2009 A nanonewton force facility and a novel method for measurements of the air and vacuum permittivity at zero frequencies Meas. Sci. Technol. 20 084012 (6pp) [3] Malardé D, Wu Z Y, Grosso P, de Bougrenet de la Tocnaye J-L and Le Menn M 2009 High-resolution and compact refractometer for salinity measurements Meas. Sci. Technol. 20 015204 (8pp) [4] Müllejans H, Zaaiman W and Galleano R 2009 Analysis and mitigation of measurement uncertainties in the traceability chain for the calibration of photovoltaic devices Meas. Sci. Technol. 20 075101 (12pp) [5] Saito T, Matsuda K, Ozawa Y, Oishi S and Aoshima S 2009 Measurement of tiny droplets using a newly developed optical fibre probe micro-fabricated by a femtosecond pulse laser Meas. Sci. Technol. 20 114002 (12pp)

Announcing the 2013 Measurement Science and Technology Outstanding Paper Awards

Announcing the 2010 Measurement Science and Technology Outstanding Paper Awards

Announcing the 2008 Measurement Science and Technology Outstanding Paper Awards

Announcing the 2007 Measurement Science and Technology Outstanding Paper Awards

Announcing the 2009 Measurement Science and Technology Outstanding Paper Awards

65th Birthday of Professor Hauptmann

Self-Calibrated Multiharmonic CO 2 Sensor Using VCSEL for Urban in Situ Measurement

Theoretical Corrections of Instrumental Broadening Effect and Surface Property Measurement of Fluid at Low Scattering Angle by Surface Light Scattering Method

A diode laser sensor for rapid, sensitive measurements of gas temperature and water vapour concentration at high temperatures and pressures

Uncertainty Quantification for High-Temperature Gas Sensing Using Direct Laser Absorption Spectroscopy

Precise Velocity Measurement by Using Even-symmetric 2f/1f Harmonics Extracted from Up- and Down-Scanning WMS Signal

High-sensitivity Phase Detecting System for Measurement of Weak Displacement Signals on the Liquid Free Surface in Thermocapillary Convection

Laser intensity and absorbance measurements by tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy based on non-line fitting algorithm

Analysis of Calibration-Free Wavelength-Scanned Wavelength Modulation Spectroscopy for Practical Gas Sensing Using Tunable Diode Lasers

Lateral resolution limit of laser Doppler vibrometer microscopes for the measurement of surface acoustic waves

New Laser Doppler Velocimetry with Wide Dynamic Range and Clear Directional Discrimination

The Role of Millimeter-Waves in the Distance Measurement Accuracy of an FMCW Radar Sensor

Implementation of Ultrasonic Sensing for High Resolution Measurement of Binary Gas Mixture Fractions

High Resolution Viscosity Measurement by Thermal Noise Detection

Low-Coherence Photothermal Interferometry for Precision Spectroscopic Gas Sensing

Double Threshold Ultrasonic Distance Measurement Technique and Its Application