Abstract:Policy Points Hospital executives posit a number of rationales for system mergers which lack any basis in academic evidence. Decades of academic research question whether system combinations confer public benefits. Antitrust authorities need to continue to closely scrutinize these transactions. Recently, mergers of hospital systems that span different geographic markets are on the rise. Economists have alerted policymakers about the potential impacts such cross-market mergers may have on hospital prices. We suggest there are other reasons for concern that scholars have not often confonted. Cross-market mergers may be conducted for purely self-serving reasons of organizational growth that increases executive compensation. Combinations of sellers should have clear advantages to consumers. System executives and their boards should bear the burden of proof. Federal regulators and state attorney generals should be cognizant that rationales for cross-market systems advanced by merging parties are unlikely to be operative or dominant in merger decision making. Policymakers should be careful about passing legislation that encourages hospitals to consolidate. Context: There is a growing trend of combinations among hospital systems that operate in different geographic markets known as cross-market mergers. Economists have analyzed these broader systems in terms of their anticompetitive behavior and pricing power over insurers. This paper evaluates the benefits advanced by these new hospital systems that speak to a different set of issues not usually studied: increased efficiencies, new capabilities, operating synergies, and addressing health inequities. The paper thus "looks under the hood" of these emerging, cross-market systems to assess what value they might bestow and upon whom. Methods: The paper examines recently announced cross-market mergers in terms of their supposed benefits, as expressed by the systems' executives as well as by industry consultants. These presumed benefits are then evaluated against existing evidence regarding hospital system outcomes. Findings: Advocates of cross-market hospital mergers cite a host of benefits. Research suggests these benefits are nonexistent. Additional evidence suggests other motives may be at play in the formation of cross-market mergers that have nothing to do with efficiencies, synergies, or community benefits. Instead these mergers may be self-serving efforts by system chief executive officers (CEOs) to boost their compensation. Conclusions: Cross-market hospital mergers may yield no benefits to the hospitals involved or the communities in which they operate. The boards of hospital systems that engage in these cross-market mergers need to exercise greater diligence over the actions of their CEOs.

Market Reaction to Bidder Announcements of Horizontal Mergers in an Oligopolistic Industry: Evidence from the US Airline Industry

Explaining the Heterogeneity in Rival Response of Acquisition Targets: Evidence from Media Coverage

Market Concentration and Performance the Case of the U.S. Airline Industry

An Evaluation of the Operational Performance and Profitability of the U.S. Airlines

Market Structure and Competition in Airline Markets

Multimarket Contact, Merger, and Airline Collusion

Merger Efficiency Gains: Evidence from a Large Transport Merger in France

Do domestic mergers improve airlines' international competitiveness?---Theoretical and empirical evidence from China

When to Initiate an International Vertical Merger? the Impact of Negative Demand Shock

The Performance of the European Market for Corporate Control: Evidence from the Fifth Takeover Wave

Horizontal Mergers and Heterogeneous Firm Investments: Evidence from the United States

Balancing Competition and Cooperation: Evidence from Transatlantic Airline Markets

Airline market exit after a shock event: Insights from the COVID-19 pandemic

An empirical analysis of the determinants of network construction for Azul Airlines

Airline cooperation effects on airfare distribution: An auction-model-based approach

The Effects of Passenger Risk Perception During the COVID-19 Pandemic on Airline Industry: Evidence From the United States Stock Market

Concentration-Based Inference for Evaluating Horizontal Mergers

Bidder Companies and Defended Bids: A Test of Roll's Hubris Hypothesis

Investigating the economic role of mergers

Big Med's Spread