Abstract:We study endogenous merger decisions among three competing firms with asymmetric capacity: One large firm has ample capacity, and two small firms have limited capacity. Each firm can either operate independently or merge with another firm. Due to antitrust laws, all three firms merging is not permitted. When two firms merge, the merged entity and the remaining independent firm use the resulting capacity to capture their own "loyal buyers" and compete in price for price-sensitive "disloyal switchers". We first consider a base model where the size of loyal buyers for different firms is symmetric. We find that either there is no merger or the large firm will merge with a small firm (called mixed merger). We explain how the equilibrium structure is driven by the "price effect" and the "demand effect". Specifically, the mixed merger which can most effectively reduce price competition is the equilibrium for relatively competitive market conditions (i.e., small size of loyal buyers and large but constrained capacity). We also extend to the case with asymmetric size of loyal segments, and show that two small firms merging can be the equilibrium structure when the large firm has a much larger loyal segment than the small firms and the small firms' capacity is sufficiently large. The impacts of mergers on social welfare and consumer surplus provide practical implications from the antitrust perspective. The antitrust agencies who are concerned about social welfare can approve a mixed merger under certain conditions, but if the agencies pay more attention to consumer surplus, then mixed mergers should not be permitted. Small mergers, though sometimes are not the equilibrium structures, can improve both social welfare and consumer surplus. In such cases, the government can appropriately promote mergers that are beneficial for society and/or consumers by adopting some restrictive measures or offering incentives.

Multimarket Contact, Merger, and Airline Collusion

Market Structure and Competition in Airline Markets

Common Subcontracting and Airline Prices

Does IT Enable Collusion or Competition: Examining the Effects of IT on Service Pricing in Multimarket Multihospital Systems

Data‐driven collusion and competition in a pricing duopoly with multinomial logit demand

The Strategic Effects of Multimarket Contact: Mutual Forbearance and Competitive Response in the Personal Computer Industry

Collusion or Competition? Interfirm Relationships in the Chinese Auto Industry

Firms’ Markup, Cost, and Price Changes when Policymakers Permit Collusion: Does Antitrust Immunity Matter?

Price Discrimination in International Airline Markets

Wireless Service Pricing Competition under Network Effect, Congestion Effect, and Bounded Rationality

Algorithmic Collusion and Price Discrimination: The Over-Usage of Data

Airline cooperation effects on airfare distribution: An auction-model-based approach

Market Competition and Its Determinants in Chinese Airline Industry——An Empirical Study Based on Company-level and Route-level Panel Data

Price Discrimination in the Online Airline Market: An Empirical Study

Alliance Formation among Competitors: Impact of Limited Capacity and Loyal Segments

Learning Collusion in Episodic, Inventory-Constrained Markets

An Empirical Study on China Airlines' Price Competition

State-owned Enterprise Dominant,Administrative Monopoly and Price Collusion

Collusion risk in corporate networks

Do domestic mergers improve airlines' international competitiveness?---Theoretical and empirical evidence from China