Price Discrimination in International Airline Markets

Gaurab Aryal,Charles Murry,Jonathan W. Williams
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2102.05751
2022-12-06
Abstract:We develop a model of inter-temporal and intra-temporal price discrimination by monopoly airlines to study the ability of different discriminatory pricing mechanisms to increase efficiency and the associated distributional implications. To estimate the model, we use unique data from international airline markets with flight-level variation in prices across time, cabins, and markets and information on passengers' reasons for travel and time of purchase. The current pricing practice yields approximately 77% of the first-best welfare. The source of this inefficiency arises primarily from private information about passenger valuations, not dynamic uncertainty about demand. We also find that if airlines could discriminate between business and leisure passengers, total welfare would improve at the expense of business passenger surplus. Also, replacing the current pricing that involves screening passengers across cabin classes with offering a single cabin class has minimal effect on total welfare.
General Economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to study the ability of airlines to improve efficiency through different forms of price discrimination (price differentiation) mechanisms and its impact on welfare distribution. Specifically, the authors construct a model to analyze the inter - temporal and intra - temporal price discrimination behavior of monopoly airlines in the international aviation market. They hope to understand the following points through this model: 1. **Efficiency improvement of price discrimination**: How different price discrimination mechanisms can reduce the inefficiency of resource allocation and thus improve overall economic efficiency. 2. **Impact on welfare distribution**: What impact does price discrimination have on the distribution of consumer surplus and producer surplus, especially the different impacts on business travelers and leisure travelers. 3. **Impact of information asymmetry**: Since airlines cannot fully grasp passengers' willingness to pay (i.e., private information), how much impact does this information asymmetry have on pricing efficiency? ### Research background and motivation - **Challenges faced by airlines**: Airlines lack perfect information about passengers' willingness to pay and do not know when passengers will enter the market. This lack of information makes it complicated to measure its impact on welfare. - **Evaluation of existing practices**: The current pricing strategy has achieved approximately 77% of the optimal welfare level. The main source of inefficiency is the private information of passengers' willingness to pay, rather than the dynamic uncertainty of demand. - **Possibility of policy recommendations**: If airlines can conduct more accurate price discrimination according to passengers' travel purposes, it may improve the total welfare to a certain extent, but this may also lead to a reduction in the surplus of business travelers. ### Methodology To evaluate these problems, the authors use the "Survey of International Air Travelers" (SIAT) data set from the US Department of Commerce. This data set contains price changes in flight classes, cabin differences, and market information, as well as detailed information such as passengers' travel reasons and ticket - purchasing times. Based on these data, the authors develop and estimate a complex supply - demand model to simulate how airlines conduct price discrimination between time and cabins and analyze its impact on welfare. ### Main findings - **Effect of current pricing strategies**: The existing pricing strategies have reached approximately 77% of the optimal welfare level. Most (87%) of the inefficiency is caused by the private information of passengers' willingness to pay, and only 13% is due to the uncertainty of demand. - **Room for improvement**: If airlines can conduct more precise price discrimination according to passengers' travel purposes, the total welfare can be further improved, but this will be at the expense of the surplus of business travelers. - **Impact of simplifying cabin distinctions**: Eliminating the price difference between economy class and first class has almost no impact on the total welfare, indicating a strong substitution relationship between the two cabins. Through these studies, the authors hope to provide airlines and policymakers with important insights into the economic benefits and distribution impacts of price discrimination strategies, thereby helping to optimize pricing strategies and related policies.