Abstract:Active learning, including student thinking and discussion in class, has been shown to increase student learning gains. However, it is less clear how instructor-level variation in the implementation and timing of active learning activities affects student gains. Our study aims to investigate the extent to which the time spent on individual episodes of active learning activities influences student performance. We hypothesized that instructors who let students spend more time on peer discussion and individual thinking on practice problems associated with particular learning objectives would have better student exam scores on exam questions addressing those objectives. To test this hypothesis, we obtained a large data set of classroom recordings and student exam scores from an introductory biology course at a large 4-year university, where three instructors shared identical teaching materials and exams for different course offerings. Contrary to our hypothesis, although the three instructors spent significantly different amounts of time on episodes of thinking and peer discussion, there was no correlation between the total time spent on active learning activities and student performance on exam questions. Linear mixed-effects modeling of the effect of the length of episodes of student thinking and discussion on exam score found that in the context of shared instructional materials, the amount of course time spent on active learning activities did not reliably predict student performance on associated exam questions. This result held true even when only considering learning objectives with high variations in performance between offerings, difficult exam questions, or exam questions requiring higher-order thinking skills. Although our study was only conducted in one course, our results imply that time spent per individual episode of student thinking or peer discussion may not be the primary factor explaining the positive effects of active learning and that it may be worthwhile to explore other factors.

It's not about seat time: Blending, flipping, and efficiency in active learning classrooms

The Effect of Blended Learning Environment-based, Flipped Classroom Practice on College Students' Learning Performance

Using Flipped Classroom Modules to Facilitate Higher Order Learning in Undergraduate Organic Chemistry

The flipped classroom: A learning model to increase student engagement not academic achievement

Promoting active learning in introductory financial accounting through the flipped classroom design

Observing Instructor Behaviour in an Active Learning Classroom: A Case Study of an Undergraduate Calculus Course

Assessment of blended biochemistry classes based on massive open online courses and a "semi-flipped" learning environment

Beyond active learning: Using 3-Dimensional learning to create scientifically authentic, student-centered classrooms

Improving Academic Performance, Belonging, and Retention through Increasing Structure of an Introductory Biology Course

Active Learning in Flipped Life Science Courses Promotes Development of Critical Thinking Skills

Blending Online Homework and Large Class Tutorials to Provide Learning Support for Introductory Organic Chemistry

Time spent on active learning activities does not necessarily correlate with student exam performance: a controlled case study

Incorporating Active Learning Strategies and Instructor Presence into an Online Discrete Mathematics Class

Exploring University Students' Engagement with Online Video Lectures in a Blended Introductory Mechanics Course

Time Spent, Workload, and Student and Faculty Perceptions in a Blended Learning Environment

Flipped microlecture classes: satisfied learners and higher performance?

Large Lecture Transformation: Adopting Evidence-Based Practices to Increase Student Engagement and Performance in an Introductory Science Course

Investigating the intensity and integration of active learning and lecture.

Building Engineering Fundamentals in an Active Learning Environment

The use of an active learning approach in a SCALE-UP learning space improves academic performance in undergraduate General Biology

Analysis of Learning Achievement and Teacher–Student Interactions in Flipped and Conventional Classrooms