Assessment of MODIS, MERIS, GEOV1 FPAR Products over Northern China with Ground Measured Data and by Analyzing Residential Effect in Mixed Pixel

Fei Yang,Hongyan Ren,Xiaoyu Li,Maogui Hu,Yaping Yang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/rs6065428
IF: 5
2014-06-12
Remote Sensing
Abstract:Fraction of Photosynthetically Active Radiation (FPAR) is a critical parameter in land surface energy balance and climate modeling. Several global FPAR products are available, but these still require considerable assessment and validation due to low spatial resolution. Three major FPAR products that have covered China and provided continuous time series data—MODIS, MERIS and GEOV1—were assessed from 2006–2010. Based on the ground measurement data, the accuracies of these three FPAR products were directly validated for maize and winter wheat over northern China. This investigation also assessed the consistencies among the three FPAR products, and analyzed the residential area in mixed pixels effect on the FPAR products accuracy, at each of the main growth stages of maize and winter wheat. The GEOV1 FPAR product was found to be the most accurate with regression R2 values of 0.818 and 0.655 for ground measured maize and winter wheat FPAR. The maize FPAR data were generally more accurate than the winter wheat FPAR data. The MODIS, MERIS and GEOV1 products all indicated that FPAR variations among the growth stages differed from year to year. The scattered residential areas in mixed pixels were found to significantly affect the FPAR data uncertainties, and these were also analyzed in detail. The effect of residential area percentage in mixed pixels on FPAR values differed for different crops, and this was not necessarily in accordance with the FPAR product accuracy. For the mixed pixels, a quadratic polynomial was able to fit the residential area and FPAR data reasonably well with R2 values higher than 0.9 for most relationships. Quadratic polynomial fitting may provide a simple and convenient method to assess and reduce the residential area effect on FPAR in the mixed pixels.
environmental sciences,imaging science & photographic technology,remote sensing,geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate and verify the accuracy of three major global Fraction of Photosynthetically Active Radiation (FPAR) products - MODIS, MERIS and GEOV1 in northern China. Specifically, the study directly verified the accuracy of these FPAR products through ground - measured data and analyzed the impact of residential areas on the accuracy of FPAR products in mixed pixels. In addition, the paper also explored the consistency of these FPAR products at different crop growth stages and the impact of the proportion of residential areas on FPAR values. ### Research Background FPAR is a key parameter in land - surface energy balance and climate modeling, used to detect vegetation water, energy and carbon balance, and is an important indicator in ecosystem productivity models, crop yield models, etc. Although there are currently multiple global FPAR products, due to their low spatial resolution, these products still need a great deal of evaluation and verification. The paper chose to evaluate three FPAR products that cover China and provide continuous time - series data: MODIS, MERIS and GEOV1. ### Research Methods 1. **Research Area**: The research area is located in Changchun in the Northeast China Plain and Dezhou and Liaocheng in the North China Plain. 2. **Data Collection**: - **Ground - measured Data**: Use LI - 191SA linear quantum sensors and LI - 250A photometers to measure the FPAR of maize and winter wheat. - **FPAR Product Data**: Downloaded the FPAR product data of MODIS, MERIS and GEOV1 from online websites. - **Proportion of Residential Areas Data**: Aggregated 1 - km × 1 - km raster data from land - use - type shape files manually interpreted from Landsat TM images. 3. **Methods**: - **Direct Verification**: Compare the ground - measured FPAR with the FPAR product data. - **Inter - product Comparison**: Analyze the consistency of the three FPAR products at different crop growth stages. - **Residential Area Impact Analysis**: Statistically analyze the FPAR data within different intervals of the proportion of residential areas and use quadratic polynomial regression to analyze their relationship. ### Main Findings 1. **FPAR Product Verification**: - For maize, the GEOV1 FPAR product has the highest linear regression R² value (0.818), followed by MERIS (0.744) and MODIS (0.630). - For winter wheat, the GEOV1 FPAR product also has the highest linear regression R² value (0.655), followed by MERIS (0.488) and MODIS (0.432). - Overall, the GEOV1 FPAR product performs best at high FPAR values, while the MODIS and MERIS products underestimate FPAR values at some growth stages. 2. **Inter - product Consistency**: - The frequency distributions of the three FPAR products at different crop growth stages show obvious differences. - The FPAR of winter wheat has a smaller inter - annual variation, while the FPAR of maize varies greatly in different years. - The FPAR values of different products show different degrees of concentration at different growth stages. 3. **Residential Area Impact**: - The residential areas in mixed pixels significantly affect the uncertainty of FPAR data. - Quadratic polynomial fitting can well describe the relationship between the proportion of residential areas and FPAR values, with R² values usually higher than 0.9. ### Conclusion This study provides a basis for the scientific use of these FPAR products in northern China and emphasizes the impact of residential areas on the accuracy of FPAR products in mixed pixels. The research results show that the GEOV1 FPAR product performs best in most cases, but users should consider the differences in different vegetation types and growth stages when choosing FPAR products.