Abstract:<ol class=""><li>The relative timing of growth and reproduction is an important driver of plant fitness. For deciduous woody species in temperate regions leaves and flowers both appear in the early spring, but the order and duration of these phenological events vary among species, populations, and individuals. Researchers have long hypothesized that this variation in flower-leaf sequences (FLSs) may be important−affecting the reproduction, recruitment and survival of individuals. Further, FLSs appear to be shifting with climate change; thus anticipating the extent of these shifts may influence projections of how climate change impacts species' performance and reshape forest communities.</li><li>Predicting FLS shifts requires an improved understanding of how environmental variation dictates FLS patterns. To address this, we compared the phenological responses of flowers and developing leaves for 10 temperate woody species to varying levels of temperature and photoperiod in a lab experiment. Our experimental design allowed us to test competing hypotheses for how environmental cues determine FLS variation| specifically whether forcing (warm temperatures) alone drives variation or differential sensitivity to chilling (cool temperatures generally in the fall/winter) and/or photoperiod matter.</li><li>Within species, we found that flower and leaf phenology responded with differential sensitivity to environmental cues, with differences in their response to chilling being the dominant driver of FLS variation. These differences between flowering and leaf responses were consistent across species, but because species differ in the order of phenological events in their FLSs (flowering-first vs. leafing-first), differences between flower and leaf phenology will have contrasting impacts on FLS variation across species. Simple projections of FLS shifts with climate change showed large shifts in species that flower before leafing, with flower-leaf interphases substantially shortened. For wind-pollinated species, this shorter interphase would reduce the time period for efficient pollen transfer, and thus raises the possibility that wind-pollinated taxa may experience reproductive declines due to FLS shifts.</li><li><i>Synthesis</i>. Our study provides strong evidence that flower and leaf phenology responds with differential sensitivity to environmental variation. Because climate change will amplify variability in temperature across time and space, our findings suggest that FLS shifts may be large, but are likely to vary substantially among populations and species. Our analyses indicate climate change will likely decrease flower-leaf interphases, especially in flowering-first species. FLS shifts are likely to affect fitness for some species more strongly than others, thereby impacting community structure and function as climate continues to change. </li></ol>

Similarities in butterfly emergence dates among populations suggest local adaptation to climate

Extensive regional variation in the phenology of insects and their response to temperature across North America.

Climate‐driven phenological shifts in emergence dates of British bees

Phenological variation in biotic interactions shapes population dynamics and distribution in a range-shifting insect herbivore

Tritrophic phenological match–mismatch in space and time

Predictable local adaptation in butterfly photoperiodism but not thermal performance along a latitudinal cline

Current and lagged climate affects phenology across diverse taxonomic groups

Sensitivity of Spring Phenology to Warming Across Temporal and Spatial Climate Gradients in Two Independent Databases

Phenological mismatch is less important than total nectar availability for checkerspot butterflies

Phenological sensitivity to climate across taxa and trophic levels

A global synthesis of animal phenological responses to climate change

Thermal plasticity in development and diapause strategy in a temperate butterfly across a latitudinal gradient

Simulated climate warming causes asymmetric responses in insect life-history timing potentially disrupting a classic ecological speciation system

Range geographies, not functional traits, explain convergent range and phenology shifts under climate change

Regional differences in thermoregulation between two European butterfly communities

Differences between flower and leaf phenological responses to environmental variation drive shifts in spring phenological sequences of temperate woody plants

Variation in temperature of peak trait performance constrains adaptation of arthropod populations to climatic warming

Advances in breeding phenology outpace latitudinal and elevational shifts for North American birds tracking temperature

Overwintering strategy regulates phenological sensitivity and consequences for ecological services in a clade of temperate North American insects

Spatial Nonstationarity in Phenological Responses of Nearctic Birds to Climate Variability

Migratory strategy drives species-level variation in bird sensitivity to vegetation green-up