Spatial Nonstationarity in Phenological Responses of Nearctic Birds to Climate Variability

Benjamin A. Tonelli,Casey Youngflesh,Tyler Cox,Montague H. C. Neate‐Clegg,Emily B. Cohen,Morgan W. Tingley
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ele.14526
IF: 11.274
2024-10-08
Ecology Letters
Abstract:Climate change is shifting the phenology of migratory animals earlier, but it is unclear how variable shifts are across populations, species and communities. In this study, we analyse 88,965 site‐specific arrival dates from 222 bird species over 21 years to investigate the role of temperature, snowpack, precipitation, the El‐Niño/Southern Oscillation and the North Atlantic Oscillation on the spring arrival timing of Nearctic birds. We find that sensitivity of arrival timing to climatic variation exhibited spatial nonstationarity, suggesting diverging responses to ongoing climatic changes at the population, species and community scale. Climate change is shifting the phenology of migratory animals earlier; yet an understanding of how climate change leads to variable shifts across populations, species and communities remains hampered by limited spatial and taxonomic sampling. In this study, we used a hierarchical Bayesian model to analyse 88,965 site‐specific arrival dates from 222 bird species over 21 years to investigate the role of temperature, snowpack, precipitation, the El‐Niño/Southern Oscillation and the North Atlantic Oscillation on the spring arrival timing of Nearctic birds. Interannual variation in bird arrival on breeding grounds was most strongly explained by temperature and snowpack, and less strongly by precipitation and climate oscillations. Sensitivity of arrival timing to climatic variation exhibited spatial nonstationarity, being highly variable within and across species. A high degree of heterogeneity in phenological sensitivity suggests diverging responses to ongoing climatic changes at the population, species and community scale, with potentially negative demographic and ecological consequences.
ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?