Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this paper is to find out what added value does the stakeholder performance concept bring with respect to that of corporate social performance. To better understand the developments of these concepts, the authors resort to Gallie’s theory (1956) of essentially contested concepts, the life-cycle model of Hirsch and Levin’s (1999) umbrella concepts. Reconciling these two theoretical frameworks allows us to introduce the competing category notion consisting of a dominant and a dominated-type concepts. Through a historical and synchronic literature examination, CSP is shown to have characteristics of the dominant type, thanks to its more diffuse character. On the other hand, the stakeholder performance would relate to the dominated type, though it provides better operationalization possibilities. Design/methodology/approach To better understand the developments of these concepts, Gallie’s theory (1956) of essentially contested concepts, the life cycle model of Hirsch and Levin’s (1999) umbrella concepts are used. Findings CSP has characteristics of the dominant type, thanks to its more diffuse character. On the other hand, the stakeholder performance relates to the dominated type, though it provides better operationalization. Originality/value CSP as a dominant type and stakeholder performance is a dominated type.

Research of the Corporate Performance Evaluation Indicators Based on the Stakeholder Theory

Individual Evaluation System on Corporate Social Responsibility Performance of Chinese Banking——On the Basis of Stakeholder Theory

Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation On Corporate Social Responsibility Performance From The Perspective Of Stakeholders

Research on Performance Evaluation of Public Sector Based on View of Stakeholders

Business Process Performance Management Based on Stakeholder Approach

The Theoretical Analysis and Empirical Research on the Relationship between Stakeholders and Enterprises’Financial Performance

A study of the evaluation model of investment projects' value based on the stakeholder theory

The Impact of Performance Feedback on Corporate Social Responsibility——Based on the Stakeholder Perspective,PAN Xiaoqing

Stakeholder Theory and Corporate Management

Organizational Performance Appraisal Model Based on Satisfaction of Multiple Stakeholders

Cooperate Performance Evaluation and Empirical Study on Added Value

Stakeholder Theory Based Performance Management in Universities

Stakeholder performance, corporate social performance

Development and Evaluation of Corporate Governance Models

Corporate Social Responsibility Performance-Evaluation Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process-Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation Model

A Study on the Relationship between Corporate Social Responsibility and Financial Performance

A Review of Stakeholder Analysis

Research on Corporate Social Performance Progress

Corporate Harmony,Stakeholders Governance and Corporate Performance

The Driving Force of Improving Coroparate Environmental Performance Based on the Stakeholder Theory