Men as cultural ideals: Cultural values moderate gender stereotype content.

Amy J. C. Cuddy,Elizabeth Baily Wolf,Peter Glick,Susan Crotty,Jihye Chong,Michael I. Norton
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/pspi0000027
IF: 8.46
2015-01-01
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
Abstract:Four studies tested whether cultural values moderate the content of gender stereotypes, such that male stereotypes more closely align with core cultural values (specifically, individualism vs. collectivism) than do female stereotypes. In Studies 1 and 2, using different measures, Americans rated men as less collectivistic than women, whereas Koreans rated men as more collectivistic than women. In Study 3, bicultural Korean Americans who completed a survey in English about American targets rated men as less collectivistic than women, whereas those who completed the survey in Korean about Korean targets did not, demonstrating how cultural frames influence gender stereotype content. Study 4 established generalizability by reanalyzing Williams and Best's (1990) cross-national gender stereotype data across 26 nations. National individualism-collectivism scores predicted viewing collectivistic traits as more-and individualistic traits as less-stereotypically masculine. Taken together, these data offer support for the cultural moderation of gender stereotypes hypothesis, qualifying past conclusions about the universality of gender stereotype content.
psychology, social
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to explore how cultural values moderate the content of gender stereotypes. Specifically, the author proposes a hypothesis: male stereotypes are more in line with the core values of a specific culture, while female stereotypes are not. This hypothesis is based on the following logic: in almost all societies, men have a higher status than women. Therefore, male stereotypes in each society should reflect the most core values of that culture. For example, in collectivist cultures, men should be stereotypically considered to have more collectivist traits; while in individualist cultures, men should be stereotypically considered to have more individualist traits. Through four studies, the author tests this hypothesis, aiming to reveal gender - stereotype differences in different cultural backgrounds and challenge past conclusions about the cross - cultural consistency of gender stereotypes.