‘Why more accounts do not mention flies’: Deconstruction, or the Corpse of Man Cut by the Insect
Sourav Kargupta
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13534645.2019.1607231
2019-04-03
Parallax
Abstract:1 See Derrida, Of Grammatology, especially the section titled "The Exorbitant. Question of Method," 157-164.2 Mani, Contentious Traditions, 7.3 A historical account of the 'sati debate' can be found in Mani, Contentious Traditions, based on her doctoral dissertation (1989), published in 1998, this is the text I read. For the context of the debate in the 1980s, see Sunder Rajan, "The Subject of Sati."4 Chaffin quoted in Mani, Contentious Traditions, 186.5 Mani, Contentious Traditions, 186.6 Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon." I am using the version printed in the edited volume, Material Events.7 Turner, "Insect Asides," 62.8 Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon," 331.9 Ibid.10 Derrida, "Ants," 19.11 Derrida, Limited Inc, 20.12 Derrida, Of Grammatology, 66.13 Ibid., 57.14 Ibid., 125.15 Derrida, Margins of Philosophy, 131.16 Derrida, Of Grammatology, 68.17 Ibid., 140.18 Spivak, "Can the Subaltern Speak?," 312n67. Also see Spivak's note to the revised version in Spivak, Critique, 285-286n133 for her disagreements with Mani.19 Mani, Contentious Traditions, 1. Mani italicizes 'sati' throughout her text.20 Satīdāha literally means the burning (dāha) of the devout widow (satī, literally, 'true wife', her truth content understood as contingent on patriarchal judgements), I have kept 'sati' also to mean the 'ritual' as is the case in most academic discussion. However, this reduction also carries marks of the colonial translations. The paleonymy of this word retains a connection with the Sanskrit word for 'being' or 'truth' (sat). For more on this 'slippage', see Spivak, "Can the Subaltern Speak?," 305.21 See ibid, 297.22 In Kargupta, "Precarious Objectifications."23 Sunder Rajan, "The Subject of Sati," 19.24 See Spivak, "Can the Subaltern Speak?," 297.25 Ibid., 306.26 Mani, Contentious Traditions, 79.27 See ibid., 163, 169.28 Ibid., 177.29 Ibid., 164.30 Ibid., 173.31 Ibid., 174.32 Ibid., 159.33 See ibid., 185. Also see Midgley, Feminism and Empire, 78.34 See Mani, 224n78. Chaffin's account is written after the colonial government clarified in 1813 that acts of 'sati' could be deemed 'legal' based on the reports of the official representatives, ibid., 19.35 Ibid., 186. W. Bampton's account is also 'significant', ibid, 185.36 Ibid., 181, 187.37 Chaffin quoted in ibid, 186.38 Ibid.39 Ibid.40 Derrida has critically read Martin Heidegger's idea that the 'animal' has no access to the propositional language ('apophantic') and therefore to the structure of the 'as such', see Derrida, The Animal That Therefore I Am, 156.41 Mani, Contentious Traditions, 186.42 Ibid.43 See Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon," 334.44 This paper is guided by Derrida's argument that 'phallogocentrism' works as an 'insurance against the return' to a general economy prior to its restrictions. See Derrida, "Choreographies," 103.45 Mani, Contentious Traditions, 185.46 Derrida, "Ants," 38. See the discussion below.47 Mani, Contentious Traditions, 187.48 Ibid., 177.49 Chaffin in ibid., 187.50 For Derrida's deconstruction of the Heideggerian thesis that 'The hand will be the (monstrous) sign [le monstre], the proper of man' see Derrida, "Geschlecht II: Heidegger's Hand," 168. 51 See Spivak, Aesthetic Education, 23.52 Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon," 353.53 Ibid., 350.54 Spivak, "Can the Subaltern Speak?," 302-303.55 Ibid., 300.56 Derrida, "Performative Powerlessness," 467.57 Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon," 334.58 See Derrida, Of Grammatology, 161-162.59 I borrow the term from Turner's "Insect Asides."60 Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon," 330-331. Derrida drops the reference to 'some insect or other', retaining only the reference to 'some animal or other' in a later version of "Typewriter Ribbon," see Without Alibi, 130. The translator notes that 'Derrida considerably revised the essay for publication', see ibid., 294.61 This and the next quotation, Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon," 331.62 Ibid.63 See ibid., 301, '("within such limits")' is also the second subtitle of "Typewriter Ribbon."64 Derrida, Without Alibi, 130-131. This sentence does not appear in the earlier version.65 Derrida, Limited Inc, 7.66 Ibid.67 Derrida, "Typewriter Ribbon," 331-332.68 See Turner, "Insect Asides," 64.69 'It comes […] to reading. […] As for […] the inedible itself', see Derrida, "Ants," 18-19.70 For Derrida's treatment of the word 'fourmi' see translator's notes, "Ants," 39-40.71 Ibid., 37.72 Ibid., 17.73 Ibid., 33.74 Ibid., 34.75 Ibid., 21-22.76 See Derrida, Animal, 156-157, see note 40 above.77 See Derrida, "Performative Powerlessness," 466-467.78 See Derrida, Animal, 127-133.79 Derrida, "Ants," 17.80 See ibid., 22, 34.81 Ibid., 29.82 Ibid., 20.83 Ibid., 29-Abstract Truncated-
cultural studies