Institutions, Semiotics And The Politics Of Subjectivity
Michael A. Peters
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9780748653690-025
2013-01-01
Abstract:ABSTRACT. This paper profiles the work of Felix Guattari as a leading thinker who has consistently throughout his lifetime focused on the question of subjectivity, examining its production especially in its collective forms and experimenting with approaches designed to enhance its value in the clinical situation. In a form of u0027institutional analysisu0027 Guattari experimented with a Freudian-Marxist concept of group tranversality as a counter-therapy to bourgeois individualism before employing a semiotic materialist approach drawing on the work of Gregory Bateson and the Danish linguist Louis Hjelmslev that enables him to go beyond Freud, Lacan and Marx, and eventually in experimental form of authorship with Deleuze, to talk of rhizomic structures that resists arborescent politics to favor horizontal, non-hierarchical and transspecies connections.Keywords: Guattari, subjectivity, Deleuze, semiotics, institutions, transversality, ecosophy1. IntroductionIf I begin with Pierre-Felix Guattari it is because I believe he embodies some of the themes and motifs that define the intellectual movement that we awkwardly name u0027poststructuralismu0027 and because in recent applications, developments and celebrations of the work of this group of intellectuals in the English-speaking world Guattari has been eclipsed by other more prominent thinkers and the radical nature of his work has been overlooked. Yet Guattariu0027s work illustrates and is emblematic of a number of distinctive aspects about the wider movement. He was consumed with the question of subjectivity, as he says in Chaosmosis (1992): "How to produce it, collect it, enrich it, reinvent it permanently in order to make it compatible with mutant Universes of value?" Guattari was a political activist, strongly inter- ventionist and his innovations and experiments emerged out of the clinical situation.The question of subjectivity runs through all of his works, from Psychoanalysis and Transversality, through Years of Winter (1980-1986) and Schizoanalytic Cartographies (1989), to his collaborations with Deleuze (Anti-Oedipus, 1972, A Thousand Plateaus, 1980 and What is Philosophy? 1991). In a strong sense the question of subjectivity is also a defining feature of poststructuralism although its treatment differs from Derridau0027s deconstruction of logocentrism in all its forms, to Lyotardu0027s u0027dissolutionu0027 of postmodern selves into Wittgensteinian u0027language gamesu0027 and Foucaultu0027s technologies, aesthetics and hermeneutics of the self. The question of subjectivity and the subject in contemporary French thought is referenced against the French tradition of interiority going back to Descartes and follows the lines of a progressive decentering of the humanist subject as u0027individualu0027 and u0027self principally through new understandings of language in its structuralist and semiotic modes of analysis. With reference to Nietzsche, Marx and Freud-the so-called masters of suspicions-these poststructuralist thinkers began to raise radical questions about the institutions of philosophy, psychoanalysis, the prison, the clinic, the school, the university and the disciplines, not to mention the factory and capitalism itself-in fact, as both Foucault and Deleuze express it, all institutions of enclosure based on the observation, surveillance and control of modernist spaces. The poststructuralist mode of analysis characterized by a Nietzschean rereading of Hegel, informed by Heideggeru0027s Nietzsche and shaped by Saussurean linguistics that privileged u0027langueu0027 (the language system) over u0027paroleu0027 (the individual speech act), ended up by recasting the humanist subject as a discursive creation of a system of meaning and signification.2. Institutional Analysis at La BordeFor Guattari the question of subjectivity was not primarily a theoretical or philosophical project but rather a problematic that emerged from his work as a practicing analyst. Guattari trained under Jacques Lacan and worked at the experimental psychiatric clinic of La Borde with Jean Oury who was also a student of Lacan. …