Abstract:Computational models enable scientists to understand observed dynamics, uncover rules underlying behaviors, predict experimental outcomes, and generate new hypotheses. There are countless modeling approaches that can be used to characterize biological systems, further multiplied when accounting for the variety of model design choices. Many studies focus on the impact of model parameters on model output and performance; fewer studies investigate the impact of model design choices on biological insight. Here we demonstrate why model design choices should be deliberate and intentional in context of the specific research system and question. In this study, we analyze agnostic and broadly applicable modeling choices at three levels—system, cell, and environment—within the same agent-based modeling framework to interrogate their impact on temporal, spatial, and single-cell emergent dynamics. We identify key considerations when making these modeling choices, including the (i) differences between qualitative vs. quantitative results driven by choices in system representation, (ii) impact of cell-to-cell variability choices on cell-level and temporal trends, and (iii) relationship between emergent outcomes and choices of nutrient dynamics in the environment. This generalizable investigation can help guide the choices made when developing biological models that aim to characterize spatial-temporal dynamics. Scientists often rely on computational models to identify the basic building blocks, and uncover interactions, underlying complex biological systems. These models have proven invaluable at enabling researchers to computationally test, refine, and generate new hypotheses that can then be experimentally validated. The impact of computational models is constrained by what we do not know about the biology and the limitations of our computer software and hardware. Scientists have to make choices about what to include or leave out in their models because of these limitations. In our study, we investigate the impact of select modeling choices on the outcomes of an agent-based model characterizing cell population dynamics. We focus this study on three types of modeling choices that are not often rigorously evaluated despite their prevalence across many different types of models: (1) system representation, (2) cell/agent variability, and (3) environment dynamics. We report how each of these modeling choices affects simulated emergent outcomes, specifically growth rate, symmetry, and cell cycle length. Our research emphasizes how crucial it is to carefully consider and communicate the impact of these choices when developing computational models.

Why Build Whole-Cell Models?

A Petri Nets-Based Framework for Whole-Cell Modeling

Emerging whole-cell modeling principles and methods

Centralizing data to unlock whole-cell models

Toward Modeling Metabolic State from Single-Cell Transcriptomics.

WholeCellViz: data visualization for whole-cell models

Computer-Aided Whole-Cell Design: Taking a Holistic Approach by Integrating Synthetic With Systems Biology

Building the next generation of virtual cells to understand cellular biology

Generative modeling and latent space arithmetics predict single-cell perturbation response across cell types, studies and species

How to Build the Virtual Cell with Artificial Intelligence: Priorities and Opportunities

Multi-Experiment Nonlinear Mixed Effect Modeling of Single-Cell Translation Kinetics after Transfection

Model design choices impact biological insight: Unpacking the broad landscape of spatial-temporal model development decisions

Modeling Biomolecular Networks In Cells Structures And Dynamics Introduction

Modeling and interpretation of single-cell proteogenomic data

From Gene to Whole Cell: Modeling, Visualization, and Analysis

Soft X‐ray tomograms provide a structural basis for whole‐cell modeling

Mapping, modeling, and reprogramming cell-fate decision making systems

Understanding the cell: Future views of structural biology

Multiscale 'Whole-Cell' Models to Study Neural Information Processing-New Insights from Fly Photoreceptor Studies

Evaluating computational efforts and physiological resolution of mathematical models of cardiac tissue

Data integration strategies for whole-cell modeling