Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to examine to what extent congruity between ethical attributes (i.e. product attributes with positive implications for the environment, human rights, social issues and animal welfare) and brand concept (i.e. the unique meaning associated with a brand in consumers’ minds) influences consumers’ evaluations of brands offering ethical attributes. Design/methodology/approach Four studies involving North American consumers empirically tested the moderation effect of brand concept on consumer evaluations of ethical attributes and the mediating role of perceived congruity. Findings This research finds an interactive effect of ethical attribute type and brand concept on brand evaluations, such that congruent ethical attribute–brand concept pairings (i.e. a utilitarian [symbolic] ethical attribute offered by a brand with a utilitarian [symbolic] brand concept) result in more favorable brand evaluations (Studies 1, 2, 3 and 4). Consumers’ perceptions of congruity between ethical attributes and brand concepts mediate this interactive effect (Studies 2 and 3). Moreover, a positive congruity effect of ethical attributes and brand concepts emerges at higher levels of conspicuous brand consumption (Study 4). Research limitations/implications It is important to acknowledge that the current research did not specifically consider the case of utilitarian and symbolic ethical attribute offerings by luxury brands. This is a question that is left to future investigations. Practical implications For marketing managers, findings indicate that brands gain from ethical attribute introductions only when these attributes are congruent with the brand concept. In addition, brands benefit to a greater extent from offering congruent ethical attributes when brand consumption is conspicuous. Originality/value The findings of this research contribute to the literature on the effect of ethical attributes on consumers’ responses to brands and highlight the importance of brands’ choice of ethical attributes.

Attribution of symbolic brand meaning: the interplay of consumers, brands and reference groups

Think Versus Feel: Two Dimensions of Brand Anthropomorphism: an Abstract

Brands as symbolic resources for the construction of identity

Collaboration between East and West: influence of consumer dialectical self on attitude towards co-brand personality traits

Reference Groups: Aspirational and Non-Aspirational Groups in Consumer Behavior

The Role of Imagination and Brand Personification in Brand Relationships

Relationship qualities of brand heritage: warmth, competence and the moderating roles of anthropomorphic factors

How Brands Acquire Cultural Meaning

Brands as Intentional Agents Framework: How Perceived Intentions and Ability Can Map Brand Perception

Examining process mechanism of celebrity attributes on brand advocacy

To partner or not? A study of co-branding partnership and consumers' perceptions of symbolism and functionality toward co-branded sport products

Think versus feel: two dimensions of brand anthropomorphism

Beauty lies in the eye of the beholder: consumers' and jobseekers' interpretations of the family business brand

How consumers define brand relationships: a prototype analysis

I am ashamed of my brand-self! Consumer-brand identification as a moderator of emotional reactions following symbol-laden brand failures

Ethical attribute and brand concept congruity enhances brand evaluations

Psychological Underpinnings of Brands

Role of corporate social responsibility authenticity in developing perceived brand loyalty: a consumer perceptions paradigm

How Do Reference Groups Influence Self-Brand Connections among Chinese Consumers?

Social media marketing and brand loyalty: exploring interrelationships through symmetrical and asymmetrical modeling

Brand communities: loyal to the community or the brand?