Abstract:Accurate assessment of animal emotion (affect) is an important goal in animal welfare science, and in areas such as neuroscience and psychopharmacology. Direct measures of conscious emotion are not available, so assessment of animal affect has relied on measures of the behavioural and physiological components of affective states. These are important indicators but have some limitations (e.g. measuring emotional arousal rather than valence (positivity vs negativity)). Human psychology research suggests that changes in cognitive function (information processing) can also be reliable indicators of emotional state (especially valence). For example, people in negative states attend to threats, retrieve negative memories, and make negative judgements about ambiguous stimuli more than happier people. Here we review a new research area investigating the possibility that such affect-induced ‘cognitive biases’ also occur in animals. We focus on a novel ‘judgement bias’ paradigm in which animals are trained that one cue predicts a positive event and another cue predicts a less positive/negative event, and are then presented with ambiguous (intermediate) cues. The hypothesis is that animals in a negative affective state will be more likely to respond to (‘judge’) these ambiguous cues as if they predict the negative event (a ‘pessimistic’ response), than animals in a more positive state. Recent studies of rats, dogs, rhesus monkeys, starlings and humans provide face-value support for this hypothesis. We discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the affect manipulation treatments used in these studies, and the possibility that treatment-induced changes in feeding motivation, general activity and learning are responsible for the effects observed, and we consider whether the type of bias observed and the precise design of the judgement bias task can provide information about different types of affective state. Judgement biases may result from the influence of affect on decision-making processes including attention to and perception of the ambiguous cue, evaluation of the value and probability (expected utility) of the outcomes of different responses, and action selection. Affect might also modulate general tendencies of loss, risk and ambiguity aversion, hence biasing decisions. We discuss these possibilities in relation to theory and findings from neurobiological and psychological studies of decision-making, in order to better understand the potential mechanisms underlying judgement biases. We conclude with some specific recommendations for study design and interpretation, and suggestions for future research in this area.

Emotion Evaluation and Response Slowing in a Non-Human Primate: New Directions for Cognitive Bias Measures of Animal Emotion?

Cognitive bias as an indicator of animal emotion and welfare: Emerging evidence and underlying mechanisms

Neural Responses During Emotion Transitions and Emotion Regulation

Evaluation of a novel translational task for assessing emotional biases in different species

Evidence That Emotion Mediates Social Attention in Rhesus Macaques

Consciousness, emotion and animal welfare: insights from cognitive science

Technology or ecology? New tools to assess cognitive judgement bias in mice

Cognitive Bias under Adverse and Rewarding Conditions: A Systematic Review of Rodent Studies

Application of Cognitive Bias Testing in Neuropsychiatric Disorders: A Mini-Review Based on Animal Studies

Social and nonsocial content differentially modulates visual attention and autonomic arousal in Rhesus macaques

Stress produces negative judgement bias in cuttlefish

Sensitivity to reward loss as an indicator of animal emotion and welfare

High emotional reactivity toward an experimenter affects participation, but not performance, in cognitive tests with common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus)

A repeated measures cognitive affective bias test in rats: comparison with forced swim test

Interoceptive Signals Bias Decision Making in Rhesus Macaques

Cognitive performance of grey mouse lemurs (Microcebus murinus) during a discrimination learning task: Effect of the emotional valence of stimuli

A chinrest-based approach to measure eye movements and experimental task engagement in macaques with minimal restraint

Behavioral inhibition in a translational nonhuman primate model: A pilot study of Kagan’s behavioral inhibition paradigm modified for use in infant rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta).

A translational rodent assay of affective biases in depression and antidepressant therapy

Investigating the Neural Correlates of Emotion–Cognition Interaction Using an Affective Stroop Task

Implicit measures of anthropomorphism: affective priming and recognition of apparent animal emotions