Chinese Private Corporate Philanthropy: Social Responsibility, Legitimacy Strategy, and the Role of Political Capital

Zongshi Chen,Yang Cao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/21620555.2015.1128815
2016-02-29
Chinese Sociological Review
Abstract:We integrate theories in the corporate social responsibility (CSR) literature and research on China’s post-socialist transition to examine charitable giving by Chinese private enterprises. Empirical analysis of data from a 2006 survey shows that private enterprise involvement in philanthropy is positively associated with their economic and ethical performances, and that it is also positively associated with the reception of government sanctions for poor environmental performance. These results support our arguments based on a synthesis of Carroll’s CSR model and the strategic legitimacy approach to corporate philanthropy. We also find that whereas private enterprises whose owners hold seats in political councils are more likely to donate to charity, those headed by former cadres do not appear to behave any differently. These findings shed new light on how political capital shapes corporate action. Finally, our analysis reveals remarkable differences between factors influencing firms’ decisions to contribute to charity and those influencing the amount of the charitable contribution. As such, our study advances the theoretical understanding of corporate philanthropy and enriches the empirical knowledge of firm behavior in post-socialist China.
sociology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the behavioral motives of Chinese private enterprises in charitable donations and their influencing factors. Specifically, the author integrates the corporate social responsibility (CSR) theory and the research on China's post - socialist transformation to explore the charitable donation behaviors of Chinese private enterprises. By analyzing the survey data in 2006, the paper aims to answer the following key questions: 1. **The relationship between economic and ethical performance and charitable donations**: The study examines whether the economic and ethical performance of private enterprises is positively correlated with their participation in charitable activities. According to Carroll's corporate social responsibility model, enterprises with good economic and ethical performance are more likely to make charitable donations because these enterprises have more resources and management attention that can be devoted to charitable activities. 2. **The relationship between government sanctions and charitable donations**: The study also explores whether the government penalties imposed on enterprises due to poor environmental performance will affect their charitable donation behaviors. According to the strategic legitimacy theory, enterprises that are punished by the government may restore their social legitimacy through charitable donations. 3. **The influence of political capital on charitable donations**: The paper further analyzes how the political backgrounds of enterprise owners affect their charitable donation behaviors. Specifically, are enterprise owners with political seats more inclined to make charitable donations, and do enterprise owners with former cadre backgrounds have different behavior patterns? 4. **The process of donation decision - making**: The study proposes a two - step decision - making model, that is, enterprises first decide whether to donate and then decide how much to donate. The author believes that these two decisions may be influenced by different factors, thus providing a more detailed theoretical framework to explain the charitable donation behaviors of enterprises. Through the exploration of these questions, the paper aims to deepen the understanding of corporate charitable donation behaviors and enrich the empirical knowledge about Chinese corporate behaviors.