Rethinking ‘ethnic’ soccer: the National Junior Challenge Cup and the transformation of American soccer’s identity (1935–1976)

Kevin Tallec Marston

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14660970.2016.1166777

2016-05-13

Soccer and Society

Abstract:This paper contends that the way in which the term ‘ethnic’ is applied to the history of soccer in America needs rethinking. Through a case study of the National Junior Challenge Cup (now know as the JP McGuire Cup), the country’s oldest ongoing competition across all youth sports, this paper examines the transformation of American soccer’s identity. The tournament began in 1935 and evolved from an initial constituency of ethnic, immigrant and Catholic youth clubs. Following societal demographic trends, the growing national participant base came from more suburban, middle-class neighbourhoods. The 1970s witnessed a paradigm change in youth soccer as the sport began to move closer to mainstream consciousness. The tournament is a window into the complexity of defining the term ‘ethnic’ and its individuals who straddled both ‘ethnic’ and ‘native’ worlds. This article explores the origins of soccer in America, the bridges between ethnic identity, immigration and the foreign-native cultural debate and Soccer Americana.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is that the application of the word "ethnic" in the history of American football needs to be re - thought. Specifically, by studying the historical case of the National Junior Challenge Cup (now known as the JP McGuire Cup), the paper explores the transformation of American football identity. This competition began in 1935 and was initially mainly composed of immigrant, ethnic and Catholic youth clubs. With the change of the social demographic structure, the participants gradually came from more suburban middle - class communities. By the 1970s, youth football began to move closer to the mainstream consciousness, marking a paradigm shift of American football from the periphery to the mainstream.

The core argument of the paper is that using the word "ethnic" to describe American football before the 1970s is too simplistic and ignores the complexity and diversity therein. For example, although many teams have obvious ethnic characteristics in their names, in fact, the backgrounds of the players are very diverse, including different ethnic groups, second - generation immigrants and so - called "native - born ethnics". Therefore, the paper calls for a more cautious and detailed use of the concept of "ethnic" in order to more accurately reflect the diversity and complexity of the history of American football.

By analyzing the competition records of the National Junior Challenge Cup, the backgrounds of the participants and relevant historical documents, the paper reveals the process of American football gradually expanding from the original ethnic, immigrant and Catholic communities to a wider middle - class community. This process not only reflects the change of the social demographic structure, but also shows the trend of American football gradually becoming a national sport.