Totality and the Dialectic in the Critical Theory of Fredric Jameson

Christopher Pawling
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137315236_7
2013-01-01
Abstract:Up to now we have been tracing the development of critical theory primarily in relationship to the European context, post 1968, focusing on the fate of continental Marxism and its interaction with poststructuralist and post-humanist currents of thought. We have noted that one of the key preoccupations of French theoreticians in particular was the perceived need to evade the political pitfalls posed by both an authoritarian capitalist state apparatus and those forces on the left which had traditionally opposed this French version of the bourgeois political formation through an over-centralized Stalinist Communist Party. Hence, for French critical intellectuals such as Derrida and, to a lesser extent, Badiou, the ‘deconstructionist’ attack on totalizing thought and what Derrida saw as the ‘metaphysical’ philosophy of dialectical materialism was a necessary precondition for an emancipatory politics. Only by destroying the ‘orthodoxy’ of what Derrida termed ‘de facto Marxism’ would the successors of May ’68 be able to escape the iron cage of an old, over-centralized order, which imprisoned politics, both on the left and the right.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?