Of Gray Vapors and Creeping Clouds: White (Male) Privilege as Blinding in Herman Melville’s “Benito Cereno”

Josep M. Armengol

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137482808_3

2014-01-01

Abstract:Most gender studies of Herman Melville’s fiction go back to Leslie Fiedler’s seminal study Love and Death in the American Novel (1960), wherein he defined Melville as one of the founding fathers of the “men without women” fictions that, in his view, pervade and define classic American literature. Indeed, Fiedler analyzed the friendship between Ishmael and Queequeg in Moby-Dick as a prototypical example for the centrality of male homosocial relations to the literary canon. Rather than women, “the mirror-image of the self,” he famously argued, “is translated in the American novel … into the comrade of one’s own sex, the buddy as anima” (Fiedler 348). Yet, despite and beyond the continued view of Melville as “the master of male bonding narratives” (Wiegman 187), several feminist readings have set out to challenge such a traditional assumption, emphasizing the relevance of women to his works. Wilma Garcia, for example, contends that there exist “female-related patterns of symbolism in Moby-Dick” (60), just as Leland S. Person Jr. has questioned the assumption that Melville wrote only “in the masculine” (Aesthetic 17).1 Indeed, Person insists that Melville, uneasy with prevailing assumptions about gender, used female character types to challenge conventional notions of masculinity.