Abstract:In addition domestic R&D investment,China has been relying on international R&D spillovers from the developed country to grow its economy.International spillovers consist of international trade,foreign direct investment(FDI),and direct(intangible) spillovers.Intangible spillovers include reverse engineering,students returning from foreign countries,dialog between academic researchers,information exchange through electronic means,academic journals,and international conferences,and so on.Researchers begin paying attention to direct R&D spillovers in addition to trade and FDI. Based on Coe and Helpman's(1995) proposed model,we evaluate the contribution of domestic and direct foreign R&D stocks to the total factor productivity(TFP) of different provinces in China.First evaluation result shows that the elasticity of TFP to the domestic R&D stock is between 0.34 and 0.47.This finding implies that domestic R&D investment is the major source of technological improvement in China.Second evaluation result shows that the elasticity of TFP to the direct foreign R&D stock is 0.06.This finding implies that direct foreign R&D spillovers have significant impact on TFP.However,its impact on TFP is weaker than that of domestic R&D investment.Third evaluation result shows that the domestic and direct foreign R&D stocks are complementary for TFP growth. The previous research primarily analyzes the effect of technology spillovers on OLS method.These studies have the major limitation that the impact of independent variables(IVs) on conditional dependent variable(DV) at different locations is assumed to be constant.According to the assumption,the mean estimate of OLS cannot reflect the differential impact of IVs on the conditional DV at difference locations. Is the impact of direct foreign R&D spillovers on the TFP in thirty provinces constant even though so much provinces heterogeneity exists? The quantile regression helps to answer this question.The results show that when TTP's quantile increases,the elasticity of TFP to direct foreign R&D stocks decreases dramatically from 0.14 and 0.02.This indicates that the contribution of direct foreign R&D spillovers to the TFP decreases while the TFP rises.There are two possible reasons for this negative correlation.First,imitative innovation is more difficult in provinces with higher TFP than in those with lower TFP. Second,direct international R&D spillovers have some limitations.Different from technology imports and patents purchases,direct technology spillovers is not effective for developing countries,such as China,to acquire critical technologies.This finding indicates that non-critical and general technological knowledge obtained through direct technology spillovers has higher effect on the growth of TFP in provinces with lower TFP than that in provinces with higher TFP.

Regional spillover research and development investment: A geographically weighted regression approach

A Study on the Effect of Spillovers of Foreign Direct Investment to Chinese Industrial Technological Innovation

Innovation,Innovation Spillover and Economic Growth ——Empirical Study based on Spatial Econometrics Model and Panel Model

Spatial Spillovers of Regional Innovation: Evidence from Chinese Provinces

Growth spillover: a spatial dynamic panel data and spatial cross section data approaches in selected Asian countries

On the Spillovers Between Regions or Manufacturing Industries in China

The productivity impact of R&D and FDI spillovers: characterising regional path development

Spillover or Agglomeration：Regional Linkage of R & D Efficiency in China

Spillover effects of globalization using alternative spatial approaches

Direct International R&D Spillover and Total Factor Productivity in China: Empirical Research Based on Quantile Regression

R&D, Human Capital and International Technology Spillovers: A Cross‐country Analysis

International technology diffusion and economic growth: Explaining the spillover benefits to developing countries

An empirical analysis of R&D cooperation and regional knowledge spillovers based on knowledge production function

Empirical research on spillover effects of regional innovation——analysis based on dynamic panel model of Beyond knowledge production function

Spatial externalities, R&D spillovers, and endogenous technological change

Effects of Indigenous R&D and Foreign Spillover on Energy Intensity in China

Foreign Direct Investment and Productivity Growth in Eastern European Countries

The role of R&D and knowledge spillovers in innovation and productivity

International R&D spillovers and institutions

Seek foreign funds or technology? Relative impacts of different spillover modes on innovation

Spillover Effect of University on Regional Innovation Efficiency: Empirical Analysis Based on the Stochastic Frontier Production Function