Abstract:Employees who perceive their supervisors to listen well enjoy multiple benefits, including enhanced well-being. However, concerns regarding the construct validity of perceived-listening measures raise doubts about such conclusions. The perception of listening quality may reflect two factors: constructive and destructive listening, which may converge with desired (e.g., humility) and undesired (e.g., rudeness) supervisor-subordinate relationship behaviors, respectively, and both may converge with relationship quality (e.g., trust). Therefore, we assessed the convergent validity of four perceived listening measures and their divergent validity with eight measures of supervisor-subordinate relationship behaviors, eight relationship-quality measures, and a criterion measure of well-being. Using data from 2,038 subordinates, we calculated the disattenuated correlations and profile similarities among these measures. The results supported convergent but not divergent validity: 58.7% (12.6%) of the correlations expected to diverge had confidence intervals with upper limits above 0.80 (0.90), and 20% of their profile-similarity indices were close to 1. To probe these correlations, we ran a factor analysis revealing good and poor relationship factors and an exploratory graph analysis identifying three clusters: positive and negative relationship behaviors and relationship quality. A post-hoc analysis indicated that relationship-quality mediates the effect of the positive and negative behaviors on well-being. The results demonstrate the challenge of differentiating the perception of listening from commonly used supervisor-subordinate relationship constructs, and cast doubts on the divergent validity of many constructs of interest in Organizational Behavior. However, using the "sibling" constructs framework may allow disentangling these highly correlated relationship constructs, conceptually and empirically.

The Power of Listening at Work

Echo ‘our’ Voice? the Influences of Team Members on the Voice Behavior of Focal Employees

How (if at All) do Perceptions of Supervisor's Listening Differ from General Relationship Quality?: Psychometric Analysis

Listening to understand: The role of high-quality listening on speakers' attitude depolarization during disagreements

Linking Colleague Support To Employees' Promotive Voice: A Moderated Mediation Model

How Does Emotional Labor Influence Voice Behavior? the Roles of Work Engagement and Perceived Organizational Support

Getting Ahead by Speaking Up: the Moderating Role of Team Goal Orientation

Listen to resonate: Better listening as a gateway to interpersonal positivity resonance through enhanced sensory connection and perceived safety

Why people listen: Motivations and outcomes of podcast listening

Effective Team Leader and Interpersonal Communication Skills

What Does It Take for Voice Opportunity to Lead to Creative Performance? Supervisor Listening As a Boundary Condition

The Voice Link: A Moderated Mediation Model of How Ethical Leadership Affects Individual Task Performance

The power of sound: unravelling how acoustic communication shapes group dynamics

We think, we do, and vice versa: Reciprocal effects of team collective perception of voice importance for leaders and team voice

Speaking Up vs. Being Heard: The Disagreement Around and Outcomes of Employee Voice

The challenge of listening: The effect of researcher agenda on data collection and interpretation

Unlocking the Power of Listening

What Employees Can Get after They Voice Toward Their Supervisors?

Psychoanalytic listening II

Discourse-based intervention for modifying supervisory communication as leverage for safety climate and performance improvement: A randomized field study.

Developing Listening and Oral Expression Skills: Pillars of Influential Oral Communication