Soldiers' Voices in In Our Time: Hemingway's Ventriloquism

Milton A. Cohen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/hem.2000.0005
2000-01-01
The Hemingway Review
Abstract:Soldiers in In Our Time encompass three nationalities, several ranks, three battle theaters, and two wars. Critics tend to over-simplify this diversity, hearing only one British voice, and reducing American voices into variants of "the" Nick Adams experience. This conflation blurs real differences in the soldiers' personalities, war experiences, psychological reactions, and in the several prose styles Hemingway constructed to express these differences. Although experimental, this diversity is also Hemingway's commentary on the need for war writing to resist cliché, stereotype, and paradigm.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?