Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to summarize the conditions under which participatory art museums and local commercial traditions can have positive and sustained interactions. Design/methodology/approach The methods include studying the quantity and content of exhibitions in the four cities of the Bay Area, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Hong Kong and Shunde, to compare their academic positioning and influence on local commercial production. Through interviewing curators, artists and university scholars who are active in the Bay Area and are invited by the museums on a regular basis, it will let us understand the attitudes from the government, public and capital towards the regional art museums and how these attitudes influence the choice of theme in the participatory art museum practice. Findings To summarize the findings, the author concludes that a participatory art gallery with commercial production in the Bay Area requires the following: a long tradition of local business and wealth accumulation; a local area is of a size where the community of acquaintances can interact on a regular basis; continued interest of a diverse local elite, including a mix of businessmen and gentry, government officials and various sectors of the public; and museums serving as intermediaries to coordinate the effective integration of the commercial and traditional resources. Originality/value Participatory approaches and their impacts are a shared area of interest across urban planning, heritage studies and the creative arts. Crucially, solely relying on either the Latin bottom-up community-oriented approach (Barnes, 2003) or the British top-down policy-oriented approach (Heijnen, 2010) did not maximize benefits, though these distinctive two approaches were convinced that museums should play a larger role in becoming agents of contemporary social change. By contrast, in focusing on Chinese Art Museums, this study will explore participatory practice in the Asian context. In doing so, it will not only diversify the emerging literature on the social and economic impacts of arts and heritage organizations but also challenge the Western lens through which participatory approaches are viewed in the interdisciplinary literature. As Lefebvre acknowledged his lack of non-Western regions in his research, this study will offer new perspectives on museology and its contributions to the Production of Space.

Cultural, Business, and Political Characteristics of Hong Kong Street Art: A Mini Review

Power, capital, and artistic freedom: contemporary Chinese art communities and the city

Disruption, Digitalization and Connectivity: Asia's Art Market in Transformation

The Facelift of Singapore Chinatown: Unbalanced Renovation by Radical Western Wave

Brand Hong Kong: Asia's World City as Method?

Art and power in the new China: An exploration of Beijing's 798 district and its implications for contemporary urbanism

Integrating Regional Culture into Public Art within the Metro Public Space

The Mechanism of Street Markets Fostering Supportive Communities in Old Urban Districts: A Case Study of Sham Shui Po, Hong Kong

The Socio-cultural Significance of Street Art in Urban Recreation Spaces

The impact of global cities' cultural facilities - Inspiration for Shenzhen

The Vertical Street as Everyday Place in the High-Density City: A Case Study of Mong Kok, Hong Kong

Examining the gray cube effect on naïve viewers' appreciation of street-based art in Hong Kong and Poland

Is Street Art Good or Bad for You?

Tourists’ experience of iconic public art in Macau

An Analysis of Hong Kong Commercial Culture under the Influence of Mainland Visitors

An exploration of a third participatory museology approach in the interaction with local business and tradition at the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area art museums

Contemporary Art in Public Spaces: Forms of Expression, Social Significance, and Revitalization

Exploring creative class mobility: Hong Kong creative workers in Shanghai and Beijing

URBAN RESONANCE: Reconsideration of Public Art and Civic Spaces in Financial Districts in the Post-COVID-19 Era

Unfolding China’s Urban Development: The Implementation of Public Art in Beijing and Shanghai

Inside Hong Kong’s Arts and Cultural Scene: Conversations with Hong Kong’s Leading Arts and Cultural Administrators, Educators, Producers, and Presenters, Patrick Lo, Rebekah Okpoti, Wei-En Hsu, Hermina G. B. Anghelescu and Dickson K. W. Chiu (2023)