A Case Study of Critical Reasons Behind Hospital Nurses Turnover Due to Challenges Across System Levels
Andrea Eriksson,Patrik Vulkan,Lotta Dellve
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/JMDH.S363390
2022-05-25
Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare
Abstract:Andrea Eriksson, 1 Patrik Vulkan, 2 Lotta Dellve 2 1 Division of Ergonomics, Department of Biomedical Engineering and Health Systems, Royal Institute of Technology KTH, Huddinge, Sweden; 2 Department of Sociology and Work Science, University of Gothenburg, Gothenburg, Sweden Correspondence: Andrea Eriksson, Division of Ergonomics, Department of Biomedical Engineering and Health Systems, Royal Institute of Technology KTH, Hälsovägen 11, Huddinge, 141 57, Sweden, Tel +46-8-7909804, Email Purpose: The aim of this study was to analyze how critical factors at different levels in a health-care system interact and impact nurses' intention to leave and decision to quit their job at a hospital unit. Methods: A case study of assistant and registered nurses' intentions to leave as well as staff turnover at a smaller Swedish public hospital was performed. Employee surveys and interviews with assistant and registered nurses who had quit their job at four units in the hospital during the period 2012– 2019 were performed. Critical factors regarding nurses' intention to leave and staff turnover are analyzed by combining narrative methods with a critical incidence technique. Results: Three main themes emerge from the analysis of factors contributing to the decision to quit, namely lack or loss of buffering factors, not owning your spare time and not feeling valued by and listened to by upper management . Conclusion: Decision-makers, including hospital management, need to consider how supportive factors in nurses' closest work environment that promote staff retention may be impacted by decisions at higher levels, such as health-care reorganizations and stricter governance. In this context, upper management adopting a servant leadership approach might contribute to employees to a greater extent feeling valued and being listened to. Finally, the results indicate that individual nurses' recovery, ability to work and ability to coordinate their personal life with their work life need to be supported by policies and decisions at higher levels in order to retain nurses in intensive and emergency health-care settings. Keywords: case study, health care, intention to leave, system theory Nursing shortages and staff turnover have been identified as one of the greatest threats regarding both employee health and patient safety in the health-care sector worldwide. 1,2 Recent studies imply that nurses turnover intention has increased significantly during the COVID-19 pandemic 3,4 with workplace stress as one of the main contributing predictors of turnover decisions. 3 This is alarming since statistics in Sweden indicate an existing shortage of nurses with both basic and specialized training. 5 However, nurses who quit a specific health-care workplace do not necessarily leave the nursing profession. A study shows that about 90% of registered nurses (RNs) in Sweden remain in the profession. The same study, however, also indicates that an increased proportion of RNs leave workplaces in Swedish regions, including hospitals, in order to work for other health-care providers. 6 A Swedish study shows that 50% of those quitting a hospital unit move on to another hospital unit, 40% move on to an external employer and 10% retire. 7 Some Swedish regions do not report the same difficulties in terms of recruiting assistant nurses, but the shortage of assistant nurses is still expected to accelerate over the next 10 years, which means that Sweden can expect a general shortage of assistant nurses in the coming years. 5 Numerous previous survey studies have identified factors correlated to staff turnover and the intention of nurses to leave. 2,8–10 However, there is also research indicating that intentions to leave and staff turnover do not always necessarily depend on the occurrence of single factors at a specific point in time, but could in many cases rather be seen as a result of individual and organizational factors interacting over a longer period of time. 2,11 There is, however, a shortage of studies on staff turnover based on this kind of system perspective. 12,13 This study adopts a narrative approach to achieve a deeper understanding of critical factors at different levels of health-care systems that over time contribute to intentions to leave and, consequently, actual staff turnover. These results are important for identifying relevant measures at different levels in a health-care system to prevent staff turnover. A system approach to staff turnover requires a broad consideration of how factors and conditions in the individual life situation (individual level) interact with circumstances in the -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services