The legitimation of the European Union in the news media: three treaty reform debates

Achim Hurrelmann,Anna Gora,Andrea Wagner
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13501763.2012.726478
IF: 4.366
2012-10-05
Journal of European Public Policy
Abstract:The news media is a major forum for the discursive legitimation of the EU. This article analyses media debates in the context of three attempts at reforming EU primary law in the past decade: the Nice Treaty; the Constitutional Treaty; and the Lisbon Treaty. Focusing on four member states – the United Kingdom, Ireland, Germany and Austria – our study shows that the EU's legitimacy is discursively constructed according to distinct patterns, most of which are remarkably similar across countries and stable over time. In the context of the EU Constitution, legitimation debates became more intensive and more critical; however, these developments were largely reversed when the Lisbon Treaty was debated. This suggests that, in the media arena, the much-discussed politicization of European integration is an episodic occurrence, rather than a unidirectional trend.
public administration,political science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?