Abstract:Enhancement of forest net primary production (NPP) as atmospheric [CO2] increases is likely limited by the availability of other growth resources, yet few ecosystem‐scale experiments include both elevated [CO2] (eCO2) and nutrient amendments. The Duke Free Air CO2 Enrichment experiment, in a mixed pine‐hardwood stand, combined eCO2 with nitrogen (N) additions. Averaged over 1997–2010, the stand NPP was 38% higher under eCO2 compared to ambient conditions. Nitrogen additions under eCO2 resulted in an additional 11% increase in pine NPP. The observed sustained NPP enhancement under over 15 years of eCO2, even without N‐additions, demonstrates no progressive N limitation. Enhancement of net primary production (NPP) in forests as atmospheric [CO2] increases is likely limited by the availability of other growth resources. The Duke Free Air CO2 Enrichment (FACE) experiment was located on a moderate‐fertility site in the southeastern US, in a loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) plantation with broadleaved species growing mostly in mid‐canopy and understory. Duke FACE ran from 1994 to 2010 and combined elevated [CO2] (eCO2) with nitrogen (N) additions. We assessed the spatial and temporal variation of NPP response using a dataset that includes previously unpublished data from 6 years of the replicated CO2 × N experiment and extends to 2 years beyond the termination of enrichment. Averaged over time (1997–2010), NPP of pine and broadleaved species were 38% and 52% higher under eCO2 compared to ambient conditions. Furthermore, there was no evidence of a decline in enhancement over time in any plot regardless of its native site quality. The relation between spatial variation in the response and native site quality was suggested but inconclusive. Nitrogen amendments under eCO2, in turn, resulted in an additional 11% increase in pine NPP. For pine, the eCO2‐induced increase in NPP was similar above‐ and belowground and was driven by both increased leaf area index (L) and production efficiency (PE = NPP/L). For broadleaved species, coarse‐root biomass production was more than 200% higher under eCO2 and accounted for the entire production response, driven by increased PE. Notably, the fraction of annual NPP retained in total living biomass was higher under eCO2, reflecting a slight shift in allocation fraction to woody mass and a lower mortality rate. Our findings also imply that tree growth may not have been only N‐limited, but perhaps constrained by the availability of other nutrients. The observed sustained NPP enhancement, even without N‐additions, demonstrates no progressive N limitation.

An alpine treeline in a carbon dioxide-rich world: synthesis of a nine-year free-air carbon dioxide enrichment study

Carbon budget of Pinus sylvestris saplings after four years of exposure to elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration

Lack of photosynthetic or stomatal regulation after 9 years of elevated [CO2] and 4 years of soil warming in two conifer species at the alpine treeline

Chemistry and long-term decomposition of roots of Douglas-fir grown under elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide and warming conditions.

Quantification of ecosystem C dynamics in a long-term FACE study on permanent grassland

Decoupling of plant carbon and nitrogen under elevated CO2 and nitrogen addition in a typical alpine ecosystem

Increased leaf area index and efficiency drive enhanced production under elevated atmospheric [CO2] in a pine‐dominated stand showing no progressive nitrogen limitation

Elevated Atmospheric CO2 Modifies Mostly the Metabolic Active Rhizosphere Soil Microbiome in the Giessen FACE Experiment

Elevated CO 2 decreases soil carbon stability in Tibetan Plateau

Isotopic evidence for increased carbon and nitrogen exchanges between peatland plants and their symbiotic microbes with rising atmospheric CO2 concentrations since 15,000 cal. year BP

Stimulation of soil respiration by elevated CO<sub>2</sub> is enhanced under nitrogen limitation in a decade-long grassland study

Links across ecological scales: Plant biomass responses to elevated CO2

The stimulatory effect of elevated CO2 on soil respiration is unaffected by N addition

Experimental soil warming shifts the fungal community composition at the alpine treeline

Carbon allocation in early successional tree species at elevated air humidity and different soil nitrogen sources

Forest stand and canopy development unaltered by 12 years of CO2 enrichment

No cumulative effect of 10 years of elevated [CO2 ] on perennial plant biomass components in the Mojave Desert

Interactive effects of elevated CO2, warming, and drought on photosynthesis of Deschampsia flexuosa in a temperate heath ecosystem

Divergent Responses of Forest Soil Microbial Communities under Elevated CO2 in Different Depths of Upper Soil Layers.

Long-term variation of tree growth and intrinsic water-use efficiency in Schrenk spruce with increasing CO2 concentration and climate warming in the western Tianshan Mountains, China

Elevated Co2 Influences Microbial Carbon and Nitrogen Cycling