Abstract:Cooperation is essential for society’s functioning, while reciprocity is one of the most critical factors for establishing and maintaining cooperative social relationships. Until now, however, the majority of studies exploring human social cooperation were in a sharing gain frame. The present study investigates the behavioral effects and neural correlates of other people’s prior history of reciprocal reputation on cooperative decisions in both gain and loss contexts. 39 Chinese adult subjects participated in the study. Participants first played a Trust Game as Trustee to understand how we quantify the reciprocal reputation and then joined a modified Public Goods Game framed in gain and loss contexts with partners with various reciprocity levels. Behaviorally, individuals tended to be more cooperative with higher reciprocal reputation partners than lower ones, contributing a higher percentage of gain and a lower percentage of loss to the public pool. This effect was robust, especially in the gain context. Trial-wise mixed-effect regression results further demonstrated that the reciprocal reputation on cooperative decisions was more salient in the gain context than the loss context. Neurally, trial-wise parametric modulation analysis revealed two distinct neural systems that right anterior insula in the gain context and bilateral superior parietal lobule (SPL, including precuneus), left inferior parietal lobule (IPL), bilateral superior frontal gyrus (SFG), are positively correlated with partner’s reciprocal reputation. Based on the behavioral and neural results, we propose that individuals use a social heuristic preference-based mechanism in the gain context while involving more strategic or reasoning concerns in the loss context in processing others’ social reputation when making cooperative decisions in PGG. Furthermore, during the decision phase, cooperating with higher reputation individuals in the gain context increased the bilateral striatum activation, and the activation in the bilateral striatum function as a neural modulator of this effect only in the gain context. Finally, parametric modulation analysis using contribution as the modulator revealed the dorsal anterior cingulate context (dACC) in the gain context that suggested that the prefrontal cortex plays a vital role in computing the action values while making decisions in PGG. The current results contribute empirical evidence to our understanding of human cooperation from a new angle, through social interactions in a loss frame.

Selfish learning is more important than fair-minded conditional cooperation in public-goods games

Self-interested learning is more important than fair-minded conditional cooperation in public-goods games

Cooperation and Charity in Spatial Public Goods Game under Different Strategy Update Rules

Conditional cooperation and confusion in public-goods experiments

A preference to learn from successful rather than common behaviours in human social dilemmas

The restart effect in social dilemmas shows humans are self-interested not altruistic

Prosocial preferences do not explain human cooperation in public-goods games

Explaining Cooperative Behavior in Public Goods Games: How Preferences and Beliefs Affect Contribution Levels

Learning Fair Cooperation in Mixed-Motive Games with Indirect Reciprocity

Cooperate without looking: why we care what people think and not just what they do

Asymmetric effects of social and economic incentives on cooperation in real effort based public goods games

Confusion cannot explain cooperative behavior in public goods games

Cooperation and confusion in public goods games: confusion cannot explain contribution patterns

The Strategy Method Risks Conflating Confusion with a Social Preference for Conditional Cooperation in Public Goods Games

Cooperation and self-regulation in a model of agents playing different games

Beyond a binary theorizing of prosociality

Social preferences and the variability of conditional cooperation

To qualify as a social partner, humans hide severe punishment, although their observed cooperativeness is decisive

Translucent Players: Explaining Cooperative Behavior in Social Dilemmas

Changes in Cooperative Behaviour and Belief in Finitely Repeated Social Dilemmas

Distinct behavioral effects and neural mechanisms of reciprocal reputation on cooperative decision-making in gain and loss context