Abstract:Many practitioners as well as researchers explore promoting environmentally conscious behavior in the context of public goods systems. Numerous experimental studies revealed various types of incentives to increase cooperation on public goods. There is ample evidence that monetary and non-monetary incentives, such as donations, have a positive effect on cooperation in public goods games that exceeds fully rational and optimal economic decision making. Despite an accumulation of these studies, in the typical setting of these experiments participants decide on an allocation of resources to a public pool, but they never exert actual effort. However, in reality, we often observe that players’ real effort is required in these public goods game situations. Therefore, more analysis is needed to draw conclusions for a wider set of incentive possibilities in situations similar to yet deviating from resource allocation games. Here we construct a real effort public goods game in an online experiment and statistically analyze the effect different types of incentives have on cooperation. In our experiment, we examine combinations of monetary and social incentives in a setting aimed closer to practical realities, such as financial costs and real effort forming part of the decision to cooperate on a public good. In our real effort public goods game participants cooperate and defect on image-scoring tasks. We find that in our setting economic and social incentives produce an asymmetric effect. Interestingly economic incentives decreased the share of highly uncooperative participants, while social incentives raised the share of highly cooperative participants.

Tacit Coordination in Games with Third-Party Externalities

Some coordination problems are harder than others

Externality as a coordination problem

The Evolution of Cooperation in Spatial Multigame with Voluntary Participation

Choice overload, coordination and inequality: three hurdles to the effectiveness of the compensation mechanism?

Tacit Cooperation

Learning to Mitigate Externalities: the Coase Theorem with Hindsight Rationality

Cooperation and Coordination in Threshold Public Goods Games with Asymmetric Players

The Effect of Loss-Aversion on Strategic Behaviour of Players in Divergent Interest Tacit Coordination Games

Cooperation and self-regulation in a model of agents playing different games

Bounded Rationality in Volunteering Public Goods Games.

On the coordination efficiency of strategic multi-agent robotic teams

Asymmetric effects of social and economic incentives on cooperation in real effort based public goods games

Cooperation and Control in Multiplayer Social Dilemmas

The Effect of Bounded Rationality on Human Cooperation with Voluntary Participation

The co-determination decision game with consumption externalities

Cooperation and Coordination in Heterogeneous Populations with Interaction Diversity.

Position uncertainty in a sequential public goods game: an experiment

Group size effect on cooperation in social dilemmas

Tournaments as coordination devices: Theory and experimental evidence

Coordination Behavior in Mode Choice: Laboratory Study of Equilibrium Transformation and Selection