Abstract:Individuals often preferentially avoid information that contradicts and seek information that aligns with their prior beliefs-a tendency referred to as "selective exposure." Traditionally, prior research has focused on intrapersonal drivers of selective exposure, including avoidance of cognitive dissonance. We take a complementary approach by investigating the conditions under which interpersonal concerns drive selective exposure. Drawing on a large literature on impression management, we test a social signaling model of selective exposure, which predicts that (a) individuals shift their information selection decisions to signal to observers and (b) observers reward such shifts. We test this model in the domain of partisan politics in the United States across five financially incentivized, preregistered experiments (N = 3,598). Our results extend prior theory by identifying three key contingencies: the type of task on which observers expect to collaborate with actors, alignment of group membership between observers and actors, and the magnitude of demonstrated selective exposure. Overall, we find that tailoring one's information selection decisions can indeed have strategic value-but only under certain theoretically predictable conditions. Our work also identifies an actor-observer misalignment: While observers are sensitive to the type of future interaction with an actor, the actors themselves do not intuit this sensitivity. In the era of social media, when information selection decisions are more public than ever and the spread of misinformation is pervasive, understanding the ways in which reputational considerations shape decision making not only illuminates why selective exposure persists, but also suggests novel mitigation strategies. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).

Ethnic Selective Exposure: A Test of Cultural-Identity Based Media Selectivity Theory

Selective exposure in different political information environments – How media fragmentation and polarization shape congruent news use

News or Noticias: A Social Identity Approach to Understanding Latinos’ Preferred Language for News Consumption in the United States

The importance of the analytic approach to the Multigroup Ethnic Identity Measure in the study of Hispanic media behaviour

Ethnic Identity, Self-Esteem, and Ethnocentrism: A Study of Social Identity Versus Multicultural Theory of Development.

Are you always ignoring attitude-challenging messages? Eye-tracking selective exposure on Chinese’ lowly involved news consumption

The contingent reputational benefits of selective exposure to partisan information.

Who is Willing to Learn About Inequality? Predictors of Choice Exposure to Messaging About Racial Disparities in Air Pollution Effects Among Black and White U.S. Residents

Ethnic identity, socialization factors, and culture-specific consumption behavior

Bridging Segregation Via Media Exposure? Ingroup Identification, Outgroup Distance, and Low Direct Contact Reduce Outgroup Appearance in Media Repertoires

How Language Usage Shapes the Public Acceptance of Immigrant Assimilation: the Case of China

Ethnic Identity: The Domain of Perceptions of and Attachment to Ethnic Groups and Cultures

Effective Cross-cultural Advertising: Moderating Roles of Ethnic Identity and Religiosity in Pitching Controversial Vs. Non-controversial Products to Diasporic Communities

Media, Racial Identity, and Mainstream American Values

The impact of cultural symbols and spokesperson identity on attitudes and intentions

Seeing Red (And Blue): Partisan Identity, Emotions, and Selective Exposure

Cantonese media promotes Chinese cultural identification: structural equation modeling based on Malaysian Chinese

Media-Based Health Information Seeking Behaviors Among Latinx Populations in the United States

Cultural Identity Configurations: A Latent Profile Analysis of Ethnic/Racial and U.S. Identity Process and Content

Influence of Selective Exposure to Viewing Contents Diversity

Ideological self-selection in online news exposure: Evidence from Europe and the US