Abstract:Rainfall-Runoff simulation is the backbone of all hydrological and climate change studies. This study proposes a novel stochastic model for daily rainfall-runoff simulation called Stacked Long Short-Term Memory (SLSTM) relying on machine learning technology. The SLSTM model utilizes only the rainfall-runoff data in its modelling approach and the hydrology system is deemed a blackbox. Conversely, the distributed and physically-based hydrological models, e.g., SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) preserve the physical aspect of hydrological variables and their inter-relations while taking a wide range of data. The two model types provide specific applications that interest modelers, who can apply them according to their project specification and objectives. However, sparse distribution of point-data may hinder physical models’ performance, which may not be the case in data-driven models. This study proposes a specific SLSTM model and investigates the SLSTM and SWAT models’ data dependency in terms of their spatial distribution. The study was conducted in the two distinct river basins of Samarahan and Trusan, Malaysia, with over 20 years of hydro-climate data. The Trusan basin’s rain gauges are scattered downstream of the basin outlet and Samarahan’s are located around the basin, with one station within each basin’s limits. The SWAT was developed and calibrated following its general modelling approach, however, the SLSTM performance was also tested using data preprocessing with principal component analysis (PCA). Results showed that the SWAT performance for daily streamflow simulation at Samarahan has been superior to that of Trusan. Both the SLSTM and PCA-SLSTM models, however, showed better performance at Trusan with PCA-SLSTM outperforming the SLSTM. This demonstrates that the SWAT model is greatly affected by the spatial distribution of its input data, while data-driven models, irrespective of the spatial distribution of their entry data, can perform well if the data adequacy condition is met. However, considering the structural difference between the two models, each has its specific application in a water resources context. The study of catchments’ response to changes in the hydrology cycle requires a physically-based model like SWAT with proper spatial and temporal distribution of its entry data. However, the study of a specific phenomenon without considering the underlying processes can be done using data-driven models like SLSTM, where improper spatial distribution of data cannot be a restricting factor.

Application of Machine Learning Techniques in Rainfall–Runoff Modelling of the Soan River Basin, Pakistan

Intercomparison and Assessment of Stand-Alone and Wavelet-Coupled Machine Learning Models for Simulating Rainfall-Runoff Process in Four Basins of Pothohar Region, Pakistan

Intercomparison of deep learning models in predicting streamflow patterns: insight from CMIP6

Rainfall forecasting in upper Indus basin using various artificial intelligence techniques

Performance evaluation of ML techniques in hydrologic studies: Comparing streamflow simulated by SWAT, GR4J, and state-of-the-art ML-based models

A Comparative Study of Various Hybrid Wavelet Feedforward Neural Network Models for Runoff Forecasting

An Integrated Statistical-Machine Learning Approach for Runoff Prediction

Development of a Three-Stage Hybrid Model by Utilizing a Two-Stage Signal Decomposition Methodology and Machine Learning Approach to Predict Monthly Runoff at Swat River Basin, Pakistan

Comparison of machine learning techniques for rainfall-runoff modeling in Punpun river basin, India

In-depth simulation of rainfall–runoff relationships using machine learning methods

Comparative Assessment of Individual and Ensemble Machine Learning Models for Efficient Analysis of River Water Quality

A novel framework for peak flow estimation in the himalayan river basin by integrating SWAT model with machine learning based approach

Estimation of data-driven streamflow predicting models using machine learning methods

A Comparative Analysis of Advanced Machine Learning Techniques for River Streamflow Time-Series Forecasting

A Novel Stacked Long Short-Term Memory Approach of Deep Learning for Streamflow Simulation

Comparative assessment of rainfall-based water level prediction using machine learning (ML) techniques

Comprehensive Review: Advancements in Rainfall-Runoff Modelling for Flood Mitigation

Water Preservation in Soan River Basin using Deep Learning Techniques

Research on Rain Pattern Classification Based on Machine Learning: A Case Study in Pi River Basin

Comparative Performance Assessment of Physical-Based and Data-Driven Machine-Learning Models for Simulating Streamflow: A Case Study in Three Catchments across the US

A comparative study of data-driven models for runoff, sediment, and nitrate forecasting