Abstract:The question of how to accurately depict visual space has fascinated artists, architects, scientists, and philosophers for hundreds of years. Many have argued that linear perspective, which is based on well-understood laws of optics and geometry, is the correct way to record visual space. Others have argued that linear perspective projections fail to account for important features of visual experience, and have proposed various curvilinear, subjective, and hyperbolic forms of perspective instead. In this study we compare three sets of artistic depictions of real-world scenes with linear perspective versions (photographs) of the same scenes. They include a series of paintings made by one of the authors, a selection of landscape paintings by Paul Cézanne, and a set of drawings made as part of a controlled experiment by people with art training. When comparing the artworks with the photographs depicting the same visual space, we found consistent differences. In the artworks the part of the scene corresponding to the central visual field was enlarged compared with the photograph, and the part corresponding to the peripheral field was compressed. We consider a number of factors that could explain these results.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?
This paper aims to explore whether artists use linear perspective when depicting visual space. Specifically, the researchers compared three groups of artworks with linear - perspective photographs (i.e., photographic works) of the same scene to analyze whether artists follow the principle of linear perspective or deviate from it when depicting real - world scenes. The following are the specific research questions in the paper:
1. **Do artists strictly follow linear perspective to depict visual space?**
- Linear perspective is a projection technique based on optical and geometric principles for representing the three - dimensional world on a two - dimensional plane. Many theorists believe that this is the correct way to depict visual space. However, there are also some views that linear perspective cannot fully capture the characteristics of human visual experience.
2. **What are the differences between artworks and linear - perspective photographs?**
- By comparing artists' works (including paintings and sketches) with linear - perspective photographs of the same scene, the researchers found some significant differences. In particular, in the central visual field, the objects in the artworks appear larger than those in the photographs, while in the peripheral visual field, they appear smaller.
3. **What are the reasons for these differences?**
- The researchers considered various possible factors, such as the artists' perception methods, the influence of visual memory, and the subjective choices in the art - creation process. In addition, they also explored the influence of different viewing angles, lens types and other factors on the results.
### Experimental Design
To answer these questions, the researchers conducted three experiments:
1. **Experiment 1: Depicting the Entire Visual Field**
- Robert Pepperell created a series of paintings attempting to depict the entire visual field relative to a fixed object. Then, the researchers compared these paintings with photographs of the same scene, measured and analyzed the differences.
2. **Experiment 2: Cézanne's Landscape Paintings**
- The researchers selected 18 landscape paintings by Paul Cézanne and compared them with photographs taken from the same perspective. By measuring the proportion of the main objects in the paintings, the researchers found a similar phenomenon: in Cézanne's paintings, the central objects occupied a larger proportion.
3. **Experiment 3: Controlled Drawing Study**
- The researchers designed an experiment in which participants with art training drew still - life scenes under controlled conditions to observe whether they would also show similar deviations.
### Conclusions
The research results show that artists do deviate from linear perspective when depicting visual space. Specifically:
- **Objects in the central visual field are enlarged**, while **objects in the peripheral visual field are compressed**.
- This phenomenon not only appears in the works of modern artists, but also in the works of historically famous artists such as Cézanne.
- The controlled - drawing experiment of participants further verified this trend.
These findings suggest that when depicting visual space, artists may not only rely on linear perspective, but also combine their own perceptual experiences and the needs of artistic expression.