Abstract:Abstract Around the world today, the magnitude and rates of environmental, social, and economic change are undermining the sustainability of many rural societies that rely directly on natural resources for their livelihoods. Sustainable development efforts seek to promote livelihood adaptations that enhance food security and reduce social-ecological vulnerability, but these efforts are hampered by the difficulty of understanding the complexity and dynamism of rural livelihood systems. Disparate research avenues are strengthening our ability to grapple with complexity. But we are only just beginning to find ways to simultaneously account for problematic complexities, including multiscalar feedbacks in the ecosystems that that support livelihoods, the heterogeneous benefits garnered by different segments of society, and the complex contingencies that constrain people’s decisions and capacities to adapt. To provide a more nuanced analysis of the dynamics of transformation in rural livelihood systems, we identified key complementarities between four different research approaches, enabling us to integrate them in a novel research framework that can guide empirical and modeling research on livelihood adaptation. The framework capitalizes upon parallel concepts of sequentiality in (1) ecosystem services and (2) livelihood adaptation scholarship, then incorporates principles from (3) adaptation in social-ecological systems research to account for the dynamism inherent in these often rapidly-transforming systems. Lastly, we include advances in (4) agent-based modeling, which couples human decisions and land use change and provides tools to incorporate complex social-ecological feedbacks in simulation studies of livelihood adaptation. Here we describe the new Ecosystem Services—Livelihood Adaptation (ESLA) framework, explain how it links the contributing approaches, and illustrate its application with two case studies. We offer guidance for its implementation in empirical and modeling research, and conclude with a discussion of current challenges in sustainability science and the contributions that could be gained through research guided by the ESLA framework.

Amazonian peasant livelihood differentiation as mutuality-market dialectics

Not WEIRD at all! Towards More Pluralistic Economies and Sustainable Livelihoods

Against the Market: Local Communities and Polanyian Contention in India and Turkey

Understanding change in traditional sustainable livelihoods: a complex socio-ecological system in an indigenous community in Mexico

Socio-ecological costs of Amazon nut and timber production at community household forests in the Bolivian Amazon

Enhancing Livelihood Resilience Through Hybrid Ecological Compensation: Evidence from Potatso National Park, China

Getting It Right in Rural Development Initiatives: The Importance of Livelihood Assets in Commercializing Family Farm Production in Brazil

Intra-cultural consumption of rural landscapes: An emergent politics of redistribution in Indonesia

Livelihood-environment Trade-off under the Payment for Ecosystem Services (PES) at Decadal Scale in Northwest China

Farmer Initiatives and Livelihood Diversification: From the Collective to a Market Economy in Rural China

Nested Markets and the Transition of the Agro-Marketing System towards Sustainability

Communal Labor in Ecovillages: Contradictions, Impasses, and Possibilities within the Notion of Self-sufficiency

Trade-offs between multifunctionality and profit in tropical smallholder landscapes

The Money-Energy-Technology Complex and Ecological Marxism: Rethinking the Concept of “Use-value” to Extend Our Understanding of Unequal Exchange, Part 1

From primitive accumulation to entangled accumulation: Decentring Marxist Theory of capitalist expansion

Advancing the integration of ecosystem services and livelihood adaptation

Household strategies and rural livelihood diversification

From “Socialist Accounting” to the “Livelihood of Man”: The Viennese and the Columbia Polanyi

The Social Contradictions of Regional Development in the ALBA-TCP: The Case of Food Production

Structural Heterogeneity in Capitalism: A View from the Marxist Abstract Labor Theory of Value

Rents, knowledge and neo-structuralism: transforming the productive matrix in Ecuador