Methodology for Establishing Risk Criteria for Dams in Developing Countries, Case Study of China

Wei Ge,Zongkun Li,Robert Y. Liang,Wei Li,Yingchun Cai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-017-1728-0

IF: 4.426

2017-06-21

Water Resources Management

Abstract:Despite the rapid development of risk analysis, there is a relative absence of risk criteria for dams in developing countries recently, which restrained the practical application of the research results. This paper proposes guidelines for establishing risk criteria of dams in developing countries in considering the coordination of social, economic and engineering factors, then establishes a method of targeted analysis and demonstrates relevant parameters selected according to the ALARP principle and F-N curves, using China as an example. Different individual life risk criteria are established based on different safety levels for existing dams and newly built dams. Social life risk criteria and economic risk criteria are established on the basis of the different safety levels of all size reservoirs, the seriousness of the consequences of accidents, and the acceptability of social risks. The process of establishing risk criteria of dams and the analysis of the parameters demonstrated in this paper are meaningful to provide a reference and promote the required level of management for developing countries.

water resources,engineering, civil

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to establish risk criteria applicable to dams in developing countries. Despite the rapid development in the field of risk analysis, there is a relative lack of dam risk criteria for developing countries, which limits the practical application of research results. This paper proposes guidelines for establishing dam risk criteria for developing countries on the basis of considering the coordination of social, economic and engineering factors, and through a case study in China, establishes a target analysis method and shows relevant parameters selected according to the ALARP principle and the F - N curve. Specifically, the article addresses the following aspects:

1. **Individual life - risk criteria for existing and new dams under different safety levels**: Based on different safety levels, individual life - risk criteria for existing dams and new dams are established respectively.

2. **Social life - risk criteria and economic risk criteria**: According to the reservoir scale of different safety levels, the severity of accident consequences and the acceptability of social risks, social life - risk criteria and economic risk criteria are established.

3. **The process of establishing risk criteria**: The article describes in detail the process of establishing risk criteria, including how to determine the values of "tolerable risk level" and "acceptable risk level", which are the keys to risk assessment and management.

4. **The application of the ALARP principle**: The article introduces the application of the ALARP (As Low As Reasonably Practicable) principle in dam risk assessment, which requires that risks should be reduced to the lowest level that is reasonably practicable.

5. **The use of the F - N curve**: The F - N curve is used to represent the probability distribution at different risk levels, and the article shows how to use the F - N curve to determine risk criteria.

Through these methods, the article aims to provide a reference framework for developing countries to promote the modernization and scientization of their dam management.