Abstract:The topic of local and community governance has garnered increasing attention from researchers in recent years, with the resulting assessments generally identifying both the advantages and obstacles. On the positive side, collaborative community governance is often viewed as a new participatory space facilitating democratic practices with favourable social and relational outcomes. Conversely, the issues of power imbalances and the continued hierarchical influence of the central government are often cited as obstacles to genuine public engagement and horizontal collaboration among diverse actors. In particular, numerous studies argue that the governance structure and initial motivation exert significant influence over the governance processes and outcomes due to the different prioritisation of goals and strategies. Such considerations demonstrate the need for additional comparative studies in diverse contexts. In addition to addressing the limitation of the existing process-focused evaluations, this study proposes an analytic framework of collaborative community governance that identifies the multiple relationships between institutional setting, governance process and outcomes, and examines two community-building initiatives in Korea. The findings demonstrate that collaborative community governance worked as an experiential incubator for individual transformation, social and relational resource building and political empowerment. The comparative analysis of two different collaborative forms reveals that differences in structure and the mode of communication resulted in building different types of relational capital (bonding vs bridging). The lack of preliminary discussions and arrangement for institutional design is highlighted as a source of problems such as excessive dependency on particular communication modes, opaque system of representation and asymmetrical development of relational resources.

Collaborative governance and information technology innovation: public–nonprofit partnerships to build neighborhood information systems

Exploring Collaborative Governance Processes Involving Nonprofits

Nonprofit-Public Partnerships for Local Development: Social Inputs in Policy Implementation

New Public Governance, Social Services, and the Potential of Co-Located Nonprofit Centers for Improved Collaborations

Exploring the Role of Nonprofits in Public Service Provision: Moving from Co-production to Co-governance

Designing Web Technologies for Local Governance Reform: Good Management or Good Democracy?

Public Service Innovation Using Smart Governance

Collaboration in Open Government Data Ecosystems: Open Cross-sector Sharing and Co-development of Data and Software

Structure and Governance of Communities for the Digital Society

A Case Study of the Interaction between NSOs and Practical NPOs: From the Perspective of Collaborative Governance Theory

The workings of collaborative governance: Evaluating collaborative community-building initiatives in Korea

Common Interest Development and the Changing Roles of Government and Market in Planning

Towards Self-Service Governance by Means of Information Technology

Cybersecurity Information Sharing Governance Structures: An Ecosystem of Diversity, Trust, and Tradeoffs

The Clearinghouse Approach to Enhancing Informed Public Participation in Watershed Management Utilizing GIS and Internet Technology

Using Network Analysis to Identify Key Actors in Collaborative Governance Processes

Using a design approach to create collaborative governance

A Longitudinal Network Analysis of Intergovernmental Collaboration for Local Economic Development

Unraveling the dynamics of social governance innovation: A synergistic approach employing NLP and network analysis

Collaborative administration: the management of successful networks