A brief historic overview of sexual and gender diversity in neuroscience: past, present, and future
Jhon Alexander Moreno,Riccardo Manca,Lucas Albrechet-Souza,Juan A. Nel,Ioannis Spantidakis,Zindi Venter,Robert-Paul Juster
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2024.1414396
IF: 3.473
2024-10-08
Frontiers in Human Neuroscience
Abstract:A brief historic overview of sexual and gender diversity in neuroscience: Past, present, and futureThis opinion paper is informed by the brief history of sexual and gender diversity in neuroscience and suggested future directions. Employing a bibliographic search of relevant literature, the authors identified an upward trend in the representation of neuroscience and LGBTQIA+ issues in scientific literature. Providing a chronological timeline of significant developments, the paper among others considers how the field distinguishes itself from psychiatry and neuroscience. Indeed, the field has moved from historically lobotomizing gay men to control their sexuality to a now wider biopsychosocial and cultural scientific perspective embracing and celebrating the sexually and gender-diverse, more broadly. Early studies were concerned with biological, abnormal, and disordered aspects of behavior, primarily related to sexual orientation. This was followed by attempts at redefinition and reclassification. Increased critiques of biological and individual perspectives morphed into more integrative theories and greater acknowledgement of social determinants of health. Notably, trans- and gender diversity-related research only feature significantly after the year 2000, with affirmative approaches coming to the fore in the decade 2011-2020 onwards. Looking to the future, the authors offer insights into the state of knowledge, identify potential research gaps, and suggest directions for further exploration in this interdisciplinary field.Keywords: Key developments; LGBTQIA+; Neuroscientific; Bibliographic literature search; Research trends; Sexual and gender diversity; SOGI IntroductionFor decades, scholars across disciplines, including researchers, scientists, and clinicians, have exhibited a keen interest in exploring the neuroscientific underpinnings of sexual and gender diversity. The purpose of this paper is thus to provide an overview and opinion on the evolution of related research. To achieve this, the authors conducted a bibliographic search of the literature in MEDLINE and PsycInfo from inception to September 2023 with specific keywords, including "neuroscience", and variations of "lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, intersex, asexual, and people with other sexual orientations and forms of gender expression (LGBTQIA+)". The results presented in Figure 1 show that there is an increase in neuroscience and LGBTQIA+ concerns represented in the scientific literature. In particular, the decade from 1991 to 2000 saw a significant growth in related publications, with the field of neuroscience establishing itself as distinct from psychiatry. However, 2011-2020 was the most prolific decade in the history of sexual and gender diversity in neuroscience. In summary, there were 1167 records (i.e., scientific articles, book chapters, opinion letters, among others) corresponding to a collective sample of 444,249 individuals on the LGBTQIA+ spectrum. Most research centered on gay men (32%) or transgender people (24.3%), and only a few addressed lesbian (1.1%), bisexual (1.3%), or other identities (1.1%). When mixed samples were included, the majority corresponded to gay and lesbian people (15.3%). The most common topics were brain development (34.6%), general biological aspects (31.8%), and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-related research (27.5%). In addition, articles focused on social (19%), psychological (15.9%), and neuropsychological (13.3%) aspects of sexual and gender identity. Animal studies accounted for 7.8% of research.Insert Figure 1 hereBefore considering the future of neuroscience of sexual and gender diversity, we first provide a chronological overview of select related key developments in the field.Overview of select key developments in sexual and gender diversity in neuroscienceEarly workThe first record we identified appeared in 1917 in the context of mental disorders suggesting that brain pathology could be related with sexual behavior (Meyer, 1917). Until 1950, only nine publications captured by this search focused on human sexuality, and as complex and multi-determined by biological, psychological, and sociological aspects (Morselli, 1931). This literature indicated that structural damages have an impact on sexual behavior. For instance, "bad thyroid gland may cause queer behavior in the human" (Moss, 1932). During the same period, homosexuality was, in fact, classified as part of psychiatric syndromes (Rosanoff, 1938) and this continued to be the case until 1973. Lobotomy was offered as an option for treating the so-called "sex psychopaths" (Banay and Davidoff, 1942). From 1951 to 1960, seven publications addressed topics linking sexuality to brain abnormalities. For instance, records theorized upon associations linking disturbed cerebral functioning with bisexuality and schizophrenia (Potzl, 1951) and the Klüver-Bucy syndrome with "homosexual adv -Abstract Truncated-
psychology,neurosciences