Abstract:Abstract Previous efforts in the area of collaborative computer-aided design (CAD) suggest that a team of designers working synchronously in a multi-user CAD (MUCAD) environment can produce CAD models faster than a single user. Our research is the among the first to investigate assemblies in MUCAD. Due to the lack of hierarchical feature dependency in assemblies, we propose that CAD teams can optimize assembly through modularization and parallel execution. In our study, 20 participants were tasked with assembling pre-modelled CAD parts of varying complexity in teams of one, two, three or four. We analyze audio recordings, team activity, and survey responses to compare the performance of individuals and virtual collaborative teams during assembly, while working with the same MUCAD platform. This paper features a multimodal approach to analyze team trends in communication, workflow, task allocation and challenges to determine which factors are conducive to the success of a multi-user CAD team and which are detrimental. In our work, the success of a team is measured by its productivity score, which is the number of mates added by a team within a given time frame. We present evidence that teams can complete an assembly in less calendar time than a single user, but single users are more efficient based on person-hours, due to communications and coordination overheads. Surprisingly, paired contributors exhibit an assembly bonus effect. These findings represent a preliminary understanding of collaborative CAD assembly work. Our work supports the claim that collaborative assembly activities have the potential to improve the capabilities of modern product design teams, delivering products faster and at lower cost. We identify areas for future research, and highlight areas of improvement for collaborative CAD platforms and engineering design teams.

A comparative analysis of computer-aided design team performance with collaboration software

Automated Analysis of Differences in the Functionality and Performance of 3D CAD Systems for Collaborative Design

Survey Of Cooperative Cad System Supported By Cscw

Some (Team) Assembly Required: An Analysis of Collaborative Computer-Aided Design Assembly

In the Age of Collaboration, the Computer-Aided Design Ecosystem is Behind: An Interview Study of Distributed CAD Practice

Analysis of Collaborative Assembly in Multi-User Computer-Aided Design

Research on Collaboration Support Technology and Toolkits for CSCW Based CAD System

Building design teamwork supported by a collaborative CAD modeling process analysis

Validation Study of a Computer-Aided Design Augmentation Tool for Cost Estimation

A comparative analysis of CAD modeling approaches for design solution space exploration

TeamCAD -- A Multimodal Interface for Remote Computer Aided Design

A Preliminary Study on Synchronized Collaborative Design Based on Heterogeneous CAD Systems

Exploring the efficacy of collaborative learning in a remote robotics laboratory: a comparative analysis of performance and pedagogical approaches

Collaborative model for concurrent product design

A comparative study of VR CAD modelling tools for design

Social Life Cycle Assessment of Computer-Aided Design Tools

Computer-aided design as a research instrument for engineering design: supporting multiple methods by observing artifacts, actors, and actions

The use of an online learning and teaching system for monitoring computer aided design student participation and predicting student success

Cooperation Management For Collaborative Cad Systems

Architectural design creativity in Multi-User Virtual Environment: A comparative analysis between remote collaboration media

Ccad: An Experimental Collaborative Cad System