Abstract:This article returns to Simone de Beauvoir’s philosophical oeuvre in order to offer a way of thinking beyond contemporary feminist divisions created by ‘gender critical’ or trans-exclusionary feminists. The ‘gender critical’ feminist position returns to sex essentialism to argue for ‘abolishing’ gender, while opponents often appeal to proliferated gender self-identities. I argue that neither goes far enough and that they both circumscribe utopian visions for a world beyond both sex and gender. I chart how Beauvoir’s ontological, ethical and political positions can be used to overcome the material/cultural, sex/gender bind that the contemporary divide perpetuates. I outline Beauvoir’s ‘ambiguous’ non-foundational ontology that attends to both the cultural origins, and material effects, of both sex and gender, and to the extent that humyns are fundamentally social. After outlining Beauvoir’s definition of freedom as purposive action, I then outline how the existence of the humyn-made and intersubjectively-upheld ‘situations’ of both sex and gender delimit this, urging feminists to return to the lost question of eradicating both. I use the utopian impulse in Beauvoir to argue that an ethics of reciprocity is an alternative mode of understanding the self and others. Beauvoir also calls for a political strategy that I call a ‘utopian realism’ that I apply to the contemporary divide. A way forward that is attentive to the concerns of both positions is the pragmatic use of identity politics that is nonetheless mindful of identity’s limits, alongside Beauvoir’s proto-intersectional vision of solidarity politics based not on identity but on a position of alterity and shared political strategy. Ultimately, I use this to argue that feminism would do better to unite around a shared commitment to challenging alterity, rather than further contributing to it.

Virtue, affection, and the social good: The moral philosophy of Catharine Trotter Cockburn and the Bluestockings

Catharine Trotter Cockburn’s Democratization of Moral Virtue

Catharine Trotter Cockburn

Catharine Trotter Cockburn on the virtue of atheists

Catharine Trotter Cockburn (1679?–1749)

Catharine Cockburn on Unthinking Immaterial Substance: Souls, Space, and Related Matters

On some footnotes to Catharine Trotter Cockburn’s Defence of the Essay Of Human Understanding

Womanhood and Democratic Household in Louisa May Alcott’s Little Women

Ambivalent Desires in Charlotte Brontë's Villette and Grace Aguilar's Vale of Cedars

John Locke and Catharine Cockburn on Personal Identity

Remembering Simone de Beauvoir’s ‘ethics of ambiguity’ to challenge contemporary divides: feminism beyond both sex and gender

Theoretical virtues in eighteenth-century debates on animal cognition

Catharine Beecher and the Mechanical Body: Physiology, Evangelism, and American Social Reform from the Antebellum Period to the Gilded Age

An Ethical Foundation for Social Good: Virtue Theory and Solidarity

Love, knowledge (wisdom) and justice: Moral education beyond the cultivation of Aristotelian virtuous character

Wollstonecraft's secrets

‘A brilliancy of their own’: Female Art, Beauty and Sexuality in Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre

Elegant Economy in Elizabeth Gaskells Cranford: A Socialist Feminist Study

Husserl, Beauvoir, and the Problem of the Sexes

From Colonial Subjecthood to Shared Humanity: Social Work and the Politics of “Doing” in Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay's International Thought

Elizabeth Gaskell: An overlooked political economist and proto theorist in the field of industrial relations