Reframing social work ethics through a political ethic of care and social justice lens

Vivienne Bozalek

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46692/9781447317357.040

2022-02-04

Abstract:An historical overview of adult social care that locates the roots of the current crisis in the under-valuing of older people and adults with disabilities, and in the marketisation of social care over the past two decades.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

A roadmap for social work ethics: reflections and a proposal

Frederic G. Reamer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46692/9781447317357.038

2022-02-04

Abstract:An historical overview of adult social care that locates the roots of the current crisis in the under-valuing of older people and adults with disabilities, and in the marketisation of social care over the past two decades.
Reclaiming social work ethics: challenging the new public management

Sarah Banks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46692/9781447317357.037

2022-02-04

Abstract:An historical overview of adult social care that locates the roots of the current crisis in the under-valuing of older people and adults with disabilities, and in the marketisation of social care over the past two decades.
Reflections on the responses to ‘Reclaiming social work ethics’

Sarah Banks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46692/9781447317357.046

2022-02-04

Abstract:An historical overview of adult social care that locates the roots of the current crisis in the under-valuing of older people and adults with disabilities, and in the marketisation of social care over the past two decades.
Ethics and the Street-level Bureaucrat

Angie Ash

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315873350-16

2019-01-02

Abstract:This chapter discusses the missing ethical dimension in implementation of policy to protect elders from abuse. It outlines the M. Lipsky’s thesis of street-level bureaucracy, to situate what follows within its originating context. The chapter considers J. C. Tronto’s several elements of an ethic of care, and the location of the missing ethical voice within those findings. It explores some ways by which a stronger ethical presence can be imprinted into policy making, planning and delivery of services to older people, as well as safeguarding more specifically. ‘Ethics’ and ‘ethical’ were not an initial focus of the research design. References to an ethic of care in social work made only fleeting appearance in the research proposal and early literature review. Social workers have an ethical and moral duty to safeguard older people; organisational and policy context within which they operate must similarly manifest this ethical and moral obligation.
Contesting Neoliberal Reform of Statutory Social Work in Switzerland and England: Discretionary Spaces, Collective Resistance and Ethico-Political Professionalism

Rich Moth,Sigrid Schilling,Lukas Neuhaus,Michael Lavalette,Beat Mürner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/bjsw/bcae122

2024-07-29

The British Journal of Social Work

Abstract:Abstract This article reports findings from a qualitative study of the impacts of, and practitioner responses to, neoliberal social work reforms in Switzerland and England. The article highlights commonalities, and contrasts, in how neoliberalism has restructured social work across the two jurisdictions. Social workers responded to neoliberalisation in a variety of ways, often through adaptation but sometimes by challenging reforms. This resistance primarily involved individualised forms of agency promoting social justice in practice, such as carving out discretionary spaces within casework. However, in Switzerland, collective agency also emerged in the form of anti-cuts campaigning alongside service users. The literature tends to counterpose these micro and macro levels of agency, theorising discretion and resistance to the contradictions and value tensions generated by neoliberal reform as largely a product of practitioners’ individual ethical dispositions. However, we argue that enduring legacies of social justice values and relationship-based practices within social work institutions are also relevant in shaping how social workers navigate reforms. These enduring features offer institutional and normative resources of solidarity which can strengthen the possibilities for practitioner agency, at both individual and collective levels, to resist neoliberal reconfigurations and promote more liberatory and transformative forms of practice. We call this orientation ‘ethico-political professionalism’.

social work
Critical Practice for Challenging Times: Social Workers' Engagement with Community Work

D. Lynch,Catherine Forde

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/BJSW/BCT091

2014-12-01

Abstract:The contribution that social workers make to communities is integral to the principles and values of the profession but is often ‘hidden’ and unacknowledged. This paper is an exploration of social workers' engagement with community work approaches in a range of settings in the Republic of Ireland, where managerialism and a climate of austerity pose particular challenges for social work practice. By exploring the findings of qualitative interviews with social work practitioners, the paper examines themes and issues that emerge in the context of their practice settings and considers how community work ideas are enacted in contemporary social work practice. These ideas challenge dominant discourses and emphasise a process of active engagement with communities to counter inequality and injustice and seek change at both community and societal levels. The concept of ‘creative activism’ is developed to explore the idea of critical practice and the different forms of collective action that social workers undertake. The use of these ideas to strengthen the links between theory, research and practice on a postgraduate qualifying social work degree is discussed. The paper seeks to re-emphasise the place of community work within social work research, theory, practice and professional education.

Sociology
The personal is political: reframing individual acts of kindness as social solidarity in social work practice

Darren Hill,Erika Laredo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13691457.2020.1805587

2020-08-11

European Journal of Social Work

Abstract:This paper develops the theoretical position proposed by Zygmunt Bauman ([2009]. The absence of society. In D. Utting (Ed.), Contemporary social evils. Policy Press – Joseph Rowntree Foundation), that one of the greatest contemporary 'social evils' or injustices we face in society, is the total marketisation and individualisation of our lived experience. Zygmunt Bauman ([2009]. The absence of society. In D. Utting (Ed.), Contemporary social evils. Policy Press – Joseph Rowntree Foundation) along with Harvey, D. ([2005]. A Brief History of Neo Liberalism. Oxford University Press) argues that the last forty years of social, political, and economic reform under the zeitgeist of neoliberalism have transferred the burden of care from the state to the individual. This paper will explore the position that the dominant neoliberal culture within social work, in the form of 'new managerialism' has reconstituted social work institutionally as one where interventions now focus on minimum statutory interventions emphasising; risk management, resource allocation, and audit culture. Despite the current landscape the research highlights the importance of the personal reframed as the political, and the nuanced ways in which acts of defiance and resistance against the prevailing orthodoxies have been adopted by social workers on the front line.

social work
A moral imperative to improve the quality of work-life for nurses: Building inclusive social capital capacity

Anne Hofmeyer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5172/conu.15.1-2.9

2003-08-01

Contemporary Nurse

Abstract:The complexity and incessant change in the corporatised health care workplace has influenced nurses' work choices, morale, quality of work-life and the wellbeing of patients. Thus, there is an urgent moral imperative to improve the quality of work-life for nurses. To this end, it is crucial to re-define progress beyond the sole economic markers of success and profit in the health care workplace. This paper argues for the identification of ethical markers and indicators of organisational success based on bridging and linking social capital which could be used to re-organise health care organisations, hence crafting inclusive moral spaces where nurses can safely work and provide quality care for patients. Social and ethical evaluation is well suited to examine current workplace dilemmas from a psychosocial perspective and provide a framework for best practice in building capacity in effective social relations and family friendly, ethical workplaces.

nursing
Ethics and the Street-level Bureaucrat: Implementing Policy to Protect Elders from Abuse

Angie Ash

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17496535.2010.484263

2010-07-01

Ethics and Social Welfare

Abstract:As an independent researcher, registered social worker and erstwhile long-term, long-distance carer, the care of older people and protection of elders from abuse had been constant professional and personal foci for me for many years. Commissioned to review a case involving the serious abuse of an elder where official safeguarding procedures had not been used, I puzzled why this had been managed ‘informally’ by social services and partner agencies (i.e. outside adult safeguarding procedures), with vague unspecified ‘monitoring’ (AEA 2006). Why was there this apparent gap between policy intention and implementation? That question led to research on which this essay is based.
Looking for elderly people´s needs: teaching critical reflection in Swedish social work education

Sofie Ghazanfareeon Karlsson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02615479.2019.1617846

2020-02-17

Social Work Education

Abstract:ABSTRACT This paper focuses on how to use critical reflection in social work education in order to encourage students to critically reflect on their standards regarding assessment, opinions and values about aging. Material, both oral and written, from needs assessments of older persons conducted by 106 social work students was analyzed. The result shows that the students initially interpreted needs based on prejudice and assumptions about aging. However, when using Schön´s three steps of reflection in the exercise, together with knowledge of critical social work theories, students became more concerned and reflected more critically on their assessments. This study shows the possibilities of working with pedagogical exercises in order to increase the awareness and critical knowledge of social work students in order to attempt to reduce discrimination. Educating students in critical social work enables them to learn how to comment on and transform the profession of social work and our unjust society, while questioning their own as well as society’s prejudice regarding the needs of elderly persons.

Sociology,Education
Everyday ethics in professional life: social work as ethics work

Sarah Banks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17496535.2015.1126623

2016-01-02

Ethics and Social Welfare

Abstract:This article outlines and develops the concept of ‘ethics work’ in social work practice. It takes as its starting point a situated account of ethics as embedded in everyday practice: ‘everyday ethics’. This is contrasted with ‘textbook ethics’, which focuses on outlining general ethical principles, presenting ethical dilemmas and offering normative ethical frameworks (including decision-making models). ‘Ethics work’ is a more descriptive account of ethics that refers to the effort people put into seeing ethically salient aspects of situations, developing themselves as good practitioners, working out the right course of action and justifying who they are and what they have done. After identifying seven features of ethics work, including work on framing, roles, emotion, identity, reason, relationships and performance, each element is illustrated with reference to two case examples from social work practice. It is argued that the concept of ethics work, with its focus on the practitioners as moral agents in context, is an important antidote to the rules-based managerialism of much contemporary practice.
A new vision for adult social care? Continuities and change in the care of older people

Mark Lymbery

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0261018309350806

IF: 1.802

2010-01-19

Critical Social Policy

Abstract:The reform of adult social care is a major preoccupation within England. It is presented as the inevitable consequence of the changed expectations of people who use services; in addition, the detail of policy is portrayed as being in accordance with what those people specify they want from social care. However, there appears to be little recognition of the complexities and contradictions that characterize much of the policy. Of these, the inadequacy of the resource base of adult social care is most significant; consequently, rationing of scarce resources will continue to be a priority. The paper also highlights problems in other areas, including the rhetoric that accompanies policy change and the evidence base for that change, the lack of connection between issues of independence and protection, the partial understandings of partnership that appear to characterize it and the inadequate conceptualizations both of the nature of those people who require social care support and of the character of that support. In discussing these issues, the paper emphasizes that there remain continuities in the context of policy, while noting the continual focus on discontinuity within government documents.

social sciences, interdisciplinary,social issues
Ethical considerations in social work research

Ana M. Sobočan,Teresa Bertotti,Kim Strom-Gottfried

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13691457.2018.1544117

2018-11-13

European Journal of Social Work

Abstract:Too often, discussions of research ethics focus on the steps needed to avoid fraud or protect human subjects. These topics, while essential, are only a fraction of the considerations for ethical research, and excessive attention to them can obscure other important and meaningful decisions. Ethical dilemmas are inherent throughout the research process, from the choice about what to study and how to study it through to analysis and dissemination of findings. Attention to these considerations is especially important for researchers in social work who, by their professional discipline, code of ethics, or research foci are expected to demonstrate particular sensitivity to vulnerable populations, issues of social justice, conflicts of interest, and respect for dignity and privacy. Rooted in three workshops held during ECSWR since 2014, this paper examines the nature of embedded ethical dilemmas, with special attention to the challenges related to the principle of nonmaleficence and to the role of the researcher. In light of illustrative examples, the paper presents recommendations and resources to build ethical awareness and research integrity beyond regulatory compliance.

social work
The marketization of care: Global challenges and national responses in Australia

Michael Fine,Bob Davidson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0011392118765281

2018-04-23

Current Sociology

Abstract:Care is a social necessity for life. Ensuring access to appropriate care at crucial points in the life course became a political necessity soon after the mid-20th century, as the right to suitable care became recognized as a fundamental entitlement of citizenship in most advanced capitalist economies. Over recent decades there has been a shift away from more traditional welfare state forms of public services towards increasingly marketized systems of provision. Changes in the provision of care in the public domain are associated with an increasing reliance on private capital and competition between a variety of providers, with public agencies competing alongside private for-profit and not-for-profit agencies. Drawing on care theory, historical sociology and political economic analysis, this article examines the conflicting tensions that shape aged care under marketization. Using Australia as a case study, it is argued that as private capital and resources take the place of scarce public resources and enable expenditure cuts to be presented as innovation, better services and more ‘consumer choice’, it is not the market but the finance, regulation and management work of the state that is the essential determinant of the assistance previously provided through non-market processes.

sociology
Twenty-first century social work: the influence of political context on public service provision in social work education and service delivery

Penelope Welbourne

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13691451003706670

2011-09-01

European Journal of Social Work

Abstract:This article explores the thesis that there is a discernable ‘direction for social work’ in Britain, and considers the ways in which its development is influenced by state policies influenced by New Managerialist, ‘market’ based and neoliberal ideologies. It concludes that there have been substantial changes across services for children, for adults and in social work education over the last decade that reflect the ethos of central government policy, rather than the ethos and values of social work. Awareness of the role of government policy in shaping the identity of the profession, and responsiveness to that agenda, is critical to maintaining social work's integrity.

social work
Elder Abuse: Clinical, Ethical, and Legal Considerations in Social Work Practice

Kirsten Donovan,Cheryl Regehr

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10615-010-0269-2

2010-03-25

Clinical Social Work Journal

Abstract:As a consequence of the steadily growing older population, and increased demands on family for community based care of elderly, elder abuse is an issue to be considered in all domains of social work practice. Intervention in cases of elder abuse is often fraught with ambiguity and ethical dilemmas as the application of professional principles is less than straightforward, bringing to the fore personal, legal, and ethical concerns in the management of the client’s safety and well-being. This article addresses challenges which arise from the complexity of elder abuse cases and reviews clinical, ethical, and legal obligations to inform ethical decision-making.

social work
A systematic review of ethical and legal issues in elder care

Nertila Podgorica,Magdalena Flatscher-Thöni,Daniela Deufert,Uwe Siebert,Michael Ganner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733020921488

IF: 3.344

2020-05-29

Nursing Ethics

Abstract:Background: Ethical and legal issues are increasingly being reported by health caregivers; however, little is known about the nature of these issues in geriatric care. These issues can improve work and care conditions in healthcare, and consequently, the health and welfare of older people. Aim: This literature review aims to identify research focusing on ethical and legal issues in geriatric care, in order to give nurses and other health care workers an overview of existing grievances and possible solutions to take care of old patients in a both ethical and legally correct way. Methods: Using a systematic approach based on Aveyard, a search of the PubMed, CINAHL, and Ethicshare databases was conducted to find out the articles published on ethical and legal issues in geriatric care. Ethical considerations: The approval for the study was obtained from UMIT-The Health and Life Sciences University, Austria. Results: Only 50 articles were included for systematic analysis reporting ethical and legal issues in the geriatric care. The results presented in this article showed that the main ethical issues were related to the older people’s autonomy, respect for their needs, wishes and values, and respect for their decision-making. The main legal issues were related to patients’ rights, advance directives, elderly rights, treatment nutrition dilemma, and autonomy. Conclusion: Further education for professional caregivers, elderly people, and their families is needed on following topics: care planning, directive and living wills, and caregiver-family member relationships to guide and support the elderly people within their decision-making processes and during the end-of-life care.

nursing,ethics
[Nursing ethics and the mandate of care-current limits using the example of inpatient care for the elderly]

Sabine Wöhlke,Annette Riedel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00103-023-03696-2

Abstract:The central guiding ethical principles of professional care are dignity, care, justice, and respect. The current framework conditions and circumstances in the care of the elderly mean that professional care ethics are no longer feasible in many cases. This leads not only to enormous (moral) burdens among the nursing staff, but also to a comprehensive degree to professional dissatisfaction and to leaving the profession. The term "Pflexit" (based on the German word "Pflege" = care) was first raised during the corona pandemic and has not faded. In order to ensure ethically justified and dignified care for the elderly that is also oriented towards human rights, as is conveyed politically in charters and rightly expected by people in need of care, rapid and comprehensive social and political intervention is required.In this context, dignity and respect are also a social mandate. Dignified professional care based on ethical values can only be implemented if nurses are shown this same respect. The clear warnings of a "nursing climate crisis" must finally be followed by action to stop the exodus from the profession. In this discussion paper, the importance of a professional care ethic is first explained. In a second step, the framework and current problems that oppose a comprehensive implementation of core values in nursing care for the elderly are highlighted. The focus here is on the effects of the precarious personnel situation.
Moral outrage: social workers in the Third Space

Patricia Fronek,Polly Chester

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17496535.2016.1151908

2016-03-11

Ethics and Social Welfare

Abstract:Injustice is at odds with social work's mandate to promote social justice, human rights and ethical responsibility. In nations such as the UK, Australia and the USA, ideologies of the far right exert strong influences on social policy. In this critical commentary, we argue that shifts from welfare states to privatisation, the return of the deserving and undeserving as ‘strivers’ and ‘shrivers’, ‘lifters’ and ‘leaners’, and policies that violate the human rights of refugees and other disenfranchised groups have activated moral outrage within the social work profession. Moral distress, ethical responsibilities and, for some, fears of complicity when unjust policies become practice, suggest that a moral response is required. A new form of online activism in a Third Space has emerged that juxtaposes traditional social work activism in ways that are responsive to social work's moral imperatives, and is a panacea for moral outrage within a global context. Such actions pose ethical complexities and are not without risk. Stéphane Hessel offers a framework to understand how peaceful civil disobedience and radical approaches are legitimate expressions of moral outrage that transcend indifference and despair. We explore the new social work activism emerging in the Third Space drawing from Hessel's philosophies.

Reframing social work ethics through a political ethic of care and social justice lens

A roadmap for social work ethics: reflections and a proposal

Reclaiming social work ethics: challenging the new public management

Reflections on the responses to ‘Reclaiming social work ethics’

Ethics and the Street-level Bureaucrat

Contesting Neoliberal Reform of Statutory Social Work in Switzerland and England: Discretionary Spaces, Collective Resistance and Ethico-Political Professionalism

Critical Practice for Challenging Times: Social Workers' Engagement with Community Work

The personal is political: reframing individual acts of kindness as social solidarity in social work practice

A moral imperative to improve the quality of work-life for nurses: Building inclusive social capital capacity

Ethics and the Street-level Bureaucrat: Implementing Policy to Protect Elders from Abuse

Looking for elderly people´s needs: teaching critical reflection in Swedish social work education

Everyday ethics in professional life: social work as ethics work

A new vision for adult social care? Continuities and change in the care of older people

Ethical considerations in social work research

The marketization of care: Global challenges and national responses in Australia

Twenty-first century social work: the influence of political context on public service provision in social work education and service delivery

Elder Abuse: Clinical, Ethical, and Legal Considerations in Social Work Practice

A systematic review of ethical and legal issues in elder care

[Nursing ethics and the mandate of care-current limits using the example of inpatient care for the elderly]

Moral outrage: social workers in the Third Space