Abstract:Aim: Research on deception detection has usually been executed in experimental settings in the laboratory. In contrast, the present research investigates deception detection by actual victims and near victims of fraud, as reported in their own words. Materials and methods: Our study is based on a nationally representative survey of 11 types of (mostly) online fraud victimization (N = 2,864). We used qualitative information from actual victims and near victims on why they didn't fall for the fraud, or how, in hindsight, it could have been prevented. Results: The main detection strategies mentioned by near victims (N = 958) were 1) fraud knowledge (69%): these near victims clearly recognized fraud. Other strategies related to fraud knowledge were: noticing mistakes (27.9%), rules and principles about safe conduct (11.7%), and personal knowledge (7.1%). A second type of strategy was distrust (26.1%). A third strategy was 'wise through experience' (1.6%). Finally, a limited number of respondents (7.8%) searched for additional information: they contacted other people (5.5%), sought information online (4%), contacted the fraudster (2.9%), contacted their bank or credit card company (2.2%), or contacted the police (0.2%). Using knowledge as a strategy decreases the probability of victimization by a factor of 0.43. In contrast, all other strategies increased the likelihood of victimization by a factor of 1.6 or more. Strategies generally were uncorrelated, several strategies differed by type of fraud. About 40% of the actual victims (N = 243) believed that their victimization might have been prevented by: 1) seeking information (25.2%), 2) paying more attention (18.9%), 3) a third party doing something (16.2%), 4) following safety rules or principles, like using a safer way of paying or trading (14.4%), or by 5) 'simply not going along with it' (10.8%). Most of these strategies were associated with a higher, not lower, likelihood of victimization. Conclusion: Clearly, knowledge of fraud is the best strategy to avoid fraud victimization. Therefore, a more proactive approach is needed to inform the public about fraud and attackers' modus operandi, so that potential victims already have knowledge of fraud upon encountering it. Just providing information online will not suffice to protect online users.

Determinants of reporting cybercrime: A comparison between identity theft, consumer fraud, and hacking

Fraud reporting in Catalonia in the Internet era: Determinants and motives

Comparing Victims of Phishing and Malware Attacks: Unraveling Risk Factors and Possibilities for Situational Crime Prevention

Online Consumer Fraud Victimization and Reporting: A Quantitative Study of the Predictors and Motives

Exploring the Factors Preventing Older Adults From Reporting Cybercrime and Seeking Help: A Qualitative, Semistructured Interview Study

A Study on the Characteristics and Influencing Factors of Victims of Fraud Crimes

Phishing for suitable targets in the Netherlands: routine activity theory and phishing victimization

Careful When You Click? How the Dark Triad of Personality Can Influence the Likelihood of Online Crime Victimization

Help, I need somebody: Examining the antecedents of social support seeking among cybercrime victims

Assessing the Factors Associated With the Detection of Juvenile Hacking Behaviors

Applying Routine Activity Theory to Cybercrime: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis

Victims rational decision: A theoretical and empirical explanation of dark figures in crime statistics

The Psychology of Internet Fraud Victimisation: a Systematic Review

Understanding motivations and characteristics of financially-motivated cybercriminals

Effects of anonymity, pre-employment integrity and antisocial behavior on self-reported cyber crime engagement: an exploratory study

Cybercrime in America amid COVID-19: the Initial Results from a Natural Experiment

Making the most of cybercrime and fraud crime report data: a case study of UK Action Fraud

In their own words: deception detection by victims and near victims of fraud

Telecommunication and cyber fraud victimization among Chinese college students: An application of routine activity theory

Empty Streets, Busy Internet: A Time-Series Analysis of Cybercrime and Fraud Trends During COVID-19

A Survey of Scam Exposure, Victimization, Types, Vectors, and Reporting in 12 Countries