Abstract:Scams are a widespread issue with severe consequences for both victims and perpetrators, but existing data collection is fragmented, precluding global and comparative local understanding. The present study addresses this gap through a nationally representative survey (n = 8,369) on scam exposure, victimization, types, vectors, and reporting in 12 countries: Belgium, Egypt, France, Hungary, Indonesia, Mexico, Romania, Slovakia, South Africa, South Korea, Sweden, and the United Kingdom. We analyze 6 survey questions to build a detailed quantitative picture of the scams landscape in each country, and compare across countries to identify global patterns. We find, first, that residents of less affluent countries suffer financial loss from scams more often. Second, we find that the internet plays a key role in scams across the globe, and that GNI per-capita is strongly associated with specific scam types and contact vectors. Third, we find widespread under-reporting, with residents of less affluent countries being less likely to know how to report a scam. Our findings contribute valuable insights for researchers, practitioners, and policymakers in the online fraud and scam prevention space.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is that the current data collection on scams is fragmented, which hinders the comparative understanding at the global and national levels. Specifically, although national governments and relevant agencies regularly collect local scam data, due to methodological differences, it is difficult to compare these data across national boundaries. In addition, existing global reports either aggregate existing data sources or use survey methods that cannot achieve population representativeness, resulting in a lack of accurate and practical understanding of the global scam landscape.
To fill this gap, researchers conducted a nationally representative survey covering 12 countries: Belgium, Egypt, France, Hungary, Indonesia, Mexico, Romania, Slovakia, South Africa, South Korea, Sweden and the United Kingdom. By analyzing six survey questions, the study aims to construct a detailed quantitative picture of scam exposure, victimization, types, transmission routes and reporting in each country, and identify global patterns through cross - national comparisons.
### Research Questions
This study mainly answers the following four research questions:
1. **RQ1: How prevalent are scam exposure and victimization?**
- The study found that residents in less wealthy countries are more likely to suffer financial losses due to scams.
2. **RQ2: How prevalent are specific types of scams?**
- The study found that the Internet plays a crucial role in all surveyed countries, and the GNI per - capita is closely related to specific types of scams and contact channels. For example, money - making scams are more common in less wealthy countries.
3. **RQ3: To what extent do scams rely on technological means?**
- The study found that from the first contact to payment, the Internet plays a crucial role in the entire scam process. Social media and instant messaging applications are more common in less wealthy countries, while email - based scams are more prominent in wealthier countries.
4. **RQ4: How well do the reported data sources cover the scam victimization situation?**
- The study found that there is a widespread phenomenon of unreported scams, especially in less wealthy countries, where residents often do not know how to report scams.
### Main Findings
- Residents in less wealthy countries are more likely to suffer financial losses due to scams.
- The Internet plays a crucial role in scams globally, and the GNI per - capita is closely related to specific types of scams and contact channels.
- There is a widespread phenomenon of unreported scams, especially in less wealthy countries, where residents often do not know how to report scams.
These findings provide valuable insights for researchers, practitioners and policymakers, which are helpful for better understanding and dealing with online fraud and scam problems.