Abstract:<p>Today's scientific research is an expensive enterprise funded primarily by taxpayers' and corporate groups' monies. All nations want to discover fields of study that promise to create future industries, and dominate these by building up and securing scientific and technological expertise early. However, the conversion of scientific leadership into market dominance remains very much an alchemy. To gain insights into how science becomes technology, we focused on graphene (which shows promise in batteries, sensors, flexible displays and other technologies) as a case study. In particular, we asked whether research on the material is on track to deliver all its technological promises. To answer this question, we analyzed in this paper bibliometric records of scientific journal publications and patents related to graphene. While performing straightforward analyses at the aggregate and temporal level to do so, we stumbled upon evidences that suggest 'Golden Eras' of graphene science and technology in the recent past. To confirm this unexpected finding, we developed a novel simulation-based method to determine how the interest levels in graphene science and technology change with time. We then found compelling evidences that these interest levels peaked in 2010 and 2012 respectively, despite the continued growth of journal and patent publications in this area. This suggests that publication numbers in a research topic could sometimes give rise to false positives concerning its importance.</p>

The New “Gold Rush”: Graphene's Research Renaissance

The Progress on Graphene-based Catalysis

The golden eras of graphene science and technology: Bibliographic evidences from journal and patent publications

Graphene: Status and Prospects

Graphene research and their outputs: Status and prospect

Graphene—From Basic Science to Useful Technology

Publishing 2D materials research towards industrialisation

The Carbon New Age

Graphene, Nobel Prize and All that Jazz

Twenty Years of Graphene: From Pristine to Chemically Engineered Nano-Sized Flakes

Graphene, beyond lab benches

Graphene at Fifteen

Exploring two decades of graphene: The jack of all trades

The commercialization of graphene electronics

Graphene Nanosheet: Synthesis, Molecular Engineering, Thin Film, Hybrids, And Energy And Analytical Applications

Graphene Nanosheet: Synthesis, Molecular Engineering, Thin Film, Hybrids, and Energy and Analytical Applications.

From Protosolar Space to Space Exploration: The Role of Graphene in Space Technology and Economy

Design Principles and Synthesis of 3D Graphene-Analogous Materials and van der Waals Heterostructures

Graphene Standardization: the Lesson from the East

GRAPHENE:A NEW QUANTUM MATERIAL

Graphene and Beyond: Recent Advances in Two-Dimensional Materials Synthesis, Properties, and Devices