Between Evidence-Based Education and Professional Judgment, What Future for Teachers and Their Knowledge?

Vincent Dupriez,Branka Cattonar
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-8279-5_8
2018-01-01
Abstract:This chapter deals with the question of what is perceived as legitimate knowledge for constructing, discussing or questioning teachers’ work. After noting the importance of knowledge in the emergence and recognition of a professional group, we argue that the professional group of teachers has traditionally occupied a position of relative exteriority with respect to the definition of knowledge useful for the profession. Our hypothesis is that the development of New Public Management in the educational field, combined with the promotion of evidence-based education, contributes to a definition that is even more external to the group of knowledge and techniques considered legitimate for the professional activity of teaching. By contrast, the criticisms of evidence-based education seem to encourage the development of an alternative conception of teacher knowledge that is more rooted in the professional group and peer interactions, based on a professional judgment structured by the singular features of the situations encountered.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?