The Relationship Between Psychological Contract Breach and Employees’ Counterproductive Work Behaviors: The Mediating Effect of Organizational Cynicism and Work Alienation

Shuang Li,Yang Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01273
IF: 3.8
2018-07-27
Frontiers in Psychology
Abstract:Psychological contract breach (PCB) may trigger negative attitudes in employees and ultimately cause further negative behaviors. By drawing on social exchange theory, this study aims to explore the link between PCB and counterproductive work behavior (CWB) by focusing on the mediating role of organizational cynicism and work alienation. We administered a cross-sectional survey of 484 energy company front-line employees. The conceptual model was examined via structural equation modeling. The results suggested that organizational cynicism and work alienation sequentially mediated the relationship between PCB and CWB. This study elucidated the mechanisms underlying the relationship between PCB and CWB by introducing negative attitudes (i.e., organizational cynicism and work alienation) into the model, and offered further evidence that organizations should pay more attention to employees' PCB and negative attitudes in order to reduce their CWB.
psychology, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the relationship between psychological contract breach (PCB) and counterproductive work behavior (CWB) of employees, and focuses on the mechanism of action of organizational cynicism and work alienation between the two. Specifically, by introducing negative attitudes (i.e., organizational cynicism and work alienation) as mediating variables, the study reveals how PCB affects employees' CWB through these negative attitudes. ### Research background - **Psychological contract breach (PCB)**: Psychological contract breach occurs when an employee perceives that the organization fails to fulfill its promises or obligations. - **Counterproductive work behavior (CWB)**: Refers to the behavior in which employees voluntarily violate organizational norms, and these behaviors cause harm to the organization and its members. - **Organizational cynicism**: Employees' attitude of lacking trust and positive emotions towards the organization, manifested as criticism and distrust of the organization. - **Work alienation**: Employees' psychological sense of distance from their work, including personal alienation and social alienation. ### Research purposes - **Explore the relationship between PCB and CWB**: Based on the social exchange theory, the researchers believe that PCB may lead employees to develop negative attitudes, which in turn trigger CWB. - **The role of mediating variables**: Introduce organizational cynicism and work alienation as mediating variables to explore their mechanism of action in the relationship between PCB and CWB. ### Research hypotheses 1. **Hypothesis 1**: There is a positive correlation between PCB and CWB. 2. **Hypothesis 2**: PCB has a positive impact on organizational cynicism. 3. **Hypothesis 3**: There is a positive correlation between organizational cynicism and CWB. 4. **Hypothesis 4**: Organizational cynicism plays a mediating role in the relationship between PCB and CWB. 5. **Hypothesis 5**: There is a positive correlation between PCB and work alienation. 6. **Hypothesis 6**: There is a positive correlation between work alienation and CWB. 7. **Hypothesis 7**: Work alienation plays a mediating role in the relationship between PCB and CWB. 8. **Hypothesis 8**: There is a positive correlation between organizational cynicism and work alienation. ### Research methods - **Participants**: 484 front - line coal miners and oil workers from five large state - owned enterprises in a large city in northern China. - **Data collection**: A cross - sectional survey design was adopted. 570 questionnaires were distributed, and 484 valid questionnaires were retrieved. - **Measurement tools**: A self - report questionnaire containing 46 items was used to assess PCB, organizational cynicism, work alienation and CWB. - **Data analysis**: SPSS 21.0 was used for descriptive statistics and correlation analysis, and AMOS 22.0 was used for structural equation modeling (SEM). ### Results - **Common method variance (CMV)**: The results of the Harman single - factor test show that CMV is not a problem. - **Descriptive statistics**: There are significant correlations among PCB, organizational cynicism, work alienation and CWB. - **Measurement model test**: The discriminant validity of the core variables was confirmed, and the 4 - factor model had the best fit. - **Model structure test**: The comparison results of the full mediation model (Model 1) and the partial mediation model (Model 2) show that the full mediation model has a better fit. ### Conclusions - **The relationship between PCB and CWB**: PCB affects employees' CWB through the sequential mediation of organizational cynicism and work alienation. - **Management suggestions**: Organizations should pay attention to employees' psychological contract breach and negative attitudes in order to reduce employees' counterproductive work behaviors. Through this research, the author not only reveals the complex relationship between PCB and CWB, but also provides specific management suggestions for organizations to improve employees' work attitudes and behaviors.