Концепт «сверхчеловек» и демонические герои Достоевского в русской эссеистике Cеребряного века

Ágnes Dukkon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1556/060.2018.63.1.3

2018-06-01

Studia Slavica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae

Abstract:<p>Studia Slavica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae 63 (1): 19-28</p>

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

THE PRINCIPLE OF DOMINANCE IN THE CHARACTERS OF THE NOVEL “DEMONS” BY F. M. DOSTOEVSKY (IN LIGHT OF THE ETHICAL TEACHINGS OF A. A. UKHTOMSKY)

Elena Fedorova

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15393/j9.art.2023.11962

2023-02-01

ПРОБЛЕМЫ ИСТОРИЧЕСКОЙ ПОЭТИКИ

Abstract:The article reveals the author’s model of the world in F. M. Dostoevsky’s novel “Demons” based on the analysis of the genre content of the work. Appeal to the allusive plan of the novel (allusions to the motifs, images, landscapes in Goethe’s drama “Faust” and I. S. Turgenev’s story “Faust”) allows the reader to engage in a kind of dialogue between Dostoevsky and his predecessors. However, the traditions of ancient Russian literature (traditions of the vision genre, orientation to the church calendar, reliance on the biblical word and Holy Tradition) allow us to draw a conclusion about the national originality of the work. In the hierarchical structure of the novel, the highest place is occupied by the Gospel Word and the patristic heritage, Sacred Tradition. The concept of personality in the novel allows us to reveal the ethical teaching of A. A. Ukhtomsky about the dominant and the chronotope. The article for the first time considers the Ukhtomsky’s concept of the dominant using the material of Stavrogin’s “confession” and the fate of Stepan Trofimovich, and concludes that a new dominant of heroes has been formed. The significance of the novel “Demons” lies not only in the warning about the destructive processes that can occur in society and in man, but also in the depiction of ways out of the crisis and restoring the personality, in particular, Shatov, Stepan Trofimovich and other heroes are helped by conciliar consciousness, faith in the Providence of God, love, and readiness for repentance. The study was carried out on the material of the reconstructed journal edition of the novel, carried out in the Complete Works (canonical texts).
Lermontov and Vrubel's Demon Images

Chen Xinyu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16238/j.cnki.rla.2011.04.014

2011-01-01

Abstract:M.Lermontov,shaped the poetic demon image in his lyrics,especially in the poem The Demon.M.Vrubel,was constantly exploring the "demon" image in his painting career.The illustrations he provided for Lermontov's The Demon may well be said to be a perfect fit of poetry and painting.The demon image described by Lermontov is a complex of contradictions.On the one hand,to the reader,the demon is an artistic symbolic image with the poet's temperament and sentiments and his viewpoints of moral philosophy;on the other hand,he is the anti-Christ image both of the Gospels and in the earthly sense.The duality of the demon image reflects the contradiction of the poet's own understanding of the world.The painter's demon is a symbolic image:he longs to get away from the vulgar world;he lives proudly in the world and observes it in a calm manner.No matter how hard Vrubel tried,the demon image he created was closely related to the one Lermontov described.
F. M. Dostoevsky – great human-lover, expert in human, well-wisher of human, sage and visionary

Evgenii M. Babosov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.33581/2521-6821-2021-3-13-23

2021-09-30

Abstract:The philosophical meaning and humanistic pathos of F. M. Dostoevsky’s work is revealed, embodied in his novels and «The diary of a writer». The depth and bottomlessness of a person – the writer’s symbol of faith – are presented. The philosophical, ethical and psychological generalisations of the Russian writer are presented as the central point of the metaphysical problem of man as a personality, her life, quest, suffering, love, faith. The theory of F. M. Dostoevsky’s creativity is reconstructed, for which a person is interesting when he embarks on only his own, individual path, but passing which, highlights something typical for the entire people, its historical fate and destiny, strength and weakness. Only in the personal identity of each person is the general identity of the nation embodied; to defend in any circumstances the honour of the Russian man and the honour of his people – this is precisely what the citizen writer saw as the vocation of Russia. The dialectic of love, freedom, beauty and immortality as components of the meaning of human life is revealed. Against this background, death is presented as an inevitable moral lesson, the meaning of which is to sharpen the feelings of love and humility: love for man and humility before God. This understanding of life and death is opposed by demonic, a phenomenon devoid of love and humility. For F. M. Dostoevsky, who had an acute presentiment of future social upheavals in Russia and Europe, devilry is embodied in the revolutionary ideas of seizing power, restructuring society and man according to the patterns of political leaders who only yearn for domination and submission of others to their will. The prophecies and premonitions made by F. M. Dostoevsky about the future of Russia and its place in world history are characterised. The emphasis is on the writer’s rejection of the revolution as a fratricidal war and the denial of the viability of communist ideas and ideals. Only religiously coloured humanism can be opposed to these gloomy forecasts: a better future will come when people, based on the implementation of the main Christian thesis, to love their neighbour as themselves, will be able to unite into a single harmonious whole or the paradise of Christ.
“Sacred horror” of the poet Gavriil Romanovich Derzhavin

Metropolitan of Tambov and Rasskazovo Theodosius (Sergey I. Vasnev)

DOI: https://doi.org/10.20310/2587-6953-2024-10-2-378-386

2024-06-13

Neophilology

Abstract:RELEVANCE. The outstanding Russian poet Gavriil Romanovich Derzhavin is one of the few authors who, in his artistic work, theologically comprehended human existence, man’s place in the world and his relationship to the Creator and Creator of the world. The object of study in the article is the spiritual poetry of G.R. Derzhavin; The subject of the study is the poet’s religious ideas about man and his relationship with God and the world around him, reflected in the genre of spiritual ode. The purpose of the study is to identify the features of the expression of the Orthodox worldview of G.R. Derzhavin in episodes of his biography and poetic creativity using the example of a spiritual ode. MATERIALS AND METHODS. In accordance with the interdisciplinary nature of the research, the author used a combination of philological, historical and theological scientific methods, the most important of which were historical-biographical, intertextual and hermeneutic. RESULT AND DISCUSSION. The analysis of G.R. Derzhavin’s biographical facts and the memoirs of his contemporaries made it possible to characterize the poet as a person deeply rooted in the Orthodox faith striving to get aware of Divine truths, as well as to convey the highest moral law to a wide circle of his readers through verbal creativity. A review of works written in the genre of spiritual odes and based on a number of psalms, as well as a theological and philological analysis of the ode “God” made it possible to identify semantic and ideological connections of the author’s worldview with the dogmatic and anthropological teaching of the Orthodox Church. By revealing the theological content of the lexemes “slave” – “king”, “worm” – “God”, the author of the article resolves the apparent antinomy and gives an interpretation of these words from the point of view of Orthodox anthropology. CONCLUSION. As a result of the research, the author comes to the conclusion that the pinnacle of G.R. Derzhavin’s poetic creativity is the ode “God”, which fully reveals the features of the poet’s Orthodox worldview, in particular, its anthropological and soteriological aspects. The main theme of the ode is the greatness of God, in whom man is called to believe, who he must constantly thank, humbly and lovingly magnify and glorify, treading in the steps of King David, the Old Testament psalmist.
Dämonisch, das Dämonische (Daemonic, the Daemonic)

Angus Nicholls

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5195/glpc.2024.70

2024-05-28

Goethe-Lexicon of Philosophical Concepts

Abstract:Due to their prominence in Goethe’s autobiography (Dichtung und Wahrheit, Poetry and Truth) and in Johann Peter Eckermann’s Gespräche mit Goethe (Conversations with Goethe), Goethe scholarship has associated the lexemes dämonisch and das Dämonische with Goethe’s life, and especially with his seemingly divinely inspired artistic productivity. Yet when these lexemes are considered in relation to the ancient Greek term from which they are derived – δαíμων (German: Dämon; English: daimon or daemon) – they appear as part of a larger tradition in European thought that is concerned with non-rational sources of inspiration, as well as with the limits of reason itself. Far from offering a consistent theory or concept of the daemonic, Goethe uses this term and its cognates in various ways: to refer to a mysterious and terrifying force that influences one’s life and seems to operate at the nexus between character and fate; as a poetic topos that depicts the relation between the striving subject and its external world; as the morphological core of the personality associated with the tradition of astrology, a core which is seen as the locus of one’s productivity; and as a name or placeholder for phenomena that escape our rational comprehension. Precisely due to the flexibility and ambiguity of these terms, Goethe’s use of them has enjoyed a rich reception in fields as various as theology, religious studies, and philosophy from the nineteenth century until the present.
ANTHROPOSOPY OF LEO TOLSTOY: SPIRIT, SOUL AND BODY

A. V. Motorin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.34680/2411-7951.2024.2(53).259-267

2024-01-01

Abstract:The article examines the artistic anthroposophy of L. Tolstoy, which became a synthesis of the main pantheistic teachings and magical believes developed by humanity. The writer tries to resolve the tragic contradiction between the reluctance to die and the desire to become God, that is, everyone, with the help of faith in the possibility of eternal faceless existence as part of the boundless divine unity. However, this belief only partially muffles the horror of death as the inevitable end for private personal existence in the perspective of the endless expansion of human consciousness. Madness, suicide and, of course, simply death in its various forms, which Tolstoy thought about all his life and which he constantly reflected in his work, become, in his understanding, typical manifestations of pantheistic ecstasies (“losses of temper”), leading a person to self-deification. This magical anti-Christian aspiration of Tolstoy’s anthroposophy should be taken into account when studying his works in school and university.
The image of the "demon Lord" in Japanese fantasy: traditions, formality, originality

Kirill Ivanovich Kovlekov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.25136/2409-8698.2022.10.38135

2022-10-01

Litera

Abstract:Modern Japanese fantasy is based on a limited set of characters. One of them is “demon lord” or "Maou" (jap. 魔王). Given the growing popularity of novels implementing the character during composition, as well as growing popularity of manga and anime adaptations, it seems relevant to study the key characters of Japanese fantasy. In this regard, the purpose of the study is to determine the role of the demon lord character. Subject of the study pertains to modern Japanese fantasy. To achieve research goals, methods of comparative historical analysis, J. G. Kavelty's literary formula approach, and content analysis were used. The main result of the work was identification of the characteristic features and the role of the demon lord as character in its diachronic and synchronic aspects. The fields of application of the research results are literary studies, Oriental studies, the study of modern Japanese mass literature. It is concluded that the demon lord as a concept dates back to traditional Buddhist origins, but nowadays returns to its roots in a new capacity after adapting Japanese popular culture, in response to the needs of modern man. In the context of modern mass literature, the demon lord holds value as a type of standard of Japanese fantasy and as an important element of the conventional structure of the literary formula.
Non-Euclidean Geometries as a Source of Faith in God for F.M. Dostoevsky and His Characters (on the Example of Ivan Karamazov)

Menglian Ou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.25136/2409-8698.2023.7.41030

2023-07-01

Litera

Abstract:Ivan Karamazov's nightmare reflects his deep ideological crisis. In the story of Ivan Karamazov's "rebellion" against God, his arguments about recently discovered non-Euclidean geometries play a major role. Confessing that he cannot understand and accept the idea of non-Euclidean geometry and the idea of worlds arranged according to different laws than our world, Ivan therefore denies the possibility for himself to sincerely believe in God. The strange connection between non-Euclidean geometry and belief in God is confirmed by an episode in The Brothers Karamazov, in which Ivan has a vision of the devil. In describing paradise, the devil uses the latest scientific concepts and non-Euclidean geometry, clearly demonstrating that new scientific theories can help a person find faith. This connection, important for the story of Ivan Karamazov, can be explained by the fact that in Dostoevsky's philosophical worldview the existence of "other worlds" plays a very important role as an expression of an unusual interpretation of the idea of immortality. If we accept the idea of people's existence after death in "other worlds", then scientific theories about "other worlds" can be seen as revealing those dimensions of being, where man will visibly understand the existence of God and the possibility of immortality.
Personocentrism in classical Russian literature of the XIX century. Dialectics of Artistic Consciousness

Anatoliy Andreev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.12737/1095050

2021-06-22

Abstract:The monograph is devoted to the study of the brightest phenomenon of the world art culture — Russian literature of the "golden age", which was formed as an aristocratic, personocentric literature. Russian Russian literature began to realize its "cultural code", its purpose, which was close to it in spirit; moreover, it unconsciously formed a program for its development, immediately finding its "gold mine": elitist personocentrism as a highly promising vector of culture, which became a decisive factor in the world recognition of Russian literature. The end-to-end plot of the book was the spiritual biography of the" extra person", a person, a personality. The author suggests that the starting point in the Russian cultural identification of the modern type is "Eugene Onegin" by A. S. Pushkin. This novel in verse, which embodied the type of "superfluous", determined not only the specifics and strategy of the development of Russian literature (which is proved by the analysis of the key classical works of the XIX century-from Griboyedov to Chekhov); in fact, it formed a program for the development of modern world literature. For specialists in literature, teachers and students of philological faculties of universities. It will also be useful for cultural scientists, specialists in literary and artistic creativity.
Modern Inspiration of Demonology:from the Perspective of Christian Philosophy

ZHAO Dun-hua

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1009-8860.2010.03.004

2010-01-01

Abstract:"Demonology" is a branch of Christian theology.Since it's difficult to get rid of religious superstition,Bultmann denies its immediate significance by the way of demythologization.Philosophically,ancient popular terms always refer to social realities so "demon" words can be restored as the criticism of evil origins like social vulgarity,evil hearts,mental disorder,cheating and ignorance,etc.
THE FUNCTION OF THE DEVIL IN CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION: “THE BROTHERS KARAMAZOV” AND THE SERIES “LUCIFER” BY NETFLIX

Angelika Molnar,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.28995/2227-6165-2022-4-65-70

2022-01-01

Articult

Abstract:The paper is devoted to the analysis of similar images of the traits in Dostoevsky's novel ''The Brothers Karamazov'' and in Fox – Netflix's series ''Lucifer''. At the same time, the elements that make up the detective layer of the verbal and the visual work are demonstrated. The basis for comparing the products of high and mass culture is created not only by the forms of murder investigations, but also by their transformation into self-reflection. Devilish figures in both cases become humanized, which allows to look at them from a new point of view. They are hereby considered in the context of the conceptualization of sinfulness, the commission of a crime. The author of the paper also touches upon both the issue of moving the fantastic layer into reality, and the presentation of deep philosophical problems in the form of criminal investigation. It turns out that both in a literary work and in a television / streaming production, the techniques of the detective novel are promoted to the background due to the predominance of Christian ideology and creative poetization.
Traditions of F.M. Dostoevsky in the prose of modern spiritual writers

И.С. Леонов

DOI: https://doi.org/10.37632/pi.2022.291.2.016

2022-05-12

Russkii iazyk za rubezhom

Abstract:Статья посвящена феномену современного литературного процесса – российской духовной прозе. Рассматриваются ее содержательные и художественные параметры, проблемы терминологического определения и поэтики. Основной акцент делается на генезисе данного литературного явления, в частности на отражении традиций русского классика Ф.М. Достоевского в текстах современных православных авторов. Выявляются общие для них аспекты: рассмотрение личности сквозь призму представлений о биполярности духовной природы человека, восприятие личности как обладателя дара свободы, проблема соотношения чуда и веры. The article is devoted to the phenomenon of the modern literary process - Russian wind prose. The author examines its content and artistic parameters, problems of terminological definition and poetics. The main emphasis is on the genesis of this literary phenomenon, in particular, on the reflection of the traditions of the Russian classic F.M. Dostoevsky in the texts of modern Orthodox authors. The article reveals aspects common to them: the consideration of personality through the prism of ideas about the bipolarity of the spiritual nature of man, the perception of personality as the owner of the gift of freedom, the problem of the correlation of miracle and faith.
GENDER AND ARCHETYPE AS COMPONENTS OF THE CHARACTER ANALYSIS IN “DEMIAN” AND “NARCISSUS AND GOLDMUND” BY HERMANN HESSE

Zoriana RODCHYN,Nataliia BLAHUN

DOI: https://doi.org/10.37708/ezs.swu.bg.v20i1.21

2022-02-10

Abstract:The article is devoted to the study of gender in the works of the German writer Hermann Hesse, in particular the gender roles and archetypes of anima and animus traced in characters of his novels. During the research, the role of the androgynous personality in society has been clarified. The anima and animus as the most important definitions in gender studies are singled out from the general system of archetypes by Carl Gustav Jung. Features and ways of synthesis of masculine and feminine principles in the human psyche are characterized. The analysis of the works of Hermann Hesse includes the novels “Demian” (1919) and “Narcissus and Goldmund” (1930). With the definition of the concepts, the presence of elements of the psychoanalysis theory and gender studies in the works of Hermann Hesse has been proved. The characters of the novel have been analyzed and characterized in terms of masculinity and femininity. Due to this research, we have been able to clearly define the system of images from the perspective of gender, which makes it possible to use literary works in gender issues more confidently and to characterize the writing activity in a more structured way against the background of gender studies.
From sacred geometry to an old man: on the figure of the Father in Dante’s Divine Comedy and in Michelangelo’s Sistine Chapel

József Pál

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11059-022-00636-y

2022-04-10

Neohelicon

Abstract:Abstract Dante was exempt from the 15–16th century Renaissance humanists’ general distrust of the medieval heritage. Among many other factors, one reason for this was the experience of shared Florentine pride and destiny. In his time, Michelangelo was considered one of the best-qualified Dante-experts. Already in his lifetime (and with his knowledge), the literature began to thoroughly explore the influence of his predecessor on Michelangelo’s sculptures, paintings and poems. The paper discusses a new aspect of this influence. It seeks an answer to the question of how the representations of God can nevertheless be radically different in the Commedia and the ceiling fresco of the Sistine Chapel. How sacred geometry (the circles of the Trinity) is transformed into a vigorous old man, who directs the events of the creation like an aerial acrobat. The answer may be found in the Platonic theology and cosmology of Ficino’s Academy, which is the continuation of the Christian trend represented by Dionysius the Areopagite and Eriugena. The Father is in motion because, along with the world and man, He also creates himself; in contrast with the “outsider” claim of ego dominus et non mutor ; he is also part of the “concert”.
THE IMAGE OF THE DEACON IN THE RUSSIAN LITERATURE OF THE SECOND HALF OF THE 19TH CENTURY — EARLY 20TH CENTURY, AS ASSESSED BY THE CLERICAL JOURNALISM

Aleksandr Nikolaevich Rozov,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31860/0131-6095-2023-2-118-127

2023-01-01

Russkaya Literatura

Abstract:The article examines the works of the writers of the 19–20th centuries, where various types of deacons are represented, assessed either as positive or as negative types by the clerical criticism. The images of the deacons did not reflect the sophisticated reality of clerical practices. Still, literary works familiarized the wider readership with these practices. Clerical critics analyzed the respective works from the religious and moral point of view, and modern literary scholars do not always fully take this into account.
Ivan Karamazov’s Poem “The Grand Inquisitor”: Dostoevsky’s Response to the Protest of Archimandrite Theodore (A.M. Bukharev)

Konstantin A. Barsht,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21146/0042-8744-2022-9-161-172

2022-01-01

Voprosy filosofii

Abstract:The article suggests that the chapter “The Grand Inquisitor” in F.M. Dostoevsky’s novel “The Brothers Karamazov”, which raises the question of the necessity/undesirability of strict administration in the field of church and social life, is a reflection of the views of Archimandrite Theodore (A.M. Bukharev), for his protests against the infringement of the human right to choose a religious model and social freedom subjected to bullying by conservative circles. In a number of his books throughout the 1860s Bukharev insisted on the need to abandon authoritarianism, he questioned the inviolability of church dogmas in favor of a free spiritual search of a person not constrained by restrictions. Contemporaries, including A.I. Herzen, commenting on this issue, spoke of Bukharev’s persecutors from the Synod and the “Domashnaya beseda” magazine (The Home Conversation) as “inquisitors” who dealt with the philosopher in the same way as the Spanish religious police did. Bukharev’s main idea was the need for the country and the whole world to move from the generally accepted Old Testament model of political and trade relations between people based on the idea of “an eye for an eye” to benevolent positive ties based on the principle of brotherly love, commanded by Jesus Christ. Dostoevsky laid this idea at the foundation of the ideology of “pochvennichestvo”, as was reported in the “Announcement” about the publication of the magazine “Time”, the organ of the socio-cultural project created by him. The motives and the basic structure of Bukharev’s logic, the idea of the saving power of Christian love, were used by Dostoevsky in all his works written after Bukharev’s death. It was used with the greatest force in the novel “The Brothers Karamazov” for modern readers at the level of hidden allusion, and for contemporaries it was done in the form of an open allusion.
Dante’s and Solovyov’s Apocalyptic Images as Stylistic Counterpoints in the Era of Change

Y.K. Volkov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17588/2076-9210.2022.1.055-066

2022-03-30

Solov’evskie issledovaniya

Abstract:Following the example of Dante’s apocalyptic images in the “Divine Comedy” and Vladimir Solovyov’s “A Short Story of Antichrist”, this article takes into consideration the ideological and artistic elements of the counterpoint – the latter being meant as a simultaneous confrontation and combination of styles from different historical epochs. For this purpose, a given stylistic version of the cross-cultural method is adopted. As a result of it, the author demonstrates that the “Divine Comedy” belongs to the Italian proto-Renaissance style, in which, along with the traditions of medieval culture, the stylistic features of Renaissance and Modern times are forming. The conclusion is that the authorial style of Dante’s eschatology is the style of the prophet and judge of humanity who proclaims the continuation of its eternal life. In the same way, the authorial strategy of Solovyov’s last work may be also attributed to a stylization of the prophetic genre that was typical of the Russian culture of the late 19th and early 20th century. Despite all this, Solovyov’s apocalyptic images do not have a clearly formulated idea concerning the coming salvation – which should be mandatory for the Christian eschatology, – but they only formulate in a new way a prediction regarding the inevitable continuation of great wars, coups and civil strives on the path leading to the end of history. In this transitional stage full of malice, lies and deceit, only the traditional Christian ideal of unselfish love and spiritual unity, which Solovyov employs within the framework of a new artistic style, is endowed with the ability to preserve its timeless value. The overall result of the comparison of the historical style of John’s Revelation with the two subsequent stylizations of apocalyptic images is a confirmation of the existence of a cultural self-development that manifests itself in the iconic works of the era of change.
Observing and mirroring secularity from divinity: Another interpretation of the duality of Dante's Divine Comedy

Jiang Cheng

Abstract:As "the last poet of the Middle Ages," Dante Alighieri is of summary significance to the old era; moreover, standing on the ground of the "divine" Christian culture of the old era, he foresees the dawn of the new era He initiates humanism, but he does not affirm it blindly; instead, he uses the reasonable humane factors existing in the Christian culture to standardize and judge the individual freedom and even human desires for indulgence. Therefore, Dante is great as "the first poet of the Middle Ages" and a forerunner of humanism, and he is also "the last poet" who "observes and mirrors divinity from secularity

Philosophy
A Student that Has the Right: The Collective Anti-Raskolnikov in Donna Tartt's The Secret History

Nina S Ishchenko,Lugansk State Pedagogical University,Nina S. Ishchenko,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22455/2619-0311-2022-3-147-158

2022-01-01

Abstract:The paper focuses on Dostoevsky’s influence in D. Tartt’s novel The Secret History. The author shows how the main plot collisions of Crime and Punishment are inverted in the book of the American writer. The character of the book is the collective antagonist of Raskolnikov who recognizes the right to kill. The Übermensch is portrayed in the novel as the impeccable rationalist Mycroft Holmes. The spiritual force that guides Tartt’s characters on the path of transformation into an Übermensch is the pagan god Dionysus, to whom the students go to kill. The novel shows the self-destruction of a murderer who refused to see a person in his victim. The author’s voice in the novel is designed on the model of Dostoevsky’s poetics, using the reception of strange phrases uttered by the hero for no reason, as it happens during the wake with the family of a murdered student. At this moment, a phrase pops up in Richard’s head by itself: “It was I who killed the old woman and her sister Lizaveta with an axe and robbed her”. This phrase of Raskolnikov is a brief synopsis of the plot of Crime and Punishment. In Donna Tartt’s novel, this phrase expresses the author’s position, the author’s explanation of what is happening in the book: other characters in another world repeat Raskolnikov’s fate, and the author shows what this leads to. Raskolnikov managed to escape by converting to Christ and accepting his human nature. Donna Tartt’s Übermensch could not be saved, because instead of Christ he communicated with Dionysus. Taking communion with Dionysus in the ancient ritual of homophagy, students go to murder. The novel shows the self-destruction of all five murderers who refused to see a person in their victim: suicide (Henry), suicide attempt (Francis), alcohol and drugs up to complete desocialization (Charles), selfpunishment in the form of rejection of the joys of life and communication with people (Camilla), loneliness (Richard). Thus, Donna Tartt proves from the opposite the same idea that Dostoevsky expressed in his Orthodox novel: every life is priceless, murder destroys people and the world.
Existential and psychological grounds of criminal behavior of the heroes of Mikhail Lermontov and Fyodor Dostoevsky

Lev Olegovich Mysovskikh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.25136/2409-8698.2023.7.38571

2023-07-01

Litera

Abstract:In the article, through the prism of the philosophy of existentialism and social psychology, the prerequisites of the criminal behavior of the main characters of the novels by Mikhail Lermontov "Hero of Our Time" and Fyodor Dostoevsky "Crime and Punishment" – Grigory Pechorin and Rodion Raskolnikov are investigated. The author of the article claims that the reasons for the criminal behavior of both Pechorin and Raskolnikov are intrapersonal. However, the personal characteristics of an individual are formed under the influence of the society in which he exists, which is demonstrated by the example of the main characters of the novels of Lermontov and Dostoevsky. Thus, the article clearly shows the main principle of the philosophy of existentialism in action: the existence of a person precedes his essence. The author of the article comes to the conclusion that Pechorin and Raskolnikov have many similar character traits, and the main difference between them lies in the social status of the characters. In both novels, the writers decry the vices of Russian class society. The author of the article summarizes that from the point of view of religious existentialism, Pechorin's fate is much more gloomy than Raskolnikov's fate, since Pechorin's soul is taken away by an all-consuming nothingness, while Raskolnikov's soul gets a chance for salvation. Dostoevsky's heroes always have hope, because God shows them the way by which a person can come to grace. This is where the main difference between Lermontov and Dostoevsky lies.

Концепт «сверхчеловек» и демонические герои Достоевского в русской эссеистике Cеребряного века

THE PRINCIPLE OF DOMINANCE IN THE CHARACTERS OF THE NOVEL “DEMONS” BY F. M. DOSTOEVSKY (IN LIGHT OF THE ETHICAL TEACHINGS OF A. A. UKHTOMSKY)

Lermontov and Vrubel's Demon Images

F. M. Dostoevsky – great human-lover, expert in human, well-wisher of human, sage and visionary

“Sacred horror” of the poet Gavriil Romanovich Derzhavin

Dämonisch, das Dämonische (Daemonic, the Daemonic)

ANTHROPOSOPY OF LEO TOLSTOY: SPIRIT, SOUL AND BODY

The image of the "demon Lord" in Japanese fantasy: traditions, formality, originality

Non-Euclidean Geometries as a Source of Faith in God for F.M. Dostoevsky and His Characters (on the Example of Ivan Karamazov)

Personocentrism in classical Russian literature of the XIX century. Dialectics of Artistic Consciousness

Modern Inspiration of Demonology:from the Perspective of Christian Philosophy

THE FUNCTION OF THE DEVIL IN CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION: “THE BROTHERS KARAMAZOV” AND THE SERIES “LUCIFER” BY NETFLIX

Traditions of F.M. Dostoevsky in the prose of modern spiritual writers

GENDER AND ARCHETYPE AS COMPONENTS OF THE CHARACTER ANALYSIS IN “DEMIAN” AND “NARCISSUS AND GOLDMUND” BY HERMANN HESSE

From sacred geometry to an old man: on the figure of the Father in Dante’s Divine Comedy and in Michelangelo’s Sistine Chapel

THE IMAGE OF THE DEACON IN THE RUSSIAN LITERATURE OF THE SECOND HALF OF THE 19TH CENTURY — EARLY 20TH CENTURY, AS ASSESSED BY THE CLERICAL JOURNALISM

Ivan Karamazov’s Poem “The Grand Inquisitor”: Dostoevsky’s Response to the Protest of Archimandrite Theodore (A.M. Bukharev)

Dante’s and Solovyov’s Apocalyptic Images as Stylistic Counterpoints in the Era of Change

Observing and mirroring secularity from divinity: Another interpretation of the duality of Dante's Divine Comedy

A Student that Has the Right: The Collective Anti-Raskolnikov in Donna Tartt's The Secret History

Existential and psychological grounds of criminal behavior of the heroes of Mikhail Lermontov and Fyodor Dostoevsky